50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mercer Island

“Great place pizza is amazing, and garlic twists are recommended 100% good prices and the staff are very nice people just great place overall“

“Great spot! Enjoyed Happy Hour very much. Aperol Spritz, Margherita Pizza, Arugula Salad & House Red Wine all great! Service was excellent and attentive. Will be back for sure.“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“Authentic, fresh, and entirely delicious. The homemade cannelloni pasta noodles and filling were absolute perfection! Fantastic marinara! And the pizza… amazing. So much for leftovers! And I haven’t even mentioned the kindness of all of the staff. Can’t wait to come back to this gem!“

“Such. Good. Pizza. We arrived at 4 on a Friday afternoon at opening and seating was full by 5 (indoor and out). Just a note if you're looking to sit - there are not a ton of tables. Service was incredibly friendly, pizza was fantastic. We ordered the Chicago and the Plain Jane for kiddos (who then ended up eating the Chicago, too). 2 pizzas for 2 adults + 2 kids were actually just right and we even took home some leftovers.“

“We've been searching for a pizza place that has pies that are crispy (or at least not soggy) in the middle. We ordered a whole sausage pizza and a slice of the pepperoni. Sausage was very soggy in the middle, outer crust was good though, crispy and soft. Sausage was pretty spicy and some of the broccoli rabe on it was bitter. The pepperoni was typical in taste and center crust was better and didn't droop when picked up. We had the chopped salad which was pretty tasty. It wasn't as chopped up as other chopped salads that I've had; more like a regular salad. I had the Japanese Slipper cocktail which was very good and my husband had a beer. Our bill was over $80, so a bit pricey for a pizza lunch. Service was order at the bar and they bring food/drinks out to you where seating is open, so not full service. Street parking in the area was hard to find. We ended up parking in a pay lot on N 35th St. and walking through AB Ernst Park and down some stairs to Tivoli.“

“Easily the best hoagie in the PNW. Don’t sleep on the slices either.“

“The best pizza in Seattle. We had the Mushroom Pizza and the Broccoli. Driving from Burien to Leschi on a Friday night and it was well worth it. this is our new pizza spot.“

“Delicious Pizza!! They grabbed me with the deep dish style pizza. i started following their Instagram so i could see what was going on. over the last few years i would order a pizza from them when in the area… a few special trips just because. Now just recently I started seeing Tavern Style pizza show up on the instagram. Started with photos from other places and then Windy City pie puts tavern on their menu! i wanted to try it since it became available and finally decided to make it part of my pre game for a saturday Mariners game. if thin crisp crust is not your thing then stick with the deep dish! it continues to amaze! If you like the thin crisp pizza try the tavern. it is not just any pizza it is special. the crust is thin uniform and crisp through out the pizza. the toppings are high quality and the sauce is something out of this world! I ate about half and took the rest home to share with my wife. thought i would be able to share our reheat but it didn’t get past the cold pizza phase… this has to be the very best cold pizza i can remember! So good we didn’t take the time to heat back up we just downed it! Check them out! really great pizza on 2 ends of the pizza spectrum!“

“Great food and great service. Our little is already asking to go back. She loved her ceaser salad and Chocolate cookie and said she really liked our waiter, he was funny.“

“I love this place. Their pizzas are always an original take on some traditional pies. The garlic butter rub they do on the crust is phenomenal. If you take the time to grab a drink before taking a pie, the bar staff is so friendly. Don’t pass over Ananas. It’s a beautiful diamond in the rough.“

“Amazing Vegan 🌱 BBQ 🍕 and ranch dressing.“

“Super delicious, fresh and hot pizza 🍕 ❤️👌🏼👍🏼love it ❤️“

“Olympia pizza is how our family celebrates a great day!“

“Absolutely love this place 💖
Thier desi - indian styled pizzas are absolutely yumm and I keep coming back for them!

P.s. - they will give you a free dessert whole you are waiting for your food! 😋“

“Stumbled upon Slicebox the other day having driven past it on my daily commute. Being from Upstate NY I was quite impressed with the quality of the slices. From NY Slices to Sicilian and Pan Pizza. The pan pizza was amazing with pepperoni and hot honey!“

“They make some of the best pizza in Seattle, and honestly some of the best pizza I've had anywhere! Delicious sauce, great crust, toppings are excellent - best lunch is a couple of slices + a cookie and a Mannies :D“

“We came here with another couple for dinner. We had the apples & Brie appetizer and shared 2 pizzas. Everything was delicious and the service was great! The vibes in the place were great too. I definitely recommend this restaurant for a casual dinner.“

“wonderful and affordable pizza.“

“6 times a truth full 😘😗“

“We are visiting for a game. Half the excitement is trying something new! What a unique and exquisite place! We will be back!“

“They had delicious pizza and drinks!“

“The pizzas were just awesome!!!
Ordered for a party… Tandoori paneer pizza, and cheese pizza - former was a hit with the grown-ups, and the kiddos loved the latter.
If you’ve ordered from CanAm before, these ones are on the same lines, but feel lighter, and just the right punch of flavor.
The only thing I’d suggest is to let the folks know of your spice level preference - the default spice levels on the indian pizzas maybe on slightly higher side, which I am sure they can adjust per your order.
Loved the fresh ingredients, freshly baked dough, just the right amount of cheese/spice blend, and on-time service.
Definitely ordering again when in Bellevue!“

“Really down to earth good people excellent food excellent service and really cares about humanity will definitely recommend and return!“

“I moved out of the area about 10-12 years ago. Back in the area for a while. Was driving down willows RD and saw the sign. Stopped in and grabbed one. Still amazing pizza and loved it!“

“The service is excellent and the ambiance can't be beat for an outdoor street side restaurant. The food is the real attraction though, ESPECIALLY on Sundays when the offer their special 18" New York Style pizza which I can say is on par if not better than some of the best NY Style Pizzas that even NY City offers!!!“

“Highly recommend making a reservation. Staff here was very friendly, engaging and funny. We did not have a reservation but they sat us outside with a friend's stroller/baby in tow.

We ordered the caramelized carrots, the sauce from the carrots was amazing added to every pizza we ordered.

The siliccsa pizza was great and the pistachio pizza was a surprise hit. We loved everything we ordered.“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“6 times a truth full 😘😗“

“There’s so much I appreciate about this place. The pizza is delicious - some of the best counter service by the slice pizza in the city. The owner and the employees are super nice, and they’re often the only spot still open in the neighborhood.“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“My wife and I regularly order from here and absolutely love it! If you enjoy Indian food and want to try pizza with a fantastic Indian twist, this is the perfect spot. The flavors are incredibly tasty. Our absolute favorite is the achari paneer pizza, and the tandoori paneer is a very close second. Highly recommend checking them out!“

“Pizza Gallery in Burien makes some of the best Hawaiian pizza I’ve ever had. The combination pizza is just as impressive—packed with flavor, well-balanced toppings, and cooked perfectly. Both pizzas are easily some of the best I’ve had, and I can honestly eat the whole thing, including the crust, because it’s that good.

What really stands out is the care they put into the food. The young gentlemen preparing the pizzas are clearly making everything with attention and pride. You can taste that “made with love” quality in every bite.

The only downside is there are no tables to eat inside and no restroom for customers, but I understand that might be how they keep the prices reasonable for everyone. I also had a great experience with the staff—a young Asian lady helped me (I forgot to ask her name), and she was very friendly and awesome to deal with.“

“We've had several excellent dining experiences at Prosecco since they opened. Everything we've ordered has been delicious, pizza is amazing! Service has been very good. Indoor and outdoor seating both comfortable.“

“I’ve been coming here forever with my parents and it’s our go-to! The Greek spaghetti and tiramisu will never let me down and is my usual! I love that they extended their hours on the weekends for some great late night food! Everyone’s so friendly and welcoming!“

“Great service and phenomenal food! The best wood fired pizza anywhere!“

“Stevie's is amazing! Hands down the best pizza around. Delicious sauce, cheese, and most importantly perfect crust. I love the cheese, pepperoni, and sausage pizzas.

I've been coming here for years - dine in, take out, delivery. Service has been getting better and better throughout the years.

My only complaint is that I wish they brought in a weekly or monthly special pizza more often.“

“Yes! Do it! Can’t go wrong with yummy pizza! 10 out of 10! Thanks 💕🌈🫶🏻🍕🍹“

“Cute little pizzeria. I think it's family owned and operated. The pizza is absolutely delicious. We usually aren't huge fans of wood fired pizza, but this crust was cooked to perfection. It had a great flavor and chew and it wasn't burnt at all. We were only given our waters and never got our drinks we ordered, but there was a large family there who were monopolizing the servers time. Cool place!“

“Love everybody there. Great environment to watch my Cardinals games. 👏 customer service is outstanding“

“Our meal at Cinque Terre was amazing. That was seriously some of the best pesto I've ever had. My husband's boar pasta had plenty of meat in the sauce. The pasta was fresh. And they even had some good mocktails - as a non-drinker, I appreciate when a restaurant takes the time to create drinks that make me feel welcomed. The atmosphere was peaceful - not too loud in any way. I would absolutely recommend this place“

“Amazing pizzzza. Great service thank you“

“We were a party of 6 for a birthday celebration. The staff made sure we were well taken care of. Everyone loved the food and the ambiance and had a wonderful evening. Thank you!“

“I got one of each of the slices, the “Coppa” was 🔥🔥🔥. Priced fair and definitely worth the money, loved how crispy it was. As someone that likes to cut their pizza, I wish they had real silverware because it made it hard to do so on paper plates. That being said, I certainly understand using disposable items and don’t hold it against them. I wanted to try the ice cream, next time, I definitely look forward to returning.“

“Fantastic pizza in a chill environment. I’d call it Neapolitan-American fusion in the best way. Not too soft, not too crunchy… just right with a nice bit of rustic char. The toppings were creative and generous, and the service was excellent too! Will def be back.“

“All around great experience! Wonderful staff and excellent pies!“

“Zachary was such a lovely bartender last night. Really saved my life by teaching me how to balance my checkbook and invest in the proper kind of crypto. Not that fake grifter kind of crypto. A real blessing and denpa antenna. I am going to name my first born after this guy, absolute angel and PRO!!!!! at what he does.

((((Edit after my girlfriend corrected me. His name wasnt Zachary. His name was Robert))))“

“Waiter forgot to put in one persons order but there was enough food without it“

“Hands down best pizza in Seattle“

“Best pizza on Earth IMO! Super friendly staff!“