50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mercer Island

“Great place pizza is amazing, and garlic twists are recommended 100% good prices and the staff are very nice people just great place overall“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“Great spot! Enjoyed Happy Hour very much. Aperol Spritz, Margherita Pizza, Arugula Salad & House Red Wine all great! Service was excellent and attentive. Will be back for sure.“

“Authentic, fresh, and entirely delicious. The homemade cannelloni pasta noodles and filling were absolute perfection! Fantastic marinara! And the pizza… amazing. So much for leftovers! And I haven’t even mentioned the kindness of all of the staff. Can’t wait to come back to this gem!“

“Easily the best hoagie in the PNW. Don’t sleep on the slices either.“

“We hosted out engagement party at My Friend Derek's and it could not have gone any better!!!!! Not only is this some of the best pizza in Seattle, the staff took exceptionally good care of us. It felt like the pizza was endless, and they made so many off menu fun pizzas for us. The drinks were amazing (spritzes, natural wine, craft beer) and the vibes were top tier. Our guests had an absolute blast.“

“Delicious Pizza!! They grabbed me with the deep dish style pizza. i started following their Instagram so i could see what was going on. over the last few years i would order a pizza from them when in the area… a few special trips just because. Now just recently I started seeing Tavern Style pizza show up on the instagram. Started with photos from other places and then Windy City pie puts tavern on their menu! i wanted to try it since it became available and finally decided to make it part of my pre game for a saturday Mariners game. if thin crisp crust is not your thing then stick with the deep dish! it continues to amaze! If you like the thin crisp pizza try the tavern. it is not just any pizza it is special. the crust is thin uniform and crisp through out the pizza. the toppings are high quality and the sauce is something out of this world! I ate about half and took the rest home to share with my wife. thought i would be able to share our reheat but it didn’t get past the cold pizza phase… this has to be the very best cold pizza i can remember! So good we didn’t take the time to heat back up we just downed it! Check them out! really great pizza on 2 ends of the pizza spectrum!“

“Our meal at Cinque Terre was amazing. That was seriously some of the best pesto I've ever had. My husband's boar pasta had plenty of meat in the sauce. The pasta was fresh. And they even had some good mocktails - as a non-drinker, I appreciate when a restaurant takes the time to create drinks that make me feel welcomed. The atmosphere was peaceful - not too loud in any way. I would absolutely recommend this place“

“We hosted a private event at Tivoli and would highly recommend it to folks looking for a casual, fun atmosphere to celebrate. The planning process was very easy and relaxed. Ed, Cassie, and the team were very communicative and made themselves available for all the questions we had. Our event was lovely - all the guests had a great time, and the food was amazing. We were very well taken care of and had a ton of fun.“

“They make some of the best pizza in Seattle, and honestly some of the best pizza I've had anywhere! Delicious sauce, great crust, toppings are excellent - best lunch is a couple of slices + a cookie and a Mannies :D“

“We are visiting for a game. Half the excitement is trying something new! What a unique and exquisite place! We will be back!“

“Amazing Vegan 🌱 BBQ 🍕 and ranch dressing.“

“Stumbled upon Slicebox the other day having driven past it on my daily commute. Being from Upstate NY I was quite impressed with the quality of the slices. From NY Slices to Sicilian and Pan Pizza. The pan pizza was amazing with pepperoni and hot honey!“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“A warm intimate atmosphere with an open flame pizza oven invites you in. But you will stay, enjoying the staff, the people ,and the beautifully crafted food. Even a basic pepperoni and olive pizza will change your attitude about what a pizza should be forever!“

“The best pizza in Seattle. We had the Mushroom Pizza and the Broccoli. Driving from Burien to Leschi on a Friday night and it was well worth it. this is our new pizza spot.“

“Best pizza I’ve had in the US. We actually ate so much it was ridiculous ;) The mushroom and fontina is insanely good. Well, so are the others. And yes, I was invited there and got to learn about pizza, the dough is a wonder. Gave me a whole new guiding light for what it should be like!“

“Chicken sandwich is so good! House made sauce 👌 simple and delivious. Owner is so sweet and cares deeply about service & his customers. New to the u district area support and show love !“

“Great food and great service. Our little is already asking to go back. She loved her ceaser salad and Chocolate cookie and said she really liked our waiter, he was funny.“

“Fun hole-in-the-wall that serves great tasting pizza with quick, attentive service. We ate the vegan pie (delicious!!) and built our own (yummy). Also had spring mix and Caesar side salads - large, fresh, and well-prepared. Skip the marinara extra sauce - it is served cold and isn’t very tasty. (I love marina sauce, so I was disappointed). Everything else A+. We will definitely be back!“

“Took the family for a nice lunch - had Mediterranean shrimp, chicken fettuccine and pizza. Food was amazing and service exceptional, will def be coming back !“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“I moved out of the area about 10-12 years ago. Back in the area for a while. Was driving down willows RD and saw the sign. Stopped in and grabbed one. Still amazing pizza and loved it!“

“They had delicious pizza and drinks!“

“We happened upon the Diller room on our way back from Pikes Place market … what an unexpected but fantastic stop! If you love bourbon (and we DO) this lovely historic bar is a must visit. The bottle selection is exceptional, and Shawn our bartender provided great pours and the most welcoming attitude despite how busy he was!! A true gem of an experience in the emerald city!“

“I come in fairly often for pickup as I live right by. Great wings and some of the best crust in Seattle. That is one thing I've noticed, most pizza joints have mediocre crust or worse. Nice atmosphere. Some employees are more friendly then others. But, the kitchen staff always does a good job. Wish they had a pesto, green olive and feta pizza. But, I don't think that is their direction. Some of the Lao inspired ones are very nice and unique. Decent drink assortment and full bar. Reasonable prices. I would come into the bar more if they had better Absinthe, like a Jade or Vieux Pontarlier. That would fit thier aesthetic more. But, they obviously know what they are doing. Glad to see them be busy.

All in all 4 to 4.5, and a repeat customer.“

“wonderful and affordable pizza.“

“All around great experience! Wonderful staff and excellent pies!“

“Really down to earth good people excellent food excellent service and really cares about humanity will definitely recommend and return!“

“6 times a truth full 😘😗“

“Great service and phenomenal food! The best wood fired pizza anywhere!“

“Super delicious, fresh and hot pizza 🍕 ❤️👌🏼👍🏼love it ❤️“

“For over 20 years we have enjoyed every meal on the menu. They are the only restaurant that I know that make their own pastas, sauces, bread, and desserts. What a difference that makes. Everything is fresh tasting and satisfying. The meatballs are so light and tasty, eat them slowly to enjoy every bite. Not only are their pastas and pizzas delicious so are their appetizers. I love how they roast their eggplant and they serve it in an incredibly rich tomato sauce with Gorgonzola on the side. Their steak is cooked to perfection with an amazing sauce, a grilled pepper, onion, and their incredible handcut shoestring fries that are to die for!! Enjoy“

“The service is excellent and the ambiance can't be beat for an outdoor street side restaurant. The food is the real attraction though, ESPECIALLY on Sundays when the offer their special 18" New York Style pizza which I can say is on par if not better than some of the best NY Style Pizzas that even NY City offers!!!“

“One of our regular go-to pizza by-the-slice spots. Today the specials were extra exciting, but love how there is always a veggie option. Also great that you can now get Normie's on any slice. Caesar is also excellent if you want an infusion of more veggies. Quick in and out, come as you are and always leave full and happy. Cheat code is that you can take your pizza to Logan's for great beer.“

“Pizza Gallery in Burien makes some of the best Hawaiian pizza I’ve ever had. The combination pizza is just as impressive—packed with flavor, well-balanced toppings, and cooked perfectly. Both pizzas are easily some of the best I’ve had, and I can honestly eat the whole thing, including the crust, because it’s that good.

What really stands out is the care they put into the food. The young gentlemen preparing the pizzas are clearly making everything with attention and pride. You can taste that “made with love” quality in every bite.

The only downside is there are no tables to eat inside and no restroom for customers, but I understand that might be how they keep the prices reasonable for everyone. I also had a great experience with the staff—a young Asian lady helped me (I forgot to ask her name), and she was very friendly and awesome to deal with.“

“Came in late Friday night. Idk what it was but the folks working seemed in great spirits. Just genuinely chill peeps.

Pizza was also pretty good. I had a few slices, one of which was vegan with ravioli. Obviously vegan pizza isn’t quite as good as regular, but when you’ve never had ravioli on pizza you gotta give it a try. Tbh would consider again and I’m not even vegan.“

“Fantastic food & service with a warm cozy atmosphere!“

“The vibes are immaculate. The interior is gorgeous, the staff were super great and so sweet with my kids, the entire menu looks delicious. I’m so excited y’all are back. ❤️❤️“

“Drew and his team were great. Tasty food and excellent service! Cozy little spot and nice vibe.“

“Amazing local pizza place! Authentic food, fast service and a nice vibe!“

“6 times a truth full 😘😗“

“We stumbled upon this place after a night of thrifting and truly couldn’t have been happier. The ingredients are super fresh, you can tell they take a lot of care when it comes to the products they use and the staff is friendly and accommodating. They also make the pizza pretty much right in front of you and our kids couldn’t have loved it more. even in the rain it was a mood.Will definitely be back!“

“My wife and I regularly order from here and absolutely love it! If you enjoy Indian food and want to try pizza with a fantastic Indian twist, this is the perfect spot. The flavors are incredibly tasty. Our absolute favorite is the achari paneer pizza, and the tandoori paneer is a very close second. Highly recommend checking them out!“

“I have ordered from Z's Pizza several times now, and they never disappoint. Their butter chicken pizza is an absolute masterpiece, the chicken is incredibly moist and flavorful, and the sauce is perfectly seasoned.What really sets them apart is the dough. Even with all those rich toppings, the crust remains soft, light, and perfectly baked with just the right amount of structure.
If you are looking for incredible flavor and a flawless crust, this is the spot to visit in Bellevue!“

“Great food and beer... amazing service!“

“ALL the food was delicious 😋“

“Best pizzas 🍕 and martini’s 🍸 Nash is one of the best bartenders in town, total customer service, always has a contagious smile!“

“This was such an odd experience. We went there after the edmonds Halloween event and it was really awesome how they were involved. The pizza was great (they need the moisture sheet on the pan so it doesn't get soggy though). The server wasn't unfriendly, but she wasn't really friendly either. $14 for a kids pizza is insane and $14 dollars for a tiny little hot toddy is even more insane. The price of the regular pizza was ok but the rest was unbelievable. Lol, $14 for a tiny bit of whiskey, hot water, honey, and lemon?! What cost to much? The electricity to heat the water? Also, 3% to use my credit card? No. That's gas station bs. I don't go to businesses who charge me to pay them. This is the cost of doing business. If your merchant services cost too much, that's on you to find a better company, not my responsibility to pay for you.“

“We've had several excellent dining experiences at Prosecco since they opened. Everything we've ordered has been delicious, pizza is amazing! Service has been very good. Indoor and outdoor seating both comfortable.“