50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mercer Island

“Great place pizza is amazing, and garlic twists are recommended 100% good prices and the staff are very nice people just great place overall“

“Great spot! Enjoyed Happy Hour very much. Aperol Spritz, Margherita Pizza, Arugula Salad & House Red Wine all great! Service was excellent and attentive. Will be back for sure.“

“Jennifer a Is the best ..“

“one of the best pizzas ive ever had, it was delivered fast and hot“

“I love the pizza’s thin crust! The spices in the sauce are just right with just enough cheese! And, the service is always great.“

“Authentic, fresh, and entirely delicious. The homemade cannelloni pasta noodles and filling were absolute perfection! Fantastic marinara! And the pizza… amazing. So much for leftovers! And I haven’t even mentioned the kindness of all of the staff. Can’t wait to come back to this gem!“

“Easily the best hoagie in the PNW. Don’t sleep on the slices either.“

“SO happy these guys are in the neighborhood! Their food is delish and the vibe is the best. I haven't been a "regular" at a place in well over a decade but my boyfriend and I stop in here at least once a week for the tasty food & drinks AND the awesome staff.
Sirin is an absolute gem, Colin and Donald are pretty fantastic and everyone else is top notch. They create the kind of atmosphere you want to come back to again and again. Love!“

“Had a nice time at Tivoli. We decided to visit while waiting for an event nearby and tried several appetizers. Everything was definitely solid, although I thought it was a bit overpriced for what you get. Drinks were tasty and vibes relaxing however.“

“I've lived here for a year now and finally found the best pizza in First/Capitol Hill! I'm a regular cheese eater, and their pizza is top notch. Just enough of the NY style I'm looking for. The sauce has a delicious slight tang to it, seasoned well, and great crust. I don't always eat the crust, but on these I do! Will probably eat here once a month from now on.“

“The service is excellent and the ambiance can't be beat for an outdoor street side restaurant. The food is the real attraction though, ESPECIALLY on Sundays when the offer their special 18" New York Style pizza which I can say is on par if not better than some of the best NY Style Pizzas that even NY City offers!!!“

“Oh My Goodness! Seattle born & I thought you closed the doors years ago & have been missing you soooo much ever since. Wow! You are alive & well Alibi. I'm aghast. Can't wait to see you. Love You, Miss You, You're Here! (how often does that happen?) Good Day & See You Super Soon :)“

“Pizza Gallery rocks my world EVERY TIME!
The staff is super friendly ( and quick! )! The pizza is amazing AND for the price i feel like the servings are pretty generous! If you’re still not convinced… just DO IT! ? ?

Dietary restrictions: I am a vegetarian and have never had a problem finding options here!“

“We had a great experience. The staff was so friendly and accommodating. Our pizzas were very fresh and the funghi pizza was excellent. We got to try an "orange" wine and it was different but very light and actually got rid of my headache. Nice folks.“

“They had delicious pizza and drinks!“

“Outstanding Pizza, easy to see why it's top 10 in Seattle“

“The best!...Good food,friendly hosts!“

“Best of the best. Love it.“

“Lee and the crew at Moto are simply amazing! When i showed up, Lee greeted me and thanked me for supporting them and we shot the shi* a couple minutes since i had got their a few min early. To have the #6 best pizza in the country, he is very humble and caring. The attention to detail and customer service is superb. We got three pies last night (Clam Chowda, Chop and Kissd) and they were fantastic! Next week we get the crab and Mr Pig! It’s worth the wait to get an order in!“

“Went back to Redmond for a work trip and made sure to stop by, and it tasted just as good as before we left in 2018. Thank you Aaron for a great night. Hope we see Zaucer Pizza in the Dallas Metroplex soon.“

“Fantastic food & service with a warm cozy atmosphere!“

“Great food, tasty drinks, excellent service! Had the caesar salad, peperonata (that sauce was on point!) shared a pizza- great crust and toppings, shared some spaghetti n meatballs…not like what your mama used to make. My old fashioned was perfectly balanced. The staff was very friendly and attentive. Give this place a shot if you haven’t!“

“Best pizza on Earth IMO! Super friendly staff!“

“Easily the best pizza in Seattle. I've lived here a long time and there is plenty of good pizza. Big Mario for example is very solid pizza. I know em from cap hill but they recently opened a location across the street. You won't have a bad time there no doubt.

But Proletariat is truly great. No gimmicks, they do everything by the book and just say we'll do the basics better than anyone else.

I'd wager to find a better pizza you'll need to hop on a plane.“

“Best pizza in Seattle by far and I went to alot of restaurants“

“Unfortunately a lot of people only leave reviews when they have a negative experience, and I'm guilty of this. Not today. Suffice to say, the slice I got (Normie MacDonald, with some added burrata on top) was so good I just HAD to leave a review. I'm something of a pizza snob, and Stevie's exceeded my expectations. Granted, from my experience the PNW isn't known for its pizza excellence, but I have to say Stevie's is a welcome outlier. I'll definitely be coming back!

Edit: Having come here a couple of times, I do believe Stevie's serves the best pizza in the state of Washington.“

“Great food and great service. Our little is already asking to go back. She loved her ceaser salad and Chocolate cookie and said she really liked our waiter, he was funny.“

“Amazing pizzzza. Great service thank you“

“Really down to earth good people excellent food excellent service and really cares about humanity will definitely recommend and return!“

“Olympia pizza is how our family celebrates a great day!“

“I LOVE THE FOOD HERE. Like I have gone to places where meh breakfast food is over $100 for 4/family, but the prices are reasonable/great for the delicious food. The servings are great here and the pizza is amazing. Please support this cool small business!!“

“Mercato Stellina Pizzeria is one of our favorite neighborhood spots, and we’ve been here several times. The food is consistently excellent, and the waiters are always friendly, adding to the warm and cozy atmosphere.

It’s a small, intimate place that gives off a great local vibe. The Pomodoro Pizza and Roasted Delicata Squash we had this time were fantastic, with authentic Italian flavors and a perfect crust on the pizza. You can always count on quality here.

The place gets quite busy during peak times, so I highly recommend making a reservation. That said, we’ve been able to walk in if we visit early or during non-peak hours. One thing to note is that parking can be tricky—free street parking is usually full. However, there are other paid parking options nearby, and also the free Bellevue Downtown Park parking lot.

Overall, Mercato Stellina Pizzeria is a cozy spot with amazing food, great service, and a laid-back neighborhood feel. Definitely worth a visit!

Vegetarian options: Vegeterian Pizzas & Appetizers are available.“

“Delicious pizza and reasonable prices. Was a little confusing to find bc it's on the side of a building and down below in a basement like area“

“Food was good and staff was nice“

“Amazing pizza! It now our top favorite pizza place. Fresh pineapple was tasty and had the perfect crust and super friendly staff. (Went to the Seattle one on Dravus St)“

“Great food! Service was on point as well :)“

“Super fun place with hospitable fun staff! The staff are absolute troopers and super ninjas with entertaining personalities. And the food was 10/10 stars, absolutely delectable and I wanted to basically lick off my plate haha. You’ll need to be patient because they’re understaffed (not their fault, it’s the same as many other places!!!). 100% worth the wait. Great atmosphere and well decorated. located by a beautiful park with pretty old growth trees.“

“I am from NYC and have lived in Seattle for almost 5 yrs. I have tried many pizza places and this is the first place I've found to truly taste like NYC style pizza! The crust is perfection and screams mamma Mia! I am thrilled to have found this hidden gem in SODO. The staff is super friendly and sweet. I will definitely be going back and making this place my go to pizza spot!“

“Great service and phenomenal food! The best wood fired pizza anywhere!“

“My Margherita had beautiful leopard spots, fresh ingredients, and the service was top notch. I look forward to visiting again.“

“Delicious Pizza!! They grabbed me with the deep dish style pizza. i started following their Instagram so i could see what was going on. over the last few years i would order a pizza from them when in the area… a few special trips just because. Now just recently I started seeing Tavern Style pizza show up on the instagram. Started with photos from other places and then Windy City pie puts tavern on their menu! i wanted to try it since it became available and finally decided to make it part of my pre game for a saturday Mariners game. if thin crisp crust is not your thing then stick with the deep dish! it continues to amaze! If you like the thin crisp pizza try the tavern. it is not just any pizza it is special. the crust is thin uniform and crisp through out the pizza. the toppings are high quality and the sauce is something out of this world! I ate about half and took the rest home to share with my wife. thought i would be able to share our reheat but it didn’t get past the cold pizza phase… this has to be the very best cold pizza i can remember! So good we didn’t take the time to heat back up we just downed it! Check them out! really great pizza on 2 ends of the pizza spectrum!“

“Great food and beer... amazing service!“

“Lee and the crew at Moto are simply amazing! When i showed up, Lee greeted me and thanked me for supporting them and we shot the shi* a couple minutes since i had got their a few min early. To have the #6 best pizza in the country, he is very humble and caring. The attention to detail and customer service is superb. We got three pies last night (Clam Chowda, Chop and Kissd) and they were fantastic! Next week we get the crab and Mr Pig! It’s worth the wait to get an order in!“

“Delicious and fresh food. Great wait staff too. Highly recommend it!“

“I hired this company for my wedding and they were AMAZING! Every single guest at our wedding was in love with DUDE'Z pizza & their very kind service. The owners were so client centric, timely, organized and flexible with our needs. They had a non-stop line for their full 2 hours of service and managed it so well & smoothly, without compromising the quality of the food & service. Their trailer for their wood-fired oven made it so that we had to do nothing but provide them space- it was too easy! Their presentation was so thoughtful and professional. They are a trio of young entrepreneurs, hiring them was such a good decision. I'd hire them a million times again and again.“

“best wood fire pizza in Washington, and the price of the pizza is very good. little plus, you can watch them cook your pizza depending on where you sit.“

“They make some of the best pizza in Seattle, and honestly some of the best pizza I've had anywhere! Delicious sauce, great crust, toppings are excellent - best lunch is a couple of slices + a cookie and a Mannies :D“

“If you’re a Minnesota Vikings fan then this is the place to go to on game day! Talk about a great atmosphere with good people. The service was also great and very quick to help. They could use another computer if you ask me though. I got the Dip Sandwich and the flavor was great but waaayyyy too soggy. The paper got stuck to the bread and was all mushy before I even dipped it much less took my first bite.

I decided to give them one more star for their breakfast sandwich. It’s a bacon, ham, egg and cheese sandwich that comes on a toasted panini with a side of tots. Very good option!“

“Honestly really solid little joint. I should have gone a lot sooner. Extremely friendly, nice little eatting area that doesn't feel small at all. Great pizza, honestly some of the best I have had in Seattle, and a great price too. The dough is extremely flavorful too! Definitely found a new regular spot :) I've already been back once in a week. The calzones look incredible too!“

“The food here is fantastic!!! We got fried pickles, the hot neighbor pizza and kale salad. I wasn't sure if the pizza would be good but it ended up being my favorite. Only complaint is it is a little pricey for the amount of food you get.“