37 Best Pizza Restaurants near Colbert

“Excellent pizza, great atmosphere and ice cream! My husband is from Wisconsin and he said this pizza was just like he remembers!“

“I have been to your restaurant a few times. The pizzas are amazing as well as the salad bar The waitresses are exceptional and so is the service. I was however appalled by the managers unprofessional behavior when he yelled at his staff in front of the customers. This has happened on more than one occasion. This puts a damper on the customer experience when this happens.“

“A Hidden Gem in Panguitch! Being from Las Vegas, we consider ourselves pretty discerning when it comes to food—after all, we’re used to world-class dining. So when we say a little hometown café like the Flying Goat is a must every time we’re in Panguitch, that truly means something. From the moment you walk through the door, you’re met with such a warm, genuine welcome—it feels more like visiting a favorite relative’s home than stepping into a restaurant. The hospitality is as comforting as the food is satisfying. Portions are generous, ingredients always fresh, and the quality never disappoints. Today I had their strawberry salad with a side of chicken fingers made with a jalapeño mango sauce, and let me just say—wow. It was so beautifully presented and so delicious that I didn’t even pause for a photo. I dove right in, and honestly, it might be one of the best salads I’ve ever had. The Flying Goat is everything a small-town café should be—charming, consistent, and full of heart. We’re already counting down the days to our next visit.“

“Tuesday trivia!!! friendly guests - nice staff. great music ☺“

“My new favorite pizza! Although it’s a fast-food chain, they bake it fresh after you order. All the toppings are unlimited, so you can unleash your imagination and create whatever you like. I’m always satisfied with my choices, and it will definitely be my top pick for pizza.“

“Great food, friendly service and great atmosphere. I have a recommend“

“Despite just ordering on the app moments before arriving they were already preparing my order and bumped it up in the line since I was there already. I love how they are prepared with my order when I arrive or prioritize it if in process. That’s of course not to say they bump me ahead of anyone already waiting. Pizza’s are better topped than anything baked and delivered and always fresh!“

“This establishment was quite a wonderful experience. The man on till got me to get a couple sides 😉 they are absolutely amazing and I think I might just grab some more next time I go in!!! The crew looked really jolly and have a great system of things. 10/10 experience will go back again sometime soon.“

“Consistently great pizza! I’ve heard some people complain, but let’s be real, if you're building your own pizza and don’t like how it turns out, that's kind of on you. Choose better toppings next time!

This MOD location is clean, the ingredients are always fresh, and the staff make the experience even better. They're genuinely fun to talk to and always bring great energy. A solid spot for a quick, delicious, and customizable meal!“

“Had an amazing experience at Selkirk! Kali was top notch and the pizza and salad bar were delicious. Tasty drinks, super fast and efficient service. All around 5 stars!“

“Ordered pizza and a drink. Card issues with there reader and I had no cash.. they happily just comped it for me. Great service and food is great at mod“

“The pizza is great. It was the best. I also like Danielle who works there. She is the perfect pizza waitress ever. Making my heart love pizza forever. please comment and react back sometime.“

“The manager of this store is so kind and understanding.!!! I have epilepsy and the flashing sign affected me being a bright white light.! I asked them to consider turning it off for me and anyone else it could affect.! They kindly turned it off and apologized and even sent a note out to other branches in town to consider doing the same.! All in all she’s an amazing manager and person and has a great team working as well…! Pizza is usually always on point but my last order was littler messy and the thin crust was not thin thin like it usually is. Was a medium fluff to thin. But I know they would have taken care of me if I called.! Overall 5 stars.! ?“

“Great food! Super hot so watch those bites, but really good first experience! The guy up front was nice and helpful, the beers were cheap, and the food was made fresh!
The restaurant inside is a little bland, but that’s not always what it’s about. Tons of people came in and picked up To-Go orders, seemed like a lot of regulars too. I’ll always say though that eating food as soon as possible is going to give you the best experience and there are $3 beers, so just chill and dine in if you can 👌
Will be back to give the pizza a try cause the Calzone slapped 🔥“

“The quality of food here is incredible, and the prices are seriously unheard of anymore! This is the fluffiest pizza, so perfect every time. Their wings are delicious. Ordering online is simple and user-friendly. I love all the specials and deals they have. It's my family's favorite place!“

“GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE+1(8O5)-41O 5OO2 NO NONSENSE AND GREAT ASSISTANCE!!!“

“haven't been but after seeing a video of the servers n shows they been taught well, I'll soon be going all the way from El Paso TX just to dine in ....“

“Beautiful yummy pizza. It arrived hot and delicious ? They have friendly delivery drivers!! They fix mix ups on orders and are just all around plesent today business with.“

“absolutely love this place. hidden gem that we drive from the valley to come too“

“Papa Murphy's offers a fantastic option for families looking for an affordable meal, and the fact that they accept EBT is a huge benefit for many. It's great to know that you can get such a tasty pizza and use your EBT card, making it easier to feed your family without breaking the bank. The prices at Papa Murphy's are definitely a standout, offering good value for a customizable pizza that you can bake fresh at home.“

“food is great, but my-lanta, the service is SLOW.... so far fifteen minutes for a sandwich.... that I ordered online fifteen minutes before I showed up... so far.“

“Great pizza. we'll definitely be back.“

“One of the best tasting pizzas ever! We always stop when we come through!“

“Had to leave after sitting at table with grand kids cause we didn't have reservation, from Montana for hockey game,people where rude.“

“IT’S A GREAT PLACE TO TAKE YOUR KIDS FOR THEIR BIRTHDAYS!!!!“

“I order from Domino's about once a month or so, Especially on Sunday's when hardly anything is open in Deer Park. And I've always been pleased. But on Saturday Nov 9th I had my family over to help me out with things around the house. I ordered pizza for everyone. They hadn't eaten at any Domino's in a long time, and weren't sure Domino's was the best option.... the pizza delivered was amazing!!! Most of us had the Extravaganza with a couple modifications. The pizza was soo loaded! Seriously the best pizza I've had anywhere in years!! Whoever made our pizza that day needs to train every Domino's employee at every Domino's location how to make a pizza!! My family was definitely sold that Domino's is the best delivery pizza! With skills like that, no wonder the Deer Park Pizza Hut closed down!! We appreciate you all. Thanks for awesome pizza and awesome service!“

“Great experience for my Grand Daughter and I ☺️ Everyone was so kind and the food was so good. Thank you for a fun lunch birthday date ☺️“

“I haven't been bowling in years, and this was such a fun date night. The jalapeño poppers were amazing! Disclaimer they are whole huge jalapeños filled with cream cheese and bacon, then deep fried. It's just a clean up-beat cosmic experience. They also have claw machines, which are fun, and we happened to win 3 stuffed animals!“

“Sbarro Pizza? More like Sbarro Piece-of-Heaven! I came in hungry and left questioning my life choices—like why haven’t I been eating here every day?! The crust is so perfectly baked it deserves its own fan club, the cheese stretch is straight out of a food commercial, and the toppings? They’re so fresh I half expected them to introduce themselves.

I ordered their cheese pizza , and let me tell you, one bite in, I heard angels singing. The staff is friendlier than my grandma when I actually call her, and the vibes? Immaculate.

If you’re debating whether to eat here, stop. Just do it. You owe it to your taste buds.“

“Delicious food! I've lived right around the corner for many years, lots of family meals here“

“New restaurant with a timless franchise, favorite amongst many, atmosphere of yesteryear lingers in memory with a fresh new feel, expect the same greatly taste and quality from years past. Fountain sodas still exist and resemble the past with high carbonation and classic fountain soda flavors, wisking away thoughts of teenage angst and family dinners. It's a true favorite of summer.“

“Jennifer the manager on division was cooking, BEST Pizza Hut Pizza I’ve had in 20 years. It’s like the great Pizza Hut that everybody loved in my home town. Jennifer should be sent around to teach the others how to cook cause most suck! Super good. I’d drive all the way from Rathdrum ID. to eat here if Jennifer was cooking!!!“

“food is great, but my-lanta, the service is SLOW.... so far fifteen minutes for a sandwich.... that I ordered online fifteen minutes before I showed up... so far.“

“We had an issue with our delivery from uber. We received the wrong size pizzas. It was an expensive order and I was frustrated. Kileigh the manager did a wonderful job at listening. She then came up with a solution. It was wonderful and refreshing to have someone make the effort to help and resolve.“

“It was my 1st experience with this location, and I was a couple minutes late for a discount app I was attempting to complete and unfortunately I had to pay full price for my meal but my wife made it in time 3 minutes prior. So, besides that the food was great and I'd revisit in the near future.“

“6.15.25 Father's Day: Snuck away to town for pizza and pinball. So, we all know that companies spend millions of dollars on marketing and advertising--well, congrats Domino's, your recent commercial for your new parmesan stuffed crust pizza did its job and lured me in! There's a local Domino's back home in Reno that was my go-to and I hoped this store could be my go-to living in Idaho.

I made my order online and used the pizza tracker to let me know when to head over. When we walked in, we were greeted with a smile and I said I had made an online order, and it was ready just like the pizza tracker said. The store was small but nicely lit and decored. I was surprised there was enough room for 1 booth and a small waiting area. Because the booth was empty, we decided to dine in so we could have hot pizza. We ordered 2 medium 2 topping pizzas with both upgrading to parmesan stuffed crust (the extra charge to make it stuffed crust was $4ea pizza). I'm still not eating meat and my topping choices were pineapple and half mushroom. My friend's topping was double pepperoni. We also got an order of the chocolate lava cakes and a couple bottled sodas. The entire meal was $39 and some change. I think that's a great value at $20 bucks p/p for a decent hot meal with leftovers to take home.

My pizza was hot, fresh, and nice and melty. I'm glad I tried the parmesan stuffed pizza because I really liked the crust and how super cheesy it was. The seasonings, garlic, and parmesan blended well together and was almost like getting a cheesy bread stick attached to every slice of your pizza, which to me was a bonus value. My friend's double pepperoni looked pretty tasty. The chocolate lava cake was still warm and rich and gooey. It was a nice treat to polish off the meal.

For Domino's being more of an American hearty pizza vs an artisan gourmet pizza, Domino's is great, good in value, and also offers more than just pizza and wings. Service was friendly and the female employee was personable. I will definitely visit this Domino's again.“

“I had a problem with my order to which it was handled so perfectly that I having been in the restaurant business for 25 yrs am still impressed with the gentleman who handled it. He represented true customer service and there are not many places anywhere anymore that really even care about customer service. Great job!“