Toby's Tavern

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+62 photos
+61 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We went on a Sunday afternoon for lunch. Food was hit and miss. We had their special thai curry mussels which were good. The cod bites, on the other hand, were somewhat rubbery, although flavor and sauce was good. Servers were great until they just forgot about us after the meal. They did have a rush though, so understandable.

I would still go again. Great atmosphere. My friends went Friday night and said that was a great experience.
Penn Cove mussels were absokutely amazing, sweet and tender. I had blue mussels from different part of the country and this is by far the best. Good service and the water front view was spectacular.
We had a good time, fun atmosphere. We liked the staff but our fish and chips took a long time, and when they arrived they weren’t really all that flakey — kinda disappointing for their specialty. The fish itself was good, the fries were fine, and the sauces were tasty but the breading needs some work. Might need a lighter batter or hotter fryer :)

Portions were great and prices were fair

More Reviews