27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Maple Valley

“We love Cascadia! Our favorite is the Lombardi pizza.“

“I contacted the catering manager who was very prompt in helping contact the MV store to put in a 9 pizza catering order for high school students. The store was able to work with my target time for pickup and arrange for an employee to come in a bit earlier than usual to have everything ready to go at my requested pickup time. Great experience, efficient communication, positive attitudes - thanks for making it all work!“

“Always great food. Not much changed since I worked here decades ago. Which is a good thing. Even the prices are on par. It's probably my favorite pizza joint cooked or no. Good service.

Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza options available

Kid-friendliness: It's a take out pizza joint. It couldn't be more kid friendly. It's more of an errand, though.“

“I only go there when certain bartender works there. There one I totally dislike.“

“I have been going here for a very long time, and service here for me has not disappointed me. Food is quickly made, people are nice and they give you brakes when you mess up orders and stuff like that. Pizza isn't the best in the entire world, but for the speed and service it's amazing. Also I would like to mention I had accidentally put one star on the website. I hope this makes it even. :(“

“Ordered Door Dash and my delicious pizza came hot and just as I ordered. My receipt told me to go to tattle.com and it brought me to an Expedia website. Since I'm a teacher and don't like tattling anyway I thought I'd give a shoutout to all the team members working 7/15/25 at 8:25pm. My pizza was delicious! Thank you for taking the care to check all the ingredients and my add ons. Appreciate you!“

“Papa's in Maple Valley is the best! Every Time! They make it all wonderful/Thanks for the great pizza again tonight!“

“I have been picking up from this location for about a year now and the pizza has always been made well and the staff super friendly. I'm always very happy with the amount of toppings albeit the boneless nuggets are underwhelming (but they were made well).“

“Great local joint with delicious pizza! Ordered online, pizza was ready in 20 mins. They have comfortable leather seats the wait in. Staff is very friendly, in a genuine way. Bacon and pineapple pizza was perfect. The buttered and seasoned crust was my favorite part!“

“Love their pizza and love supporting local businesses whenever I can!!“

“I had an amazing experience with Papa Murphy’s Pizza! The staff was friendly and helpful, and the pizza was incredibly fresh and delicious. I loved the option to bake it at home, which made it taste like a homemade masterpiece. I’ll definitely be coming back for more!“

“Such a good atmosphere! Ben is the nicest person ever and the food is amazing! I personally recommend the pesto pizza🤍“

“Excellent food. great service. 5*“

“i had an amazing experience at papa murphy's at 4350 ne 4th st suite c, renton, wa 98059. josh and kiana helped me with my pizza around 7:30 pm and they were fantastic. super friendly and made sure everything was perfect. the pizza was delicious and so easy to bake at home. highly recommend this spot for great service and tasty pizza!“

“If you like a traditional bar pie. Crispy, a little char, good undercarriage, no flop...this would be a place you'd like. If you're a hand tossed or deep dish lover...probably won't dig this style.
Good service. Everything is fresh. Pizza is on point.“

“Went into MOD Pizza at 7pm, and the young man named Austin at the front was exceptional with the service. Not only was he very friendly but he got everything right on the pizza and got us out in a timely manner. There was another gentleman with him as well, didn’t catch his name, he was wonderful too.“

“Next time you decide to have papa Murphy's you gotta try subbing out there red sauce for the garlic white sauce...... Yummmmm..... Mmmmmmmmm...... My new favorite on almost any pizza, ( personally I wouldn't try it on the hawaiian,but that's just me) it's delicious ?!!!!

Vegetarian options: Vegetarian options available ?

Kid-friendliness: Has mini ? pizzas in its own little cute cardboard pizza box?“

“Everyone there is super nice and they have great food the cook and the waitresses are super friendly and the regulars that go in are also super friendly and will chat with you definitely recommend going there“

“Great local spot, haven't ever had a bad meal --- from breakfast to burgers to pizza. Yum!!!“

“This is one of the most amazing locations Olive, Christian, & Zoi are beyond friendly. They are always smiling and bringing great energy. The store is clean. I can tell they take pride in their jobs. Love this location and the team.

9.16.25 update
I cannot add a new review. So big up to Mario and crew. I’ve been studying and starving. They really came through with the customer service and speed.“

“Really nice early dinner with the Family. service was top notch as was the food. Gustoso.“

“Great food and drinks was a lot of fun“

“Standard little Caesar’s location. Little run down and dingy. Seems to be a common theme in the 1/2 doz I’ve visited

Food was ready around the time it was promised.

Didn’t see a single person when I walked in. Entered my number, picked up my pizza and walked out.

Pizza was good though. I did reheat it in the oven for 5 min at 350.“

“Recently went on a motorcycle ride and stopped in to the city hall saloon. The outdoor eating area had a spooky but cool theme of old bikes with mannequins on them. The drinks were good. We had margaritas. Surprisingly... the tuna melt was the best I've ever had. The staff were super friendly. The regulars were very welcoming! Cool place and different experience!“

“Every time I come here the manager comes out from the back and asks how I’m doing and smiles and I feel welcome. The pizzas have always been top notch here and are usually done in under 12 minutes which allows me to get groceries next door and then come pick up a couple pizzas on the way home. A humble location but a cornerstone of the community!“

“Best to order ahead, just a lobby with 3 chairs. Seems to be high volume, so employees are going at 100 miles an hour. It cranks out pizza. The most important part, the price, it is consistent, and if you order online, fast. Very convenient, 5 minutes away, and hot. FYI, BYOB(bring your own bag). The only real hangup I have with this place. Other than that I feel they are a slice above the local competition.“

“They were short staffed the night I picked up. Ordered online, then waited 30 minutes there. But everybody was nice. The customers were fairly patient and it was worth the wait because the food at this Domino's location is better than other I've tried“