19 Best Italian Restaurants near Puyallup

“good food and service from regular menu. for brunch the mushroom fritata was a bit disappointing. it lacked mushrooms and presented as more of as potato dish than a fritata“

“Best service and most fun in a while. Kellie was our server in south hill. She was so much fun pointed out a better deal for a dinner to take to our elderly neighbor and liked my boyfriends jokes.“

“Mama Stortini’s has amazing service. Our server Gabe was awesome. The food was wonderful. Justine the manager came over and introduced herself to everyone and wanted to make sure we all had everything we needed.“

“Fat Zach’s offers the perfect combo of delicious wood-fired pizza and flexibility. Their on-site catering accommodates dietary needs without sacrificing flavor, and the team is always friendly and fast. A guest favorite every time.“

“food was delicious and the service was great.“

“Ate here the other day. Their pizzas are very good. A little pricey, but generally worth it. What I do not understand is their pricing. We ordered a Daily Double: any 2 pizzas for $28. But on the receipt it says $28.98. Huh? was there some fine print somewhere that I didn’t notice and was not brought to my attention by the host? The pint I ordered was listed as $8 on the menu, but I was charged $8.28. Same with the salad. What the menu showed as $8 was actually $8.28. Can anyone explain this to me? It was generally a good experience, you do have to place your order at the window and go pick it up like at a fast food joint. So the service was lacking. But doing it yourself saves on the tip. I just don’t understand the pricing.“

“I have never had pizza to go and went there tonight. The second I walked in Patrick, Danni and Giuseppe were so warm, welcoming and quite the comedians! They suggested a glass of wine while I waited for my pizza so I went and had a glass of wine. The bartender was just as amazing as them! Hands down the best customer service in a long time and the pizza was outstanding! I'll definitely be back! Thank you :)“

“Delicious food, great happy hour and such a nice server“

“Thank you for making my mom's 95th birthday special tonight. John is fabulous and made us all laugh and feel very welcome. Food was all delicious. Lasagna, Wild caught salmon, smoked salmon fettuccine and pizza were ALL perfection. And I will definitely be dreaming about that lemon cake!!!!“

“33 years ago, my new wife introduced me to Vinces. In her previous marriage, Vinces in Renton was the family go to. One bite of Vinces pizza and I was hooked. The only negative is Vince's pizza has spoiled me to every other pizza place in the area. Vinces pizzas are Neapolitan style......much, much better (in my humble opinion) than any other pizza's. Vince's is the place our family always meets for special occasions. We have always been treated very well. My 9 year old grandson told me Vince's pepperoni pizza is his favorite.....it happens to be my favorite too. Writing this I'm starting to crave a pizza! Their other menu offerings are equally excellent. A year or so ago, we stopped for lunch. Out of the blue, I ordered one of their Italian Hero's. I will say it was the absolute BEST Sub/Hero/Grinder I had ever eaten. If you have not been to Vinces, so yourself a favor and try it. You might find you have a new favorite pizza/pasta place. A++“

“There were four of us for lunch. The atmosphere is Italian and casual. Unfortunately, the background .music is not in the background, making it difficult to talk. I asked the staff to turn down the music, and they did a bit, but loud music is the norm here.
I ordered the Mistra salad, and it was good. However, the housemate dress was BAD. Seemed to be almost exclusively olive oil. They did bring a ranch, which was fine. I paid an extra $6,50 for a small chicken breast, which had good flavor but was pretty dry.
My wife had tomato basil soup and 1/2 turkey panini. She said her food was very good. The servers were excellent and a bright spot in lunch.
We will probably come again at some point.“

“Our ohana loves going to Olive Garden, but this Olive Garden has something that the others lack, a server named Mark who made our family time exceptionally beautiful. He went above and beyond in getting us what we desired to consume, and made us laugh, and feel genuine joy throughout our entire meal. This man was a blessing to my ohana and I, and we're so grateful that Olive Garden has hired wholesome employees like him. Mahalo Mark.“

“Great service, great food.... love this place🥰“

“Food is amazing, I had the Wild Boar Bolognese and it was really good“

“We found Aversano's during COVID times and haven't gone anywhere else locally for Italian fare since. We love them - the food is always good and there is always lots of it. We love picking up and eating in the comfort of our home however, we enjoy going in as the the feel of the restaurant is like being at home!“

“Great pizza, hot and delicious. Crust is one of the best around. Plenty of cheese, just the right amount of sauce, toppings covered the pizza. Only reason atmo is 3 stars is it is just a pick up counter. I did get a chuckle out of the collection of items on right side of counter. If you want good pizza, this is the place. They have pizza rolls, sandwiches, salads and desserts.“

“Every time we go we have THE BEST service, THE MOST delicious fresh food, and we ALWAYS get the donut holes - they are to die for! 🩷“

“Best pizza in town. 5 stars out out 5 stars.“

“I just love this place out of all the other restaurants in the mall their food always fresh their equipment always clean and they serve the best chicken ranch pizza it’s just try and the crew is just the best crew you will meet. The manger is always nice and as a regular they always remember my order which makes me feel like I am seen and taken care of. Exactly how I should feel. They know what they’re doing and they do it best !! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️“