Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Appleton
2120 W College Ave, Appleton
(920) 734-4000
Customers' Favorites
Cream Cheese Jalapeno Poppers
Cardiac Arrest Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Alfredo
Nickel Nuggets
Boaris Karloff
Garlic Bread
Fetalicious
Mac & Cheese
Menu
Photos
+61 photos
+60 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Ordered pizza and salads for delivery. Service was great. Pizza was really good. Salads were awful. Cheese was dried out, bacon was raw and all fat, lettuce was old and red around edges. Ended up throwing the salads away. I have eaten here alot of times and will continue to do so although won't be ordering any more salads. Obviously they don't check them much to see what they look like.
We received a pizza delivery from here. It was earlier than anticipated. The delivery person, Kayla?, deserved a bigger tip than we included on the order. The crust was perfectly done for me. The sauce had a great Italian seasoning flavor. The ingredients were fresh and evenly distributed. The cook on the pizza was great- browned slightly but not crunchy. I will definitely order from here again.
Hostess wasn’t very nice. Asked for a booth (there were a lot open) and was told she had only one on the end in the middle of everything. She was pretty short with us. Waitress was cordial but that was it. Pizza was good though. Thankfully.
You May Also Like
Egyptian Delights Cafe - 2310 W College Ave
![]()
Cafe, Egyptian, Pet Friendly
The Melting Pot - 2295 W College Ave
![]()
Fondue, Vegetarian