6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Baldwin

“Stopped 9/12/26 for dinner. We were pleasantly greeted walking in. I had the Cuban and fries. Love those fries OMG they are good. The meatloaf looked amazing. Im getting that on our next stop. Love the fish tank. Our overall experience was very enjoyable. Bunch of friendly folks with a beautiful establishment. Can't wait to come back.“

“Disappointed tonight. Have ordered many times with no problems, tonight we ordered with no green peppers because of a friends food allergy, it came with green peppers.“

“We stopped in the GarageBar on Friday night, July 3, 2026. Great atmosphere. such friendly owners!! we had a potato appetizer they call hubcaps.. DELISH!!!! You have to try them! then we took a pizza to go. Also.. DELISH!! Thank you for a great time and meal!!“

“Very laid back friendly atmosphere, this is the place I decided to stop in to after not being in spring valley for over 25+ years. Very impressed with the professionalism and politeness of staff. And the food, amazing! The cook even personally delivered our food!“

“We had a friend recommend this restaurant for their buffets and for our wedding wanted local and buffet style. We set up a taste testing and this was the first time there/having their food. Communication was great! Owner was 10/10! We booked them as our caterer and do not regret it! So many compliments on the food, owner was SO awesome throughout the whole process, and we even have some friends that booked them for their upcoming wedding! We only have great things to talk about! Now we enjoy their fish Friday’s for date night!“

“We hosted a pizza party for 10 people. I called Jess at Hilltop and she was very helpful and was able to figure out how many pizzas I needed to order so that we had enough. Her recommendation was spot on and pizza was delivered on time, nice and hot and very tasty. We demolished those pizzas and no one left hungry and we had a small amount of leftovers!“