13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Stillwater

“Delicious, fresh, hand made pizza. We love patronizing this local establishment. We'll definitely be back!“

“Great pizza! Friendly staff. Will be back for sure!“

“My mom and I stopped in for lunch. I ordered the lunch ribs. They were some of the biggest ribs I have ever had. Lots of meat and so good! The sides had alot of flavor and everything was fresh. My toddler even approved! I would definitely go back!“

“Best pizza in town! Why?
Real, melty cheese!
Thick, rich red sauce!
Thin, firm Crust!
Generous toppings!
Locally owned and operated!
Because of the fresh, high-quality ingredients, this Pizza Man earns a 10/10 - Pizza Dude“

“Great experience, food was excellent and service was amazing! Andres recommended great appetizers and wine. He was very welcoming, knowledgeable, and made us feel at home! Highly recommend!“

“I love going to Carbone's pizzeria in Stillwater Minnesota. They have a potluck breakfast during the Vikings 8:30 a.m. European games. They give out free purple Jello shots every time the Minnesota Vikings score a touchdown during all season games. Kudos to the Jello shot girl, Jenna. Carbone's has top-notch pizza and they just added BBQ pork ribs as a special, $14.99. I always have a super fun time that Carbone's.“

“Thank you for fantastic service on a large last minute order...and correcting it when I messed up! I appreciate you! Definitely will order again. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!“

“It's always fun to stop into the harbor bar in Stillwater. The service is great from Donna mae, Jake, Sam, Pedro, and others. Coldest and cheapest White Claw's in town, $4.25. all roads lead to Harbor Bar. It's like Cheers, everybody knows your name. See you there.
5 stars. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“They do a good job when they get the order correct. I have to order a create your own and pay more for my pizzas to get them made correctly. If I order a standard pizza and modify it they always mess it up. So I pay the $3-$4 more per pizza to get them correct.“

“Stopped on a Thursday afternoon to see PT on the patio. The female singer performing was amazing. My wife and I had a couple happy hour apps including wings, nachos and cheese burger sliders. Everything was awesome! Only got a pic of the wings tho. We love this bar and look forward to returning again and again!“

“We got a pepperoni pizza and ceasar salad. The pizza is top tier, will order again. The flavor of the ceasar dressing was different than what we expected, not their fault though... if you know what's in it, you know how unique the taste can be.“

“I order Domino's pizza from this location often and they are always very consistent. My orders have never been incorrect. The food always is delivered on time. The delivery drivers are always friendly. They always have great deals here.“

“****do NOT recommend**** Waited 10 minutes for our table only to see that literally only a handful of table were being used. Ok fine… then waited over 20 minutes to be greeted by our waiter. Order an app and our entrees. Then waited literally over an hour for our app to come out and 30 seconds for our entrees. Hostess tells me “it is what it is” and Manager acted as if it wasn’t a big deal that literally we’d been there for almost an hour and a half waiting!!!! Tyler apologies and takes the blame but management only takes a measly appetizer off our bill. We order two pizzas which came out cold and raw and an app and she only takes off an app. Worst place ever. Disappointed!!! Only thing this place had going for it was the view aside from that everything else wasn’t worth our time“