Restaurants near Colgate

“This is one of my favorite places in Lake Country!! The food is amazing. Service is great. They have a great patio option for summer! Staff is always friendly and fun!”

“Best Christmas cookies ever.”

“Awesome people!!!!! Fun!!!”

“Dave's Hot Chicken - fastfood greatness. Extremely quick order processing - 6 minutes after ordering; order was prepared for pickup. Prepared orders are always tasty, accurate and on time. I enjoy the variety of spice levels. Also, service staff are great.”

“My friend and I met Derek the bartender… he is always funny and does a great job…. He needs a raise…. I really like that place everyone is so nice Thanks Derek”

“Wanted to shout out Adonis! Great customer service. I really hope the food is great. If so I'll be returning as Adonis handled the crowd. Hope he sees this post and know he is appreciated !”

“Fantastic service and very clean environment!”

“This is the best barbecue I’ve ever come across!! After years of trying many many places in many different areas both here in Wisconsin and when traveling. They get 5 stars and an A+!! They are also super friendly every time I go there. This place won’t disappoint you!!”

“Slo' Motion BBQ saved Thanksgiving with their turkey meal plus brisket! Everyone loved it and it was so easy to order and pick up HOT! Game changer for holidays. thank you!”

“We order for pizza delivery fairly often where I work. the pizza is AWESOME and delivery is fast. online pizza ordering is a little confusing but that's the only thing that could be improved. yummy pizza!!”

“Good food, great service, a fun place to go!”

“The staff were super accommodating to our large group and the food was fantastic! Great service as well. Highly recommend.”

“I was intrigued by the building when I was dropping my kids off at sky zone and decided to give it a whirl I tried a blackberry lavender mocha and it was the best coffee I've had ever. t literally makes it in about 30 seconds and I went back today to redeem my free coffee, one of the owners happen to be there and let me peek inside and meet Frank the robot behind the magic. Getting to see the inner workings, the variety of drinks and fair pricing knowing I'm getting Stone Creek coffee just sealed the deal for me”

“BEST breakfast in SE WI. Super friendly staff and incredible food. The owner always stopping by our booth to check on us is the icing on the cake. Jimmy’s appreciates its customers. Well, the customers appreciate Jimmy’s even more.”

“Depends on Monday or Tuesday.
Monday had it's slipped the girl that took me to the waiting room didn't mention that the one piece of cloth she handed me was a robe not a blanket. The lockers were so bad that I had to try four of them before I found one that worked. Plus I had to wait that I was almost late for my next appointment.”

“Friendly staff, great service, good choice of drinks, gluten free options - thank you 😊”

“They are so yummy! You have to get there early to get one as they will sell out. Kind of shocked to see the 1 star review over them! The new people in our neighborhood must not know that bakeries are businesses with limited stock :) they can’t just pull more goods out of thin air. To write a review over not getting the item you want isn’t a review it’s whining. There are dozens of other yummy options they have amazing danishes. And the cake is UNREAL. My son and I will have out and play board games located under the tv.”

“We had a great experience at Parkside 23!! The food is amazing and we have never had a meal we didn’t like. Nikki was our server and she was very lively and fun!”

“I recommend a visit to the Barn. I opened a new shop April 3rd of 2024 a month before the makers mart event in May of this year. What a wonderful opportunity for my new business to get introduced. It’s been a wonderful experience so far and my neighbors have been very welcoming. My new business is called MoeChic the barn shops which is located in the barn on the grounds of Stone wood Village. I’m so excited to be here and I’m loving it. Come visit the shop and meet myself and my greeter, Buddy who is my lovable Burnedoodle. The shop includes a gallery area with unique handmade items created by local artists. Another area is set up as a boutique with women’s clothing, handmade from a several countries purchase through fair trade, a shoe line and many accessories and jewelry. All handmade, artistic and cultural in fashion. And of course the upper level is layed out with vintage, re-purpose an upcycled items mixed with vintage and current artwork. Come visit and see what treasures you can find here.”

“Our first time at Capital Cafe and we had a wonderful experience. Food was excellent and our waitress was very kind! Definitely recommend the waffles with fresh fruits (had to order the hashbrowns and sausage as sides, separately), and the biscuit and gravy!”

“The pizza was excellent! Crispy crust on the thin side, tasty sauce, and good toppings. Reminds me of a real Chicago style pizza. A couple center pieces had almost no sauce under the cheese tho. Don't be afraid to lather that beauty! Delicious”

“So-Agave, best new Mexican Restaurant. located in Germantown. just to let everyone know, we have been to Mexico 5 times. This is authentic Mexican food.”

“Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful German themed/inspired restaurant. Great food. Great drinks. Great people. Ground level bar allows for a spectacular panoramic view of the outdoor wildlife.”

“Always Great food ,Great flavor and Great Service. Do yourself a favor and stop here to eat, you will not be disappointed.”

“Went to Maxim's after my mom's. The choices for the entree were wonderful, and it included 2 choices for gluten-free
The only complaint was that the cod dinner wasn't enough food. Everything tasted great.”

“A Consistently Incredible Dining Experience at Prec1nct Every time my wife and I dine at Prec1nct, we’re blown away. The food is not only constantly delicious, but it’s also crafted with such precision and care that each visit feels like a special occasion. Let me tell you about the seared scallops—they are nothing short of perfection. Perfectly caramelized on the outside, tender and flavorful on the inside. Honestly, I could eat them every night and never get tired of them. It’s a dish that hits all the right notes. Dining here is always a pleasure, not just because of the incredible food, but because of the warm, welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service. The staff is always attentive without being overbearing, and the experience feels personalized every time. A huge shoutout to Chef Jody and Angie—you two are truly the heart of this place. Your passion and talent shine through in every dish and interaction. It's clear how much pride you take in your work, and it makes all the difference. Prec1nct has become our go-to dinner spot, and we look forward to every meal there. If you're looking for food that hits every time, a great vibe, and a team that genuinely cares—this is the place. Also, Mikey is okay to! 😁 Highly recommend!!!! P.S Don't forget dessert 😋”

“lotta bang for your buck!”

“Gosh is this place beautiful. For me personally, I wish the menu had more items on their non coffee menu that were not carbonated. But other than that, everything there is amazing”

“We love Beer Snobs!!! Great atmosphere and great bartenders!”