10 Best Bakeries near Colgate

“Best Christmas cookies ever.“

“Brought these into the office for my co-workers because they are the most delicious cinnamon buns I have ever had. They were gone in seconds. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this bakery, I recommend it to everyone!“

“Amazing!!!! My friend and I stopped in to get a gf muffin and I walked out buying many items. ALL were so delicious! This is probably one of THE BEST all gluten free bakeries I've ever visited. It will definitely be a staple stop whenever I'm in town visiting. You have to check it out!🙌🥰“

“I asked for decorations to match our bridal shower invitation. She did amazing. Everyone asked where we got the cake from because the flavor was delicious (lemon cake with raspberry and vanilla custard filling and butter cream frosting). We are ordering our daughter's wedding cake from her too. Amazing value with amazing taste!“

“Stopped in yesterday to grab my girlfriend a chocolate chip cookie, I was confused on what type of chocolate chips are used and why there was no sea salt on my cookie last month when I stopped. I was greeted with a welcoming smile from to find out the assistant GM Hilary I think she said her name was. She clarified my confusion and took her time to make sure I was educated on their products. She will be a great GM one day and a great leader. I have owned many restaurants and nightclubs in Buffalo. NY, this manager should be recognized as someone who cares about her business. GREAT JOB“

“They are so yummy! You have to get there early to get one as they will sell out. Kind of shocked to see the 1 star review over them! The new people in our neighborhood must not know that bakeries are businesses with limited stock :) they can’t just pull more goods out of thin air. To write a review over not getting the item you want isn’t a review it’s whining. There are dozens of other yummy options they have amazing danishes. And the cake is UNREAL. My son and I will have out and play board games located under the tv.“

“I’ve been to Beach Bum Bakery a few times now. From the items I’ve had (donuts, cookies, cupcakes and breakfast sandwich) most items have been good. I was there recently on a weekend morning to get donuts and a breakfast sandwich. As I was there it went from just a two people in the shop to 15 people, thankfully I had ordered prior to all these people arriving. The two employees working did seem a little overwhelmed and frantic. I was able to get my donuts in a timely manner but the breakfast sandwich took about 25 minutes to get and it only had one small/thin piece of bacon on it that was torn in half.
Note: the employees were very kind, I could just see the distress on their faces and they were trying to get caught up. The other times I’ve been here the service has been much quicker than what I experienced.“

“Ordered the Overdrive and Tiramisu cold brew. Both drinks were delicious. Would highly recommend the Tiramisu cold brew if u like your coffee a bit sweeter. Cozy vibe inside. Barista wasn’t very welcoming. Not exactly rude but certainly not going out of her way to be friendly. Will be back for the great tasting coffee and solid pricing.“

“The cookies were awesome we loved and enjoyed our Benson Boone Moonbeam ice cream mystical magical cookies....... and the following day we are off to the concert at Summerfest 2025, Milwaukee baby!!!!!!! Benson Boone put on an awesome show. Best-selling for Summerfest 2025 thank you Crumbl Cookie.“

“Very disappointed in Coffeeville bakery lately. My husband had a cinnamon roll and I had a peanut butter muffin. This was on Sunday. Both bakery pieces were extremely dry and obviously not fresh. Bakery prices are very high these days, that being said, I expect fresh bakery at a coffee shop. The coffee was very good.“