24 Best Bakeries near Waukesha

“We ordered cheese cakes for our wedding from mama ducky. Melissa was awesome start to finish! She took time to talk with me with out an appointment.(I had been to 3 other bakeries and no one would even answer any questions I had with out a appointment) We like red velvet and Melissa made little trials of each red velet option for us to try. She was always prompt to respond to any messages we sent. The day of She delivered to the venue right on time. She truly cares about her customers. We would highly recommend her and mama ducky!“

“My wedding cake was amazing! So pretty and very yummy. My guests couldn’t stop talking about it. There was barely any left by the end of the night. And so happy we saved the rest of our top tier for our anniversary next year. Thanks Aly!“

“Very nice place with great people and excellent food and bakery! We will definitely be going there many times in the future.“

“My husband surprised me with some gluten free cookies from Aunt Mabel’s and it was a delight. The cookies were delicious! I’m so excited to have a new gluten free bakery nearby. There aren’t a lot of options in Waukesha so we’ll definitely be supporting this new business!“

“Been to Rochester Deli many times over the years, mostly for their fish fries. This visit was specifically for bakery items, and that is when I learned that I have apparently been enjoying Periwinkle desserts all along. Their production facility is next door, but the baked goods are sold through Rochester Deli. I also learned that the deli owner’s daughter runs the bakery.

I came in hoping to pick up a few cupcakes and possibly a small round cake. There was only one cupcake option available, a Boston Cream, which did look good. Unfortunately, there were no cakes available, so I struck out there. I did grab a couple of the peanut butter cookies half dipped in chocolate, which are always a hit at my house.

The staff member who helped me apologized for the limited selection, but there was not much they could do.

Overall, I really enjoy their cookies, bars, and cake slices, and I will definitely be back for some of their regular items.“

“What a cute little place to stop for a bite for lunch. Traditional deli set-up and atmosphere; order at the counter, find a table, pick-up at the window when your number is called. When finished, take your dish to the waste station and dump and stack.

The young man at the counter was friendly and welcoming, as well as knowledgeable about the offerings of the day. When I went back to the counter after eating to purchase some bakery to take home, the young lady who was now there was also very friendly.

The food is delicious. I had the Reuben with Potato Salad, which also came with a pickle spear. Everything was wonderful. The Reuben was very well balanced without any one ingredient overpowering the others. The corned beef is brisket but sliced thin and stacked, making it easier to eat than those who use a single, thick wedge. The bakery I took home was good, but actually too sweet for me. The flavors were good, but the overload of sugar was too much for me. If you're a fan of sweet sweets, then definitely give it go!“

“Delicious treats, great service and outstanding owners!!“

“Overall this place is pretty good. However lately I’ve had bad experiences. Cookies clearly missing toppings, hardly any filling in “sandwich” cookies, and over baked cookies that are hard and clearly should have never gone out. If I wanted a crunchy dry cookie I’d go to the gas station. 95% of my interactions here are good, but it’s the bad ones that stick out.“

“We have ordered custom cookies and cupcakes a handful of times from Sally’s, and not only are they DELICIOUS, the staff is great at communicating and so friendly!! Highly recommend!!!!“

“Wonderful fresh homemade gluten free goodies! The breakfast sandwiches and pizzas are so good!“

“Brought these into the office for my co-workers because they are the most delicious cinnamon buns I have ever had. They were gone in seconds. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this bakery, I recommend it to everyone!“

“Had the Snickerdoodle & Pumpkin Spice cakes here & they were delicious 😋 Best cream cheese frosting I’ve ever had! Super moist & sweet cake! Cakes for any occasion will come from here from now on 🙌🏼“

“Me encantan desde años mis favoritos“

“The Mickey Mouse was so cute and delicious! Everyone remarked how incredible it was! Definitely going to get more cakes from them.“

“These cookies not only look amazing, but they taste just as good. We tried these for the first time this week and we were thoroughly impressed. Highly recommend these.“

“Exquisite Sweets is our family staple for special occasions. Simone is the BEST. Beautiful and great tasting cakes, cakes pops, candied apples and strawberries just to mention a few of her specialties. Book orders with Exquisite Sweets. You can’t and will not go wrong because this talented and dedicated to her business lady won’t do you wrong.“

“Highly recommend. Excellent experience. The atmosphere and staff were very welcoming and friendly. Thank you for the coffee(s) and meeting space. See you soon!“

“Belated review…Caryn made chocolate cupcakes for my daughter’s 3rd/4th grade birthday treat. All the kids LOVED them!! And they looked so pretty! Healthy and food allergy friendly was a plus too 😍“

“I recommend all of them. So far. haven't had one I have not totally enjoyed“

“I had such a nice experience at Brookfield crumbl. I didn't get the names of the associates, but they were so kind to my dumb ass walking in not knowing what to do. I got two boxes of minis and they were quick, nice, and got me out the door in record time. You guys are great!!“

“Just ok. Probably not worth a second trip. Chaotic service. Breakfast sandwiches are not made on site. I woukd not recommend. Too many probably better choices in the area.“

“Amazing! Definitely recommend“

“Visited for the first time today and absolutely loved the food, decor and service. 10/10 Can't wait to come try breakfast.“

“Cookies weren't bad, they were pretty good I just wish they were a little warmer and I didn’t like how the chocolate chip cookie and the s'mores cooking was a-bit crunchy an I don’t like that texture.. I prefer soft cookies but they mostly tasted fine.“