26 Best American Restaurants near Conover

“The deep dish pizza was definitely worth the wait!! The Old Fashions were perfect and the staff was a lot of fun! Great experience!“

“There on a Thursday night; had the Smoked Meatloaf with Baby Reds and maybe Asparagus. Outstanding meal. Top 10 for me over the last 15-20 years. Would eat it once a week. Fun place with a large bar, good tap-beer selection, good service, and plenty of room to sit.“

“Just had one their Classic Double cheeseburgers with grilled onions. It was the best burger I’ve had in a long time. Delicious!!! Thanks“

“Their pizza is outstanding, no matter what crust style you like. We prefer the thin, and it always eats big with flavor. And the staff are always so nice!“

“I love this place! The outdoor deck overlooks the lake with spectacular views you can’t get in town. I was able to bring my dog and I saw many families. They have a large assortment of drinks and the food I had was delicious. Prices are in line with all the restaurants in the area. If you have a boat there is a large dock.“

“Very welcoming with exceptional service! The atmosphere was very nice! Chef Emily was able to make a special meal just for me to accommodate my dietary lifestyle. Family owned and operated. A must try!“

“The Bear Trap Inn: A journey back to Wisconsin supper club paradise the Bear Trap In truly embodies the spirit and tradition of a classic Wisconsin supper club, offering an evening that feels less like dinner and more like a cherished ritual. From the moment you step in, the ambiance evokes a sense of nostalgia, with the warm glow of low lighting and the comfort of plush seating. The evening began with a carefully crafted drink in the bar area. The bartender's expertise in preparing my cocktail of choice was evident, served in a classic heavy-bottomed glass. While sipping my cocktail, conversations with fellow patrons at the lively bar felt effortless, creating a sense of community that is a hallmark of the supper club experience. The dining room, though busy, maintained a comfortable intimacy. The menu, a testament to classic American fare, offered tempting choices from steak and seafood to the quintessential Friday night fish fry. After a brief wait, which allowed for more conversation and anticipation, orders were taken by the friendly and efficient server, Maddie. The meal began with some delicious cheese curds and Tomato Bisque setting the stage for the culinary journey (highly recommend soaking your curds in the bisque). My entree arrived hot and artfully presented. The Pork Ribeye rumored to be a specialty, exceeded expectations, cooked medium-rare and boasting flavor and tenderness. The side dish of Parmesan Risotto was absolutely AMAZING and was suggested by Madi. Even with generous portions, the meal concluded with a huge piece of homemade Carrot Cake. It was a fitting end to a memorable meal, and a testament to the supper club tradition. Bear Trap In. delivers on the Wisconsin supper club experience, combining delicious food, attentive service, and a welcoming atmosphere that invites guests to enjoy the company of friends and family or even by yourself 😉. Guests will certainly return for another taste of this tradition. Thank you Madi for yet another excellent dinning experience and always being so welcoming!“

“The biscuits & gravy are by far the best I have ever had! We were in Eagle Rover for the weekend & went there on Saturday. After the first great breakfast. we had to try it again on Sunday! They did not disappoint. It is worth waiting to get in!“

“Best supper club experience in so long! Friendliest owners/staff..kid friendly..great food! We all left with smiling faces & happy bellies.. WILL BE BACK!“

“The staff was great , the ribs were delicious. The rest of our group had the prime rib and said the same. Will definitely go back.“

“We have always loved the food and service“

“Fantastic joint. Stopped in on the way through from Marquette to Chippewa Falls. Connor is a great bartender and the kid working in the kitchen is on point. Try the horseradish, just not too much. I'll be back for sure!“

“Absolutely brilliant bar. We try and go every time we're in Eagle River. ❤️“

“very friendly service and fun staff. I ordered a spicy bloody and it did not disappoint! came properly fully dressed and all. food was also amazing. definitely recommend for a good place to chill and eat.“

“Always a good idea!“

“Great food, great service and very clean.“

“There is not a thing on the menu that isn't great. The staff is friendly and accommodating. They make you feel at home.“

“Beautiful, friendly place. Our lunch was delicious!“

“We stopped in after our round of golf. It was after 8 and they close at 9. We were seated promptly and waited on right away with great service. The food was really good and came out super fast. We were not sure if we were able to eat being close to closing time but we were still served with a smile. We will be back next time we are up and the view was Beautiful!!!“

“Love the coffee! Staff is always friendly even when there’s a rush of customers. Seating area is comfortable for visiting with friends, reading, or working on my computer. I highly recommend getting your morning brew here!“

“Wonderful food and family friendly clean restaurant! Great service and atmosphere! Loved the Hawaiian grilled chicken pineapple sandwich!“

“The bacon cheeseburger pizza is a must try!“

“Awesome stay !! clean rooms and friendly staff! Dinner was outstanding and the pool and hot tub was a perfect way to finish the night!“

“Great little local location for a large group. Great atmosphere. Something on the menu for everyone. Great burgers, pulled pork sandwiches, appetizers, and wings. Their taco salad needs some attention (burnt tasting taco bowl shell and flavorless taco meat). Fabulous table service. Would highly recommend and will be back.“

“We stopped on our way home and we had a great time. Shayna “Agnes” was fantastic and fun. We had great food, drinks, and service. We will definitely stop again when we get back up there.“