10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Eagle River

“The best pizza around! We went here with a free coupon from our boat storage/marina. We will be back. Super friendly staff—delicious pizza—homemade crust and sauce—next time we will try the homemade sausage….we also see pizza casserole? And we were told about Pickle Soup? Sounds great to us!!“

“💯 recommend. Good stuff behind the bar. Great pretzels. But biggest reason why I love Andy's? The vibe, the community connection, the spirit and attitude. Fantastic all the way around.“

“very friendly service and fun staff. I ordered a spicy bloody and it did not disappoint! came properly fully dressed and all. food was also amazing. definitely recommend for a good place to chill and eat.“

“Always a good idea!“

“The bowling was fun. The bartender in the hawian looking shirt doesn’t acknowledge customers standing at the bar he just repeatedly walked past me and my sister-in-law. No tip for him but the guy that got me a box for my leftovers got $5 for just being willing to help.“

“I will be a frequent flyer here! What a great experience! Went in to just check it out and was greeted with a friendly smile. There were rhubarb strawberry pies coming out of the oven and I was able to buy one to take home!! How lucky is that!!! Purchased a sour dough based cranberry walnut bread too with a huge cookie. Got to chat with the owner, Jo!! Super nice!“

“Great service. Great people. And the baked chicken wings were phenomenal! Definitely will order again.“

“Great local bar with great food and an amazing staff!“

“The deep dish pizza was definitely worth the wait!! The Old Fashions were perfect and the staff was a lot of fun! Great experience!“

“There on a Thursday night; had the Smoked Meatloaf with Baby Reds and maybe Asparagus. Outstanding meal. Top 10 for me over the last 15-20 years. Would eat it once a week. Fun place with a large bar, good tap-beer selection, good service, and plenty of room to sit.“