9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Eagle River

“The best pizza around! We went here with a free coupon from our boat storage/marina. We will be back. Super friendly staff—delicious pizza—homemade crust and sauce—next time we will try the homemade sausage….we also see pizza casserole? And we were told about Pickle Soup? Sounds great to us!!“

“very friendly service and fun staff. I ordered a spicy bloody and it did not disappoint! came properly fully dressed and all. food was also amazing. definitely recommend for a good place to chill and eat.“

“Always a good idea!“

“Update: we went back again today and it was a night and day difference!! The food was delicious the staff was incredibly friendly as well. Today we paid 101 and we all bowled and extra game had 2 appetizers and 2 pizzas!! WELL WORTH IT!! We were there 2.5 hours and left satisfied with fun bars full!!

Was a frustrating ordeal from the start. We were not able to order food as there was another party going on. So we decided we would bowl less and go somewhere else to eat. My son is in area for next 6 months for AWI so I’m hoping it’s not always like this. Then when we left bill was 57 dollars. 3 people 2 games with shoes =39 1 pitcher of watered down mtn dew-18$?? when I questioned it I was the problem even though the girl who got us the ONE pitcher of soda was the one who checked us out. I told her to reverse it if she could and keep it as a tip but it was not good customer service I very clearly was overcharged. Not a huge amount but we were there an hour-pretty pricey hour of fun. We will be back for another try ordering zero drinks but if I’m disappointed again, then never again Rhinelander ain’t far 🤷‍♀️ ohhh and the vending machine was NoT working which is why I had to order the overpriced soda to begin with. 😬“

“I will be a frequent flyer here! What a great experience! Went in to just check it out and was greeted with a friendly smile. There were rhubarb strawberry pies coming out of the oven and I was able to buy one to take home!! How lucky is that!!! Purchased a sour dough based cranberry walnut bread too with a huge cookie. Got to chat with the owner, Jo!! Super nice!“

“Favorite pizza and always so willing to help with team lunches at work!“

“Great local bar with great food and an amazing staff!“

“The deep dish pizza was definitely worth the wait!! The Old Fashions were perfect and the staff was a lot of fun! Great experience!“

“There on a Thursday night; had the Smoked Meatloaf with Baby Reds and maybe Asparagus. Outstanding meal. Top 10 for me over the last 15-20 years. Would eat it once a week. Fun place with a large bar, good tap-beer selection, good service, and plenty of room to sit.“