“My wife and I stopped in for a bite to eat with my uncle. We ordered a pizza and some cheese curds to come out first. The curds were delicious and the pizza that followed was excellent ??. Every one of the staff was friendly and made for a pleasant dinning experience. The owner greeted us when we entered and took time to visit with us before we left. Highly recommend this place. Look forward to eating here again.“
“Total traditional supper club! with a unique charm this restaurant is a popular eatery amongst the locals and tourists who are soon to be regulars. Our food was cooked over a wood fire grill, and served over a table side grill. Service was exceptional! And drinks are a delight, I skipped dessert due to finishing all of my food (expected) stuffed. Portions are decent, would definitely recommend for first timers. PS, I'll let you find out about in house made dressing and fantastic wedge salad.“
“Omgggg I know I’m a mediocre cook.. but this place… wonderful service- Danny was excellent; the food…. Outstanding!! - and the design… right up Mike’s alley!! And I should mention great company!! Can you believe I didn’t get pics of our meals… I was too excited to grub!!! And coming soon to a door front near me… the screw address sign. Lol If you’re ever in Eagle River… DO NOT skip the #TheCraftsmanAmericanTavern #ajobwelldoneDietary restrictions: Had vegetarian and gluten free options“