“If you like pie, you need to come here! The Pie Lady is passionate about what she does, and will make sure you leave with something you like, that you will have time to bake to perfection. She discouraged us from getting a whole pie, because we weren’t sure we would be home long enough that evening to bake it properly, suggesting instead several of the small individual pies, and they did indeed take a long time to bake, so we enjoyed them for breakfast - so delicious! They encourage you to call, but even had several varieties of gluten free pie in stock.Dietary restrictions: They had several kinds of whole and small individual gluten free pies available frozen when we stopped in, but offer a larger selection if you call ahead of time.“
“My wife and I booked Pink Bakery to do our wedding cake in October of 2023. Kim was incredibly helpful in helping us make decisions and providing options for cakes and desserts. She was very accessible and always responded when we had questions, both via email and on the phone. We were also able to adjust our order according to the final guest list, she was very accommodating! We are very grateful that she was able to deliver the cake herself to Sturgeon Bay, and it was absolutely fantastic. We opted for a vanilla cake with raspberry compote and a chocolate ganache drizzle for our cutting cake, and then cookies & cream cakes for the other guests. These are, by far, the best cakes I’ve ever had. Our guests devoured the cakes, leaving very little left over! You will not be disappointed by Pink Bakery for your special occasion.“