18 Best Bakeries near Genesee Depot

“Absolutely delicious cookies and they are always beautiful!! You almost feel bad eating them! Key word- almost 😉“

“We had the most beautiful first fiesta cake for my daughter’s birthday. It was beyond my expectations and everyone raved about it. Thank you so much!!“

“I enjoy Crumbl cookies. I like the texture and their brownies are amazing. Different choices every week and the frosting is so buttery/sugary delicious. The girls helped with the process and were super friendly as I had questions and the smell had me ‘excited and a sugar high’ from the start 😋😊 definitely a fun treat and the store is busy!!“

“I love the Coffee Talk Bakery! The baked goods are always fresh and so delicious. The bathroom is huge, handicap accessible and always clean. The service is friendly, fast and efficient. the outdoor patio is so peaceful to sit in and enjoy a cup of coffee. The parking lot is well maintained and just had new very striaght lines put in. This hidden gem is a breath of fresh air after being in the city all day! I would definitely recommend and will be visiting again.“

“Amazing!!!! My friend and I stopped in to get a gf muffin and I walked out buying many items. ALL were so delicious! This is probably one of THE BEST all gluten free bakeries I've ever visited. It will definitely be a staple stop whenever I'm in town visiting. You have to check it out!🙌🥰“

“GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE+1(8O5)-41O 5OO2 NO NONSENSE AND GREAT ASSISTANCE!!!“

“Brought these into the office for my co-workers because they are the most delicious cinnamon buns I have ever had. They were gone in seconds. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this bakery, I recommend it to everyone!“

“My wedding cake was amazing! So pretty and very yummy. My guests couldn’t stop talking about it. There was barely any left by the end of the night. And so happy we saved the rest of our top tier for our anniversary next year. Thanks Aly!“

“Melissa at Mama Ducky’s Desserts recently made the cupcakes for my baby sprinkle. They were a huge hit and everyone kept asking where we got them from! 🧁 Mama Ducky’s is our go to for desserts, hot ham on Sundays and if you’re craving a delicious, reasonably priced breakfast you should check them out! 😊“

“I called with a bit of a special request at the last minute. The cheesecake turned out to be awesome and I will definitely be returning with my next request.“

“I’ve been to Beach Bum Bakery a few times now. From the items I’ve had (donuts, cookies, cupcakes and breakfast sandwich) most items have been good. I was there recently on a weekend morning to get donuts and a breakfast sandwich. As I was there it went from just a two people in the shop to 15 people, thankfully I had ordered prior to all these people arriving. The two employees working did seem a little overwhelmed and frantic. I was able to get my donuts in a timely manner but the breakfast sandwich took about 25 minutes to get and it only had one small/thin piece of bacon on it that was torn in half.
Note: the employees were very kind, I could just see the distress on their faces and they were trying to get caught up. The other times I’ve been here the service has been much quicker than what I experienced.“

“We got all our buns for my sons graduation party they did a great job!!! We had burgers and brats. They said they've never done brat buns but willing to try. They were great. hot out of the oven literally. Thanks Again!!!!“

“We used Periwinkle's Bakery for the dessert bar at our wedding on 9.9.2023 and I can say their desserts are a crowd pleaser!! Everyone loved the desserts and I loved how they cut them into half pieces rather than the whole piece. We had roughly 150 guests and we ordered 5 large platters and ended up with one extra platter by the end of the night so it worked out perfectly!“

“Highly recommend. Excellent experience. The atmosphere and staff were very welcoming and friendly. Thank you for the coffee(s) and meeting space. See you soon!“

“An Ocon hidden gem! Fantastic coffee and friendly service in an adorable shop.“

“I had never been to this place and our family met at Rochester Deli recently. This is a quaint little restaurant with really great food. It’s sort or hidden downtown Waukesha from someone like me who just happens to be passing through the area. We were all able to find something to eat from the menu. There were small children in our group that had difficulty finding something to eat from the menu. They eventually decided on plain hotdogs.

The adults had no problems finding anything to eat here. Each sandwich comes with a bag of chips and you can purchase a drink as well. Our group was very complimentary on the large lemonade from their cooler. I’m not a sandwich person but I found something from the menu. I love chicken Parm sandwiches and Rochester Deli makes one of the better ones that I have eaten. The bread was toasted perfectly, the tomato sauce had a nice kick to it and the sandwich was so delightful that I found myself taking smaller bites because I didn’t want to finish the sandwich too soon. I almost ordered a second one I liked it that much.

Everyone enjoyed what they ordered and the atmosphere was quiet and family friendly. I would definitely recommend Rochester Deli. We stayed and chatted for awhile after eating and the atmosphere was accommodating for chit chat among our group.“

“Just ok. Probably not worth a second trip. Chaotic service. Breakfast sandwiches are not made on site. I woukd not recommend. Too many probably better choices in the area.“

“My wife and I don't get here often but we do love the pies and other bakery that we purchase. Unfortunately we stopped Saturday march 8th 2025 and bought a lemon poppy seed muffin and when we opened it the next day for breakfast it was dried out. this is the first and only time we were disappointed with something we bought. We ate it with a cup of hot coffee and the flavor was great. We will be back again and I'm sure what we purchase will be awesome!“