New American Restaurants near Genesee Depot, WI

“This is such a hidden gem! I’ve driven past many times and always wanted to stop - we finally did this evening and everything was so delicious! There’s a great variety of items on the menu without being overwhelming. We ordered the any day fish fry and it came with not 3, not 4, but 5 generous pieces! Potato salad and coleslaw were also good (and that’s saying a lot - I don’t enjoy coleslaw!) as well as the chicken portebella sandwich special (so good!). The pumpkin cheesecake was also delicious. We will definitely be back!!“

“Tofte’s Table is hands-down the best date night restaurant in Waukesha. The food is always delicious. This time, we had the braised short ribs, scallops, mushroom risotto, and maple bacon Brussels sprouts. Seriously delicious. The staff was engaging and provided excellent recommendations for wine pairings. 10/10 recommend Tofte’s Table! We will be back soon!“

“My wife and I love this place! We like to come early on the weekends to have ourselves a little day date before the kids get up. The food is always consistently good and satisfying. The service is always there when you need them. This place closes early so get there while you can!“

“I can absolutely recommend the Hilton Garden Inn Bar and Grill at Pabst Farm in Oconomowoc, WI! The food is awesome, and I would say that the burger is the best in town. The wings are fantastic, and on Mondays they are 40 cents a piece! The dry rubs and wet sauces are all specially prepared and are very good!The rest of the menu, along with the weekly specials, are all great value and prepared with fresh ingredients and care by the Garden Inn chefs, Tammy and Will.Service at the bar is great. Emily, Lisa, Heather and Dan are all accomplished bar tenders, very personable and provide great service.There is no better spot to land for a great meal and great service in Oconomowoc - please stop by and enjoy an evening at the Garden Inn Bar and Grill!“

“Shanahan's is the place to go. Way better than Brew52 - a chill spot to read, do work, or be with friends. Seasonal drinks are always the bomb (but their regular menu is a great go-to). Love love their thai chicken salad (so gooddd) and all of their coffee. I always get one coffee drink and then one light seltzer drink and I feel light and happy the rest of the day. Absolutely go here!“

“Fantastic dining experience! You’ve gotta try the square cheese curds, our burgers were juicy and flavorful, cooked perfect. Pulled pork sandwich was tender and tasty. Bbq pizza was awesome, loved the crust. Great service and food that tastes like it’s supposed to is a win!“

“My husband and I went for dinner this evening and we would HIGHLY recommend Artisan 179!! The live music, our waitress Kelly, the drinks & the food were all amazing. The best dining experience we’ve had in awhile. We will 100% be back!“

“First time customers, the wait staff was very attentive and very friendly, the food was average. Came for breakfast. It was very not busy and we were served in less then 10 mins of arriving. Very fast service, very friendly, reasonably priced.“

“We are never disappointed! From entering, would definitely recommend a reservation!, the service and the food...delicious beyond what you will get anywhere! So impressed. The choices vary vastly so read the menu's carefully as we all have preferences. The attention to detail at Belfre; so solid! Enjoy.“

“We had a cocktail at this establishment quite some time ago and it was OK. We came back to town and decided to have cocktails and dinner. Maddy our bartender was amazing. Great personality, and knowledgeable in her craft. Then on to dinner the food was awesome and Chris our server was spot on. Im in the food service industry and my expectations are pretty high. You definitely surpassed my standards. Thank you Christopher(server) and Maddy ( best lemon drop martini ever) for taking care of us. See you next time.I would be remiss if I mention Chris who cemented a great night with his great humorD. BayneWausa“

“We ordered the battered cod and half the fish was pollack and the other was cod. The pollack was so fishy tasting the dog wouldn't even eat it. It went down the garbage disposal. Fries were overcooked, almost burnt. Salad was all leaves, no tomato except for 2 tiny pieces.The bun was the best of the whole meal.Tally's has always been our go to for fish fries. Always excellent. Hopefully our next visit will be better or we'll be on the hunt for a new place.“

“I come in here all the time and the food and service is always amazing. I ate at the bar with my parents and Caterina was our bartender and server. best server i’ve had in a very long time. she was super energetic, bubbly and just so sweet!! definitely recommend coming here :)“

“Food was great, our waitress was absolutely fun and fantastic, the atmosphere friendly and welcoming. I usually am petty wary of places with a huge varied menu, but Amalia's surprised me with the delicious meal. It's a bit far otherwise I would be back more often.And just remember, if you have any questions or doubt, Maya knows best!“

“This was a really great dining experience. The service was outstanding, good atmosphere, great drinks, and the food was very good with generous portion sizes. The reason for 4 stars was that the desert was a miss for me. I would absolutely eat here again.“

“I always enjoy the food when I come here. They have a very large selection of food. The service is always amazing. Not to mention the interior design is elegant and very beautiful. It has a very nice consistent theme to it as well. I would recommend this restaurant.“

“The service is excellent the food is always the best in Oconomowoc. The staff is lead by the best general manager in town,Emily she makes sure that everything is perfect. No place I'd rather eat they have tons of meatless options which is great!!“

“First time at Zesti, for my birthday and we will be back as a regular in the rotation for sure. The menu is diverse and nicely different than other restaurants. A great choice of pastas, salads, beef, pork, chicken, seafood, pizza and deserts. Full choice of beverages with a great wine list and a surprisingly inexpensive evening! Also, Brandon was our server and did a great job explaining dishes and taking care of us in a very casual, friendly way. Thanks Chef Feker and crew!“

“Ella's was near a friend's house so we decided to stop there for dinner. It's nice inside with ample room. Expansive drink menu with a good selection of bourbons. I got a Four Roses on the rocks. We got some cheese curds for an appetizer that was good. It a mix of white and yellow curds. I got a side salad and then the Tomahawk Chop, which is a bone in pork chop. There was an apple chutney on the chop, which was very good. It came with mashed potatoes and choice of vegetables, and I chose the asparagus. Overall, a positive experience. I really liked the old posters on the walls for Milwaukee beer companies. I will be back.Parking: Most parking is across from the restaurant in a lot.Kid-friendliness: There are kids menus and sippy cups.“