Customers` Favorites
“This was our first visit because our normal Amish bakery is now only open on weekends, and it did not disappoint. Great bakery and canned products with reasonable prices.”
Customers` Favorites
“Wonderful food and drinks. Wendy and her staff are the best! Come try it out...you won't be disappointed!”
Customers` Favorites
“always friendly and great consistent food for dine in or take out”
Customers` Favorites
“A true gem from the kind, hardworking Amish community makes this an absolute must stop if you are anywhere within a 4-hour driving distance. Everything we bought was the best we ever had. Must tries are the pies, cinnamon rolls, pumpkin bars, and donuts. We did not try the pretzels this time around, but they were selling fast so definitely keep an eye out for those.
Few tips and asks:
-CASH ONLY
-The bakery is in the building on the left-hand side past the parking lot area, follow the concrete sidewalk around the corner and through the little white door.
-Please show respect and drive with care when sharing the road with their community. We saw many people (mostly who were clearly from out of state/town) speeding around the horse buggies and kicking up dirt in the parking lot.”
Customers` Favorites
“Good food, large portion.”
“The people here are great. Drink prices are really good, and overall atmosphere is fun.”
Customers` Favorites
“EVERYTHING FROM START TO FINISH WAS PERFECT. 1. DRINKS WERE PERFECT 2. SERVICE WAS EXCELLENT AND SERVER WAS FRIENDLY AND VERY ATTENTIVE 4. FISH WAS VERY TASTY, HOT, AND DONE JUST RIGHT 5. WERE NOT RUSHED AND WAS A NICE EVENING AND MEAL. 6. WE WILL RETURN SOON !!!!!!!!!!!”
Customers` Favorites
“Absolutely 100% recommend! We happened upon Reilly's Pub by chance as we were driving home from Grand Valley Campground this past weekend. They were packed, but had a table for us immediately and we never felt that we were waiting on service, drinks or food. Our server, Sean, was amazing! He was obviously swamped, but still so attentive! Superb service! 🙌🙌🙌 also, drink recommendations were excellent! Our food was so delicious! We ordered the cheddar blocks, sweet Thai chili wings, kids mac n cheese, and the southwest shrimp salad. I cannot put into words how delicious that salad was. 🤤 and the family was raving about their meals as well!! I'll be counting the days until our next camping trip so we can make it back to Reilly's!”
Customers` Favorites
“Incredible Food! Prime, Burgers, Steak, Fish, Chicken, I had it all pretty much. Different Cooks, Waitresses, and Bartenders from a year ago. Great Owners who have a good name and seem to have a team that cares and puts customers first. I highly recommend this Restaurant ? karaoke? , Bands, Raffles, you name it!”
Customers` Favorites
“I was there today, 5/9, and I just want to give a shoutout to Amelia. There were a lot of factors against her, being out of some food items, getting a little busy, and trying to keep the line moving. They were out of turkey but instead she went to the back and sliced me fresh turkey without me even asking. When we saw that they had no mayo left, she went on a mission to find more. She was great and even apologized for making me wait just a couple minutes longer! She did great at keeping everyone happy.”
Loading...
“Great times with Old and News friends.Cant go wrong with the local bar in town”