Customers` Favorites
Customers` Favorites
“Wonderful food and drinks. Wendy and her staff are the best! Come try it out...you won't be disappointed!”
Customers` Favorites
“Absolutely amazing! The food is always warm and fresh out of the oven, and it’s affordable. I purchased three donuts today for $3 and those donuts were one of the best I’ve ever had; they are not processed, but made locally by hand. The atmosphere is pleasant; bakers were singing.”
“My husband an I have been there twice now, and will definitely go back. Food is delicious, great service, and cute inside. Love prints done by local artists too.”
Customers` Favorites
“One of the truly best eating places in Montello. I always recommend it to my friends. The soups are divine and the salads are always fresh and lovely to look at.”
Customers` Favorites
“Excellent homemade pizza. Cozy, inviting and friendly. Highly recommend for burgers, steak sandwiches and the pizza!!!!”
“Carol's Cones did not disappoint! I ordered an amazing espresso cookies and cream shake, my son the freedom sundae.... DELICIOUS 😋 So good in fact, we ate them in their glory!”
Customers` Favorites
“Amazing food and pizza! We eat here a few times a month and it’s always great service, great food and very well priced.”
“Stopped in for a bite to eat while traveling. Loved the charming atmosphere and everything was delicious!”
Customers` Favorites
“always friendly and great consistent food for dine in or take out”
Customers` Favorites
“Great Food & amazing service. Eva (i think) was our waitress's name. very friendly and on top of everything. pizza was done quick too ;) we havr a 2nd home in Packwaukee so I think we will be back often!! thanks”
Customers` Favorites
“Amazing food and pizza! We eat here a few times a month and it’s always great service, great food and very well priced.”
“Love the Fresh Baked Donuts with blackberry glaze. It was so good i only let my boyfriend have one bite of the 2nd donut even tho it was his lol i just couldnt share it all. And i know my donuts n sweets as i run a bakery myself. and the couple that runs it are kind and nice. 😊”
“My husband and I bought a cabin in Coloma this summer and discovered the Town Pump in Montello on a UTV ride to the Amish. Destiny is a great bartender and just the sweetest little thing! We loved stopping in to see her on Thursday mornings whenever we got the chance. We aren’t typically “bar” people, but this place is always clean, welcoming, and full of the friendliest patrons. Awesome popcorn too!! The candle shop next door is a fun bonus for me. Sad to be home for the winter. Destiny, we wish you a great school year and hope to see you again next summer!-- Joan & David”
Customers` Favorites
“Our server Allen was exceptional! What a great personality!! He did a great job at explaining the food options and they tasted as good as he described. He really made us feel like valued customers, almost like family. He's a real gem. So glad we tried Smokin' Oak BBQ and we will definitely be back on our next trip to Montello. Thanks to the cooks for the delicious eats and THANK YOU ALLEN for making our dinner special!!”
“Great times with Old and News friends.Cant go wrong with the local bar in town”
Customers` Favorites
“We drive from Oshkosh and camp up the road in Montello. I love this place, best burgers ever! All the food we have had has been amazing. We love the atmosphere, Jeff is so funny, rest of staff is very friendly. Highly recommend this place.”
“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”
“Bob and Kris are great people and do so much for their community !!”
Customers` Favorites
“Cute little diner and the best burger I’ve had in a long time. Everyone in the family enjoyed their meals. We’ll definitely be back to give breakfast a try!”
Customers` Favorites
“Excellent home cooked food!!! Delicious homemade jellies, sweet ladies, just like grandmas house!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ we will be back!!! ❤️🇺🇸”
Customers` Favorites
“Fabulous food, friendly staff & fast service! Homemade soups & desserts are amazing! We always have a great meal at Sparks!”
Customers` Favorites
“Great burgers…great staff…great atmosphere. This is officially on the go to list going forward.”
“Was there for an Honor Guard memorial service. We didn't use the facility inside, but there was a nice meeting room area and a small bar area. Food would need to be catered in.”
Customers` Favorites
“Food is good, some staff are nice and helpful, others rude and ignore you as long as they can. The 20% on to-go fees is absolutely ridiculous!! The previous owners started this with covid and the new owners kept it. Charge a to-go fee for the containers is reasonable, but if you order a couple burgers and fries you are paying more than if you sat down and ate at a restaurant!!! I refuse to go there and pay such an astronomical fee!”
Customers` Favorites
“We had a little mix up with our order, but Kathleen made it right and that cake was absolutely delicious! My mother in laws 80th birthday went off without a hitch. Thank you so much.”
Customers` Favorites
“My favorite breakfast place. People are friendly. Service is great. Food is yummy!”
Customers` Favorites
“Friendly service, delicious food, charming atmosphere.”
Customers` Favorites
“Always great service and the sandwiches were great too. We drive ten miles and haven't been let down once.”
Customers` Favorites
“Happened upon by chance before a Cross Country meet. Easy as could be to get food and drinks. Friendly and prompt. But wow, the BBQ, and also the side are like candy. You'll appreciate the paper towel rolls at the tables while you stuff your face 😆 Will have to visit again in summer to enjoy to outdoor deck.”
Loading...
“Great place to purchase awesome, fresh favorful baked goods. Sorry no pics to share, just have to trust me on this! Love picking up cream cheese covered cinnamon rolls! Remember to bring cash or check for payment. There is an assortment of pickled goods, breads, donuts, pies and more; plus other handmade non-edible Amish creations. Enjoy@”