Castaway's on the Island
$$ •
Hours:
131 Clinton St, La Crosse
(608) 519-9700
About Castaway's on the Island
Customers' Favorites
Castaway's on the Island Reviews
Share your opinion about Castaway's on the Island
We had the BEST meal there. Everyone was beyond pleased with their meal. The walleye meal, the beef tips and pasta were amazing.
This is a hidden gem. the food has been delicious the few times we have been there since coming to town. awesome apps, great entrees and killer desserts.
Some of the best food I’ve eaten in a long time. Large portions and despite being a packed house, the service was timely. Definitely returning.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
.jpg)
Castaway's on the Island is a hidden gem in La Crosse, WI, offering a delightful dining experience. The restaurant features a fantastic selection of drinks and a surprising menu. The Mahi Mahi with risotto stood out, praised for being fresh and full of flavor. The encrusted walleye with a blanc wine sauce, served with rice pilaf and asparagus, was highlighted as a special that impressed diners. The Friday night fish, shrimp, risotto, and brussel sprouts were also delicious. The casual and comfortable atmosphere is complemented by friendly and attentive staff. Bartender Patrick is known for being super attentive and kind, providing great recommendations. The view from the big windows behind the bar showcases beautiful scenery, including seagulls and bald eagles flying over the river. The $4 martini night is a must-try, and the chocolate lava cake is a perfect way to end a meal. Castaway's on the Island is a place where good drinks, dinner, and merriment come together for a memorable dining experience. The attention to detail, such as serving a cold salad plate and a hot dinner plate, enhances the overall dining experience, making it a favorite spot for many.