27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lyons

“Stopped in on our way back from Lake Geneva. Never had been. Sundays they serve smoked meat from 12-8. We split the Divine B it was beef, caramelized onions, and candied bacon with our choice of two sides. The split it for us! The bartender was attentive, sweet, and talkative. Very welcoming! Lots of shenanigans if you're a dice shaker, including two different shake of the days and a wheel spin! Look forward to coming back for the duck races in August!“

“Came in with a group after a day skiing at alpine valley. Couldn’t have picked a better spot. The cook wasn’t in but the bartender juggled so we could get some much needed grub in our bellies. Her service/energy was exceptional. 10/10, would recommend.“

“I've eaten at Next Door Pub twice. Fantastic both times. The food is awesome, the menu is extensive, the service is very friendly and efficient. This place is ALWAYS packed, lunch or dinner. Locals love it. Very casual.Lots of seating for large or small groupsReasonable prices. Lots of parking. Highly recommend.“

“We had great experience, Sasha was amazing, interactive, friendly and professional. Food was yummy, great choices available on the menu for food and beverages with reasonable prices and pleasant atmosphere. We are from NZ and here for a few days, so definitely will be going back.“

“The most perfect pizzeria around. The service and cleanliness is top notch. The pizzas are made fresh with the highest quality ingredients around. Our family has enjoyed eating there as well as taking our pies to go. Always done to perfection. If you are in the area this is a must stop!!!!“

“I wish I could pick one thing to rave about but I can't because everything is amazing. The pizza, wings, burgers, beefs. All incredible! Wings are the best in town. You can tell they put everything into their product. Highly recommend.“

“My parents took me here for my Birthday with my son and our au pair. Great family dining experience. Seemed like a good place for a date night too. My son loved their pasta. I've never seen my 3 year old eat All of his dinner out before. He really loved their sauce! That says a lot about a place. Great flavors.“

“This was my first time patronizing this establishment. When I first walked in I was surprised at how busy it was, but we found a family just leaving so our wait time for a table was minimal. The waitress was extremely busy yet was able to keep up with her responsibilities. The food we ordered was very good. The atmosphere was energetic and positive. The only thing that I could say that may be a negative to some is that trying to hold a conversation was trying because of amount of noise. Overall, I really enjoyed my experience and would definitely come back again.“

“Yes!!!!! A pizza buffet and I am here for it! Amazing selections. Great quality! Awesome service! What you may not be aware of, you can tell them at the counter what type of crazy pizza you want made. They give you a buzzer and call you up when it's ready. They give you first dios and then add it to the array or other pizzas on the buffet. Dessert pizza! Salad, pasta, chicken....breadsticks...soup! I mean c'mon! This place is the cat's meow of buffets! All super fresh and hot! Service has always been top notch. Clean! Inviting and filling!“

“Amazing place! Couldn't extend my love enough for this place and the veryyy welcoming owners and regulars. They have a wild meat burger who is a wild boar, elk and bison burger all in one! And 75¢ BOMBBBB wings, everyday now! You HAVEE to stop in if you're in the area, otherwise YOU ARE MISSING OUTTT!!!!“

“Fantastic Dining Experience at Mama Cimino's Pizza with Exceptional Service from Carmen!I recently dined at Mama Cimino's Pizza in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, and it was truly a remarkable experience. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted by the lovely server, Carmen, who made us feel right at home. Her exceptional customer service truly enhanced our dining experience.The cheese curds we ordered as an appetizer were out of this world - so fresh and delicious! As for the main courses, both the chicken parmesan and chicken carbonara were absolutely divine. The flavors were rich and authentic, and every bite was a delight to the taste buds.As a Chicago native, I have high standards when it comes to Italian cuisine, and Mama Cimino's Pizza exceeded all expectations. The food here rivals that of any 5-star restaurant, and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a top-notch dining experience.If you find yourself in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, do yourself a favor and pay a visit to Mama Cimino's Pizza. You won't be disappointed! Thank you, Carmen, and the entire team at Mama Cimino's, for a memorable evening of great food and exceptional service. Five stars all the way!“

“Stopped by on a random weekend after doing a "close our eyes and pick a random spot on the map for a road trip". We didn't have food, but sat for a few cocktails. The local crowd was so fun and our bartender "Fiona" was a kick. (Not her real name but she knows who she is!) Speaking some code here, Fiona, don't get caught doing the superglue trick! Hope to see you at "Cabana's" some day but if not we"ll be back for sure.“

“It has been a long time since I had a pizza that impressed me. When we got there we saw all these pics of thick crust pizzas and were excited. We ordered and didn't know we had to ask for the thick crust and got a thin crust pizza instead. Instant disappointment! Then we grabbed a piece and started eating. That disappointment quickly changed to omg this is so good. We instantly knew we had to come back for the thick crust because if the thin crust was this good, the thick crust would be epic. Upon our next visit a week later, we found out we were right. This place was instantly my new favorite pizza spot.“

“Great Location overlooking the Lake Geneva lakefront. At the time of my visit it was very windy and cold but the view from the windows of this place was fenomenal. Very excited to come back during the summer month so that I can seat in their outside patio and really absorb a great experience. Overall place was very clean and the services was great. Food was good too. Will definately comeback as this location has a very lovely lakefront view and not to mentioned how close to the downtown area this is located. Parking can be diffcult to find as I wasn't aware if this particular establishment has it's own parking location, otherwise expect to park and pay in the public parking designated areas.“

“Luis’s is such a gem in Lake Geneva! We order carryout several times a month and our favorite items are the burritos and tacos- all of the meat options are delicious (barbacoa is a favorite) and the portions are generous with rice, beans and excellent tortilla chips as sides. The menu is large with many options and the remodeled restaurant is fantastic! Consistent quality and reasonable prices. Only suggestion is to be open more weekdays for dinner during your winter hours- we’d be there even more!!“

“Great burgers and amazing cheese curds. Went on a very busy Saturday night and they only has one server, a bartender and a bus boy for the whole place- they were trying their best but really need more staffing. Would eat here again, just maybe not at a peak time“

“If you're in the area, go here. They have an option on the menu to to the kitchen staff, it's called buy a round for the kitchen. Food was so delicious on multiple occasions that I buy a round for the kitchen on every visit.Try the wings with Jack Daniels Sweet Barbecue!!“

“We ordered 5 pizzas for a pizza party, each different due to people's dietary needs, all were delicious and very much appreciatedVegetarian options: Great pizza but red peppers would have been niceDietary restrictions: Gluten free crust was good, together with toppings was great“

“For sure our new go to place. Decided to try it out tonight reminds us of little ole restaurants back home in the southern small country towns we’re from. Blast from the past. The nostalgia is awesome! 10/10 recommend and the service and food were really great!“

“Go for the cheese curds! The rest of the menu is meh, but the curds are fantastic. Make a plate your whole meal.Views of the lake are lovely too. We only come here in winter, in the off season. During warm weather it's a mad house, but it does have a patio so it's pretty nice.I'm sure those cheese curds will call me back next time I'm in lake Geneva!“

“Everyone knows Gino's pizza is killer. The Italian roast beef was way good. The Lake Geneva location had a great view of the lake. We were staying in the joining hotel so it was also it was very convenient. A 10% discount for hotel stay was a bonus.The service, however, was terrible. My friend waited 20min to get silverware, I had walk up to the bar for another beer, gave up on wanting ketchup...“

“We go for a Drink at the Bar and Always get Food to go! We Love their salads, The Chicken Cacciatore, is very Flavorsome, The Main Course Items are Large Portions! Great Pizza their soups are Very Good! If your in the Mood for Italian Food Zumpano's is the Place to go in Burlington, WI!“

“I'm an idiot and ordered online to their Libertyville location.The Burlington location made the order and gave us free drinks while we waited.They refunded my card fir the Libertyville order and were absolutely top notch when it came to handling my stupid mistake.I'll be back as long as they're here.“

“Man… I think this is another one of those “great pizza” places that you’d never suspect. The Waterfront was recommended by a friendly neighbor and wow was it worth the trip. The pizza was great with nice thin and crispy crust-go for the Hawaiian-or any other for that matter!! The wait staff was short-but they were on the ball making sure every full table got adequate service! We definitely look forward to going back again to see the views over Browns Lake!! Great place for family or friends gathering with a decent separation of the bar and main dining area.“

“Very good pizza, fresh and hot, and they delivered quickly! The delivery driver was so patient and helpful while I was dealing with excited children and barking dogs even. This will now be my go-to pizza when I'm in town visiting my grandchildren!“

“Wow amazing food and hospitality!!!! Every different meal our tablet of 7 had was different and they all came out piping hot and delicious! Our waitress Sue was top notch and even sat with us a bit after dinner and talked! We will definitely be back!“