18 Best Italian Restaurants near Menasha

“Luigi’s is the closest it gets to an authentic Italian meal locally! I had lasagna and it was amazing! Would recommend to anyone and everyone wanting to try out something new and authentic!“

“the staff was amazing, their food was as good as ever. it was clean and quick and friendly“

“Great food and great service! Could not recommend more!“

“Everything about this place was wonderful. The staff are pleasent and knowledgeable, the atmosphere is great, and the food is fantastic! Our server was Sierra and she was so helpful with her recommendations.“

“Shout out to the bartender at the mutual way location. Drinks were 👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽
Always a great place to eat with huge portions that u most likely will take home half . #winning . Staff are friendly, curtious and prompt with everything that we needed“

“I've stayed at this hotel twice but never visited the restaurant on-site. A late flight in and a busy day ahead left me with limited choices, and I decided to check it out.The waitress/bartender was super helpful in answering questions I had concerning items on the menu.I decided on the pretzel bites and teriyaki chicken wings. She brought the pretzel bites out first, and although the beer cheese was not the best I've had, it was good.At the moment, my wings were brought out. I was so excited I told my husband who was on the phone with me that I would call him back because my favorite dish had arrived.I pushed my pretzel bites to the side and immediately dug into my wings to be immediately disappointed. They were cold! I reached down to the lower portion of the basket and tried another one, but it was also cold.The taste of the wings were amazing, but I could not eat them cold, so I asked them to be sent back. By the time my waitress got back to me for me to send them back, her explanation was that I had let them sit too long before eating. Hold up! What did you just say? I cook wings at home, and my family has to wait at least 5 mins before eating to prevent burning their mouths! I literally tried to eat these as soon as they were set before me!She was kind and removed the charge from my ticket but politely let me know that they were hot when she brought them out because they were personally cooked by their manager. I declined to comment that managers make mistakes, too.All good things start from leadership. Perhaps they need to implement corrective actions based on their customer complaints. Here's your sign.“

“I had an excellent experience at Olive Garden thanks to our waitress, Christina. She was incredibly friendly, attentive, and made sure our table had everything we needed without us even asking. She checked in at the right times, gave great recommendations, and made the meal feel extra special with her positive attitude. Her service was professional, warm, and genuine, which made our visit so enjoyable. I truly appreciate the effort she put into making our dinner a great one—she’s a wonderful representative of Olive Garden’s hospitality, Thank you, Christina!“

“Visited the new Menomonee Falls location today. Loved the wood fire pizza 🍕 you can choose between ones on the menu or make your own which is really cool. The layout for seating is really nice. There are games to play at the tables with kids or family which is a really cool idea. The staff is really friendly, will definitely be one of my go to local places.“

“Victorias is by far our favorite Italian restaurant. We have been going there for 26 years. Birthdays, anniversaries, family gatherings. We have not had a meal that was not delightful, and the service is always top notch. If you have not visited, you should put it on your list. If you have been there you know what I’m talking about. You go once and you will go back.“

“Hands down the best pizza I've had outside of Chicago! The deep dish rivals my favorites from my home town. Can't wait to come back. Just wish I didn't live 90 minutes away. Kudos!🙌“

“We went for our first time tonight and our takeout was food coma crazy good. The staff was incredibly nice!! 10⭐️s“

“The older gentleman with a pony tail was very friendly and patient while my son was deciding what he wanted. He also let my other son have a free chocolate milk, on the house. It is the little things in customer service that make it a wonderful visit. Thank you for the kind gesture.“

“Incredible food and service!! The employees are friendly, outgoing, and fun! We had lots of laughs with our waitress! Thank you Luigi's!!!“

“Kind servers and bar tenders, great salad bar, excellent menu I have NEVER had a single complaint. The food is five stars!⭐️“

“I love pizza. I moved to Kimberly only 3 days ago, so trying Butch's was a no-brainer. Got the 12" hand-tossed chicken alfredo, add pineapple. I'm hard-pressed to find anything bad about it. Crust was insanely crispy and the toppings/sauce had so much flavor. The was a delicious pizza“

“One of the best Italian meals I have had outside of Italy. It is definitely the best Italian food in the area, and one of our favorite restaurants to go to. There is almost always a wait, but it is worth it. Every dish we have had there has been outstanding. The bruschetta might be our favorite appetizer. The service is always good as well.“

“Been coming to cranky pat's for 30 years. Was in there today with my wife around 3pm. We were the only customers there. One waitress was on the phone with a customer and 2 others were in the area. We sat there for 20 minutes and not one ounce of service. A couple of walk bys but no service. Doesn't the help work together or just ignore customers? Got tired of no service for 20 minutes so we got up and went elsewhere. Nice way to lose lifelong customers........we won't be back.“

“love your pizza! Disappointed no locations in appleton anymore! last night we ordered, Grub hub delivered "God knows where? Not to us! when we tried to reorder/redeliver we were told not taking any more orders?? ( busy I guess) But, seriously, you just figure oh well too bad for us???? I und ER stand its Grub hubs fault, but you look pretty bad not having very good customer service!!!! meanwhile someone got a free pizza & cheese bread 😕😡“