50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Menasha

“Luigi’s is the closest it gets to an authentic Italian meal locally! I had lasagna and it was amazing! Would recommend to anyone and everyone wanting to try out something new and authentic!“

“Best take and bake pizza in the valley!“

“Menasha Glass Nickel is a small locally owned pizza joint with tons of options and friendly staff. They have a small dine in area, perfect for a quick stop for some delicious food. Delivery is fast and the food is hot. I highly recommend this place to all!“

“This location is BY FAR THE BEST Parker John's! The food is ALWAYS hot and on point!!! The service is ALWAYS friendly, attentive and on point! We will always travel to this specific location! ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS LOCATION!“

“The service was outstanding“

“Our family loves Toppers! They have great dairy-free options. Food at the Menasha location is always good. However, their hours are always changing and never posted online. They also do not update the main phone number so no one knows when they're open. If you're driving past the Menasha location, they may have a piece of paper with the hours for that day taped on the front door. Not helpful. Other than that, they're great!

Dietary restrictions: Dairy free cheese; vegan meat-free options“

“While family was visiting from Denver, we decided on bowling on a rainy day. Sabre Lanes had just opened and we piled out of the car to the door. A fun place to bring the kids. Everything was clean and a friendly staff. Perfect family place to spend quality time with family or friends. My only concern was the price. A bit more than my budget expected.“

“Delicious food but extremely tiny portions. Nice atmosphere just don't come hungry.“

“The only pizza my husband is allowed to get me from now on 😂 best pizza I've had in a long time“

“I don’t care, it’s just like Frank’s was. Prices are good. It’s a pizza that you can’t beat! No one comes close!“

“Hands down the best pizza I've had outside of Chicago! The deep dish rivals my favorites from my home town. Can't wait to come back. Just wish I didn't live 90 minutes away. Kudos!🙌“

“We went for our first time tonight and our takeout was food coma crazy good. The staff was incredibly nice!! 10⭐️s“

“the staff was amazing, their food was as good as ever. it was clean and quick and friendly“

“Incredible food and service!! The employees are friendly, outgoing, and fun! We had lots of laughs with our waitress! Thank you Luigi's!!!“

“Delicious pizza and great service. What more could you ask for?“

“The owners are some of the most kind and generous people I have ever known! They would bend over backwards for their family, staff and customers! I know as a former employee and current customer that they put their hearts and souls into their business! We love the food and will continue to support Pizza King!!“

“Love Sals, it’s a family tradition & excellent every time 🍕“

“$10 Tuesday Pizzas.The staff is friendly, greets you when you enter,and asks you if you need help (most customers are picking up pizzas from the online order rack) 9/10 Times my pizza is located on the rack within seconds and I am on my way, on the rare occasions it is not, my pickup time coincides with their busiest time, and the staff quickly corrects the issue and I am on the way.Good job everyone!

Parking: Reserved spots for pickup orders, so if not during a significant rush period easy in and out. The parking lot is adequate, however it is shared with a few other businesses so you may have to walk a row or park next to the building (oh no....) but in reality not a long walk by any means.

Kid-friendliness: There is no dine in so you will not be spending much time inside, but the staff is friendly there are glass partitions that allow a view of the pizza making process. (Among other things).

Wheelchair accessibility: No steps to enter the building or curb, also multiple dedicated handicap spots as I am sure are mandated by the ADA. The interior is open and would not make it difficult to navigate with a wheelchair/walker/etc“

“Stopped in on a recommendation, left with an eggplant Parm pie and yessir it’s good! Friendly chat with the owner and a great dinner! Try em out!“

“Great food and great service! Could not recommend more!“

“The owners are some of the most kind and generous people I have ever known! They would bend over backwards for their family, staff and customers! I know as a former employee and current customer that they put their hearts and souls into their business! We love the food and will continue to support Pizza King!!“

“Wow! This is the best pizza I’ve had in years! We bought a chicken bacon ranch and a bbq bacon pineapple and they were both incredible, wayy better than the other place with rectangle pizzas!“

“We just had a birthday party here on Sunday for our two 7 year old boys. We reserved a room with one of the party packages, which included a ranch hand, pizza, ice cream, drinks, gift bags and arcade cards for each kid, and very accommodating staff. Nick is always friendly and provides great service every time we visit.“

“Thank you Mike and Brenda for bringing the awesome pizzas to our neighborhood Halloween party. I hope you can join us next year, so fun. Everyone loved the pizza so good 👍“

“just ate there tonight with my dad and honestly was the best pizza around no lie. beautiful and nice waitress/ waitresses.“

“Visited the new Menomonee Falls location today. Loved the wood fire pizza 🍕 you can choose between ones on the menu or make your own which is really cool. The layout for seating is really nice. There are games to play at the tables with kids or family which is a really cool idea. The staff is really friendly, will definitely be one of my go to local places.“

“Just ordered pizza's it is spring break and all the kids r home we just had cheese but the girls ages 5,6 told me to tell the pizza maker he is the best pizza maker ever!!Thanks for helping a Mom out!!!!“

“I love pizza. I moved to Kimberly only 3 days ago, so trying Butch's was a no-brainer. Got the 12" hand-tossed chicken alfredo, add pineapple. I'm hard-pressed to find anything bad about it. Crust was insanely crispy and the toppings/sauce had so much flavor. The was a delicious pizza“

“One of the best Italian meals I have had outside of Italy. It is definitely the best Italian food in the area, and one of our favorite restaurants to go to. There is almost always a wait, but it is worth it. Every dish we have had there has been outstanding. The bruschetta might be our favorite appetizer. The service is always good as well.“

“Messed up my pizza two times. First said no pinions, put on red onions. I again Stated no onions, they remade it with green, I noticed right away. They asked if I would like to keep it and give it to someone I knew knowing we wouldn’t eat it. Gave it to the in-laws. They remade it for the third time correctly. The team was doing a great job working together under pressure as it was very busy and most likely embarrassed for the mistake. Took my name and next pizza was free. They did a great job and made it right. Stand up service!“

“Two of my favorite Papa Murphy's Pizzas ?? Bacon cheeseburger and Garlic Chicken! My girls do not like the cheeseburger one…. I didn't really either the first time I had it YEARS ago, because I usually do not like warm pickles. But the second time I had it, I fell in love with it! They stopped making it the same year I first tried it...they said it was a seasonal feature but it has been YEARS and they never brought it back until this year!!!!(2023)Idk how long they will have it for but if you haven't tried it yet you should!! ? It’s now 2024 and I haven’t checked to see if they have this pizza again but I will find out soon! Always fast and friendly service at the Calumet St. (kk) location!

Kid-friendliness: Mini pizza making kits for kids are awesome! Also cookie dough to bake cookies with the kiddos!“

“I ordered pizzas for our employees for lunch today. The thin crust and bread sticks cooked faster than the original crust so I had them start with that. I cooked them in the house and had to carry through the rain to the shop. Second pizza was cooked and upon entering the shop umbrella in tow...the pizza ended up face down on shop floor. I called a reorder in and when i arrived to pick it up i told them what had happened. They said this one is on us! Wonderful experience!“

“Great food and quick service! Definitely will return next time we’re in town“

“Been coming to cranky pat's for 30 years. Was in there today with my wife around 3pm. We were the only customers there. One waitress was on the phone with a customer and 2 others were in the area. We sat there for 20 minutes and not one ounce of service. A couple of walk bys but no service. Doesn't the help work together or just ignore customers? Got tired of no service for 20 minutes so we got up and went elsewhere. Nice way to lose lifelong customers........we won't be back.“

“Visited Urban Modern Kitchen with the husband to celebrate our anniversary and we had an absolute wonderful dining experience! Our waiter (unfortunately I forgot his name) was amazing and VERY personable. He made us feel important and he accommodated our every need. The food was amazing as well and it was prepared super fast! We didn’t have to wait long at all after we ordered. I got the Greek Bowl, husband got the Mexican Bowl. My husband can be picky, so I was a little nervous if he would like the food, but he loved it! We also shared some nachos, which he really liked as well. Everything from food to experience was top notch! Thank you!“

“This is one of my favorite restaurants in the Appleton area. However, I was disappointed with the front-desk folks’ lack of creative thinking and can-do attitude. When I called before arriving, I mentioned the number of people in my party and mentioned that I will also need a high chair. He said nothing available inside but patio is open and lots of seats are readily available. When we arrived, he was right, nobody was sitting in the patio. Bad news came after we were taken to our table, “sorry, we don’t have high chair available for at least another hour!” I understand that this may happen, but why do you tell me 5 mins before I arrive that you have everything available? Very disappointing, but this is even more disappointing when it comes from one of my favorite restaurants and I had guests with me.“

“Great food! Great service.“

“I may not have been the one that paid for the food that I picked up to deliver to someone else, but I'm still a customer and deserve to be treated like one. Or is that just how you talk to all your customers.... 🤔“

“Best pizza for your money in the area! � always tastes great! No complaints ever!“

“I used the online pre-order option to place my order with ease, but misjudged my pickup time. I went to the location early, and the staff was able to look up my order to start ahead of time, and got me going as soon as possible. Very accommodating and friendly, not to mention excellent pizza!“

“I ordered two Party Packages for an event that I had and they had everything ready when I picked it up and they even loaded it into my vehicle. My quests loved the food and kept asking where I got it from. The beef brisket was a fan favorite. I would definitely order from them again. If you are looking to serve a large group (I had over 100 people) and give them great food this is the place to go!“

“One of the better little ceasers in the state. They almost always have hot and ready unlike Oshkosh and they give you good servings of marinara unlike Steven's point. (Had to take jabs at two of the worst in the state) this one has a nice building in a nice part of town too. Usually quick service and almost always cooked perfect here.“

“Great food! Great service.“

“I eat here pretty frequently, and I have never a bad experience. Food is consistently good. Their Gyros are 👍 and the burger version of it is a mouthgasm. Double cheeseburger is a beast too. Highly recommend!“

“Great place to eat! Wow! Stephanie was our waitress and she is as nice as can be. Salads were awesome…but…save room for dessert!! “6” out of “5”!!!“

“Always great food and friendly staff!“

“Stopped in to pickup my husband's favorite pizza for his birthday and the guy at the register was welcoming, outgoing and friendly. He read back my order to assure it was correct and even packed everything with extra napkins and seasoning packets. Great service and the food was hot and fresh.“

“I’ve been going here since the old location. I usually get Heather and Papito around the times I go. Food is always quick, conversations great and always jokes to be had. My favorite burger (the only one I get and made into a turkey version) the raging Cajun is no longer on the menu, but they know that’s my same order with a side of Cajun/BBQ fries. The other servers I’ve had over the last couple summers as well have all been great as well. Cheers!“

“Great food! Great service.“

“I came from out of out of town for my mom's funeral. My sister and I wanted to try your pizza . When we ate the first slice it was so delicious . They made it the way we like it. The price was reasonable and the time it took to make it was perfect. It did not take to long.“