43 Best Pizza Restaurants in Appleton

“Delicious food but extremely tiny portions. Nice atmosphere just don't come hungry.“

“Delicious food, a warm atmosphere, and great service. We had a party of 14, the attention and service was spectacular. There was something on the menu for everyone, they all loved it.“

“the staff was amazing, their food was as good as ever. it was clean and quick and friendly“

“Great pizza!! We will definitely be back.“

“Incredible food and service!! The employees are friendly, outgoing, and fun! We had lots of laughs with our waitress! Thank you Luigi's!!!“

“Great food and great service! Could not recommend more!“

“Great food and service. Pizza is always delicious and hot. They frequently change their beer lineup so it’s nice to try new beers with pizza. They also have root beer and cream soda on tap.“

“A little slice of heaven. Absolutely amazing pizza, for an awesome price, you can't go wrong.“

“Hands down the best pizza I've had outside of Chicago! The deep dish rivals my favorites from my home town. Can't wait to come back. Just wish I didn't live 90 minutes away. Kudos!🙌“

“Visited the new Menomonee Falls location today. Loved the wood fire pizza 🍕 you can choose between ones on the menu or make your own which is really cool. The layout for seating is really nice. There are games to play at the tables with kids or family which is a really cool idea. The staff is really friendly, will definitely be one of my go to local places.“

“We took our family to Wiseguys last night at 7:30. There were 14 of us and they close at 8:00. I didnt think we would be able to be seated but they were so nice and told us to come on in. Im sure they were counting on closing on time but we never got any indication that they were upset with us. The service was spectacular and the food equally as good. Just want to give everyone who took care of us a huge thank you for such great service and making our night so fun and enjoyable. We promise to come earlier next time! Very sincerely The Seitz Family“

“Stopped in on a recommendation, left with an eggplant Parm pie and yessir it’s good! Friendly chat with the owner and a great dinner! Try em out!“

“The owners are some of the most kind and generous people I have ever known! They would bend over backwards for their family, staff and customers! I know as a former employee and current customer that they put their hearts and souls into their business! We love the food and will continue to support Pizza King!!“

“I ordered two Party Packages for an event that I had and they had everything ready when I picked it up and they even loaded it into my vehicle. My quests loved the food and kept asking where I got it from. The beef brisket was a fan favorite. I would definitely order from them again. If you are looking to serve a large group (I had over 100 people) and give them great food this is the place to go!“

“The owners are some of the most kind and generous people I have ever known! They would bend over backwards for their family, staff and customers! I know as a former employee and current customer that they put their hearts and souls into their business! We love the food and will continue to support Pizza King!!“

“love the pizza great menu polite staff“

“We just had a birthday party here on Sunday for our two 7 year old boys. We reserved a room with one of the party packages, which included a ranch hand, pizza, ice cream, drinks, gift bags and arcade cards for each kid, and very accommodating staff. Nick is always friendly and provides great service every time we visit.“

“What a wonderful evening in your restaurant last night. As a first time diner at your establishment, we were met with rustic charm and elegance, Fresh roses on the tables and an amazing view. Our waitress Amanda M made us feel welcome and her attention to details was amazing. We felt spoiled by her and amazed at her spunk. It was a magical treat for my daughter and myself. Thank you and especially Amanda for making us Welcome and Special & Worthy of a special evening out. ^j^“

“Outstanding food and prevention! Our food looked like a work of art and tasted amazing! Dessert was amazing! We'll be coming back again for sure.“

“Great food! Amazing people!“

“Two of my favorite Papa Murphy's Pizzas ?? Bacon cheeseburger and Garlic Chicken! My girls do not like the cheeseburger one…. I didn't really either the first time I had it YEARS ago, because I usually do not like warm pickles. But the second time I had it, I fell in love with it! They stopped making it the same year I first tried it...they said it was a seasonal feature but it has been YEARS and they never brought it back until this year!!!!(2023)Idk how long they will have it for but if you haven't tried it yet you should!! ? It’s now 2024 and I haven’t checked to see if they have this pizza again but I will find out soon! Always fast and friendly service at the Calumet St. (kk) location!

Kid-friendliness: Mini pizza making kits for kids are awesome! Also cookie dough to bake cookies with the kiddos!“

“love the pizza great menu polite staff“

“Always great food and friendly staff!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I may not have been the one that paid for the food that I picked up to deliver to someone else, but I'm still a customer and deserve to be treated like one. Or is that just how you talk to all your customers.... 🤔“

“Just ordered pizza's it is spring break and all the kids r home we just had cheese but the girls ages 5,6 told me to tell the pizza maker he is the best pizza maker ever!!Thanks for helping a Mom out!!!!“

“We usually go to Uncle Mike’s for breakfast on Saturdays. But today arrived after breakfast ended and ordered lunch. We both ordered burgers prepared medium. One PBJ and one basic burger. Both burgers came well done, little to no jelly and aioli. Service is always good, food comes hot and on time. We will go and dine again but only for breakfast.“

“Pullman’s did an amazing job coordinating our large group on a Saturday night during the holidays. Marty was an excellent waiter who exceeded our expectations. A wonderful experience overall.“

“I’ve been going here since the old location. I usually get Heather and Papito around the times I go. Food is always quick, conversations great and always jokes to be had. My favorite burger (the only one I get and made into a turkey version) the raging Cajun is no longer on the menu, but they know that’s my same order with a side of Cajun/BBQ fries. The other servers I’ve had over the last couple summers as well have all been great as well. Cheers!“

“great place for special events and fun entertainment and party!!“

“Searra and Christin are great bartenders and very friendly! Great atmosphere and tasty drinks. They probably deserve their own office! Hard working gals.“

“DO BETTER TOPPERS. You only deliver to Kimberly through delivery apps. Your store staff does the delivery. You cannot use your store coupons when you deliver to Kimberly. If I could have ordered directly through your store website and used your store coupons tonight, I could have paid less than half of what I paid, and given your store's driver who delivered this order a very generous tip. Instead, I had to pay a ridiculous price by ordering through Uber Eats and the very same driver got a tip of less than $1.50 because that's all I could afford to give them. They would have gotten five times that tip if I could have ordered directly through your store's website and used the current promotion of 50% off of a pizza. DO BETTER TOPPERS.“

“I used the online pre-order option to place my order with ease, but misjudged my pickup time. I went to the location early, and the staff was able to look up my order to start ahead of time, and got me going as soon as possible. Very accommodating and friendly, not to mention excellent pizza!“

“I would give 10 stars if possible. We all in Appleton got hit with a tornado, that’s right a tornado. The got a big order for us quick to feed our group cleaning up and kept serving the community at the same time. They kept on when others were in need. A big thank you from Bergstrom Chevrolet. Not all hero’s wear capes, some have aprons and make pizza.“

“Food was all so good and we tried a lil of everything. Good portions, quality food. Delivery was on time and the driver was super nice! Would eat here again.“

“Usually a 5 star joint. I ordered online & when I came to pick up the bigger lady with glasses at the counter was degrading & made a point out of me and basically announced that I was going to be last in line & spoke down to me like a teenager. Very unattractive & the pizza wasn’t even cut through. Usually a good time tho, sucks yelling everything over the counter.“

“Came in on June 14!!! At like 1215 the pizzas were amazingly warm and yummy! Even enjoyed the reheated pizza so yummy!“

“Great sandwich! Excellent service!“

“Thick rectangular crust, but more bready than your usual Chicago-style crust. Plenty of yummy cheese. Sausage comes in nice big seasoned chunks. Sauce has a bitter taste, and it isn't for me. Overall, better than your average mall food court pizza.“

“Stopped in to pickup my husband's favorite pizza for his birthday and the guy at the register was welcoming, outgoing and friendly. He read back my order to assure it was correct and even packed everything with extra napkins and seasoning packets. Great service and the food was hot and fresh.“

“First visit. I got the broasted chicken and my friend the steak sandwich. I thought the Chicken was great but my friend didn't like the sandwich. Service was good. The tap selection is fantastic. The bar is well lit and not too loud. TVs are all over. An outdoor patio was available. The menu is large for a bar. Much more than standard bar fare. I will be back“