31 Best Bakeries near Middleton

“The BEST pretzels, danishes, and bread that I have ever had! Their baked goods are very high quality and they have a wonderful homemade feel to them. HIGHLY recommend!!!“

“Greatest desserts, worth the trip.“

“An awesome traditional american breakfast spot. It’s great when you walk in and everyone is a local. They had a great selection of just about anything you could think of, omelette, pancakes, scrambles, skillets, etc. My boyfriend said they were some of the best pancakes he’d ever had. My omelette was good, wasn’t out of this world but it was cheesy and had a nice balance of every ingredient. I would loved a little more ham. Very good for a quick bite, they are fast and efficient! Definitely will come again, looking forward to trying more of the menu.“

“I loved my experience at Crumbl Madison and will gladly come here again. As soon as we walked in the staff greeted us and were very friendly throughout. They showed us our cookies and they tasted just as good as they looked. Crumbl is sometimes hit or miss with the store quality but as a visitor to Madison I can confidently say this is a very high quality Crumbl store. I wish my hometown Crumbl was as good as this one is“

“We were looking for Brownies for our wedding dessert and thank goodness we found The Baled Lab. They were wonderful and so easy to work with! The brownies… to die for!!! It was so hard narrowing down which ones to choose for the wedding. We also got a small Salted Carmel cake which was delicious and exactly what we wanted. We can’t wait to find another reason to work with them and get more delicious desserts.“

“I found the perfect place to eat some delicious Puebla-style árabes tacos, with the traditional flavor that makes them unique in Madison. El Hornito Bakery 100% recommended.“

“So wonderful! The GF/DF baked goods are out of this world delicious!! They are careful with cross-contamination, I've not gotten sick. And the staff is SO welcoming, patient and kind. I make a point to stop in when I can, though I live over an hour away. You won't be disappointed!“

“We stopped by there both at the Mad Gluten Free Fest and had your magic bars and this cookie dessert filled with fluffy frosting. My gluten free son LOVED them both as did the rest of our family! Delicious!!!“

“My partner and I were by Batch Bakehouse yesterday and are new to the area, so decided to stop in. It was the end of the day, so immediately the employees were apologetic about the "limited amount of items available". There were PLENTY of items available and every one of them was absolutely delicious. We were able to try their butterscotch chocolate chip bars, salted caramel brownies, and two of their cupcake flavors. We are typically not dessert people, but absolutely cannot wait to return, due to the unparalleled baked goods and the exceptional customer service! I wish I had gotten the names of the people who helped us, so whoever was there at 1 PM yesterday thank you!!“

“Just had the most delicious thing I’ve ever tasted. An almond croissant that was flaky on the outside and filling that was heavenly.“

“Our Christmas variety cookies just arrived today from Yummee Treats! The dough was so rich and dense, and the fillings, chocolate, smores, oatmeal, and pecan were soooo good! They ship internationally to your doorsteps within a day or two! 😋“

“Always a favorite when we are visiting near Park Street. My personals favorites include the coconut custard bun, cheese twist and sponge cake. Very reasonable prices too! Absolutely love this place and have introduced it to many people over the years.“

“We were on vacation and we were not leaving Wisconsin without mapping and getting to Stella’s! Seriously the best breads and pastries we have ever had… The cheese bread is the absolute best!!! The customer service was exceptional and very helpful! Now we just need to get one in Indiana!“

“Our company brought a variety of cupcakes in for our annual awards ceremony and they were fabulous! Highly recommend these delicious treats 🧁“

“Craig's Cake Shop did an amazing job on a Celebration of Life cake. It was a little out of the ordinary request, but they made an incredible cake that everyone loved. It was a special way to honor our loved one and I knew he would have appreciated it. I highly recommend them as their staff went above and beyond our expectations to make this cake special.“

“I met a friend here for the first time. The staff was friendly and welcoming.
Once we ordered, we sat outside on the adorable patio.

For breakfast I ordered a peach danish (delicious!), orange juice (freshly squeezed), and the croissant breakfast sandwich with bacon. The sandwich was delicious. It was cheesey, and the croissant was flakey and absolutely perfect.

The outdoor patio is so cute. I’m mad at myself for not staying longer to read a book.
I also got a chocolate chip cookie to go, which was also wonderful.

I will definitely be back

Parking: There’s a parking lot just around the corner! And also street parking available if the lot is full.“

“The pinnacle of Sourdough baking that I have found in the Midwest. Amazing! Great Job!“

“I called on a Thursday to have a cake for that Saturday. They said yes and it turned out great. The cake was looked great and taste good.“

“Delivered right to my door and absolutely delicious! The kids were extra excited for the Easter bread with sprinkles.“

“Let me just tell you: I had planned for a cake and smash cake for my son’s first birthday. We had to reschedule the cake being made TWICE one day before the scheduled time. They were gracious, patient, and understanding each time. The cake was delicious and perfect.“

“I went there at the behest of a gastronome buddy some years ago to try their Torta Cubana. It is an unbelievably huge layered and delicious sandwich of legend. Sadly, I have since moved far away and have not found any semblance of this "Holy Grail" of tortas! Elated to see they still offer it. Be sure to prepare your Will if you're insane enough to take on La Concha's challenge.“

“Melissa made all of the desserts for my wedding on 5/21/22 and they were all AMAZING. I was actually a bit disappointed that there were no leftovers! I have Celiacs disease, and Melissa was even able to make everything gluten free - cake, cake pops, Oreo balls, and pie bars...wow! The dessert displays and the cake decorations were also beautiful. We got so many compliments on the desserts, and Melissa was so easy to work with. Thank you, Melissa!“

“Great ambiance, and delicious pastries! If you aren’t a coffee person, like me, Alice has a variety of teas for us tea lovers. The staff is very kind. I also love to support local businesses! Give Alice Good Coffee a try! You won’t want to leave ☺️“

“I came back to town and visited two days in a row. I’d forgotten how much I love this place!“

“One of my favorite foods is pastys, I was excited to learn about this place, otherwise you would find them normal in the u.p area of Wisconsin. All of the varieties are great! Had the chicken tikka masala one today, was awesome! I do like they wrap it in foil, because my 40min drive home it's still warm!“

“beautiful location, great service and wonderfully cozy atmosphere!“

“Doughnuts are amazing. My family showed up on Friday night after getting some pizza. The workers there, a husband wife combo, were amazing. Not only were the doughnuts amazing, the workers laughed and joked with my 4 year old son. Showing him all the doughnuts they had in stock. They even gave us 2 free doughnuts to take home for tomorrow. I will be buying all doughnuts from here from now on. 10/10“

“Drinks were delicious first and foremost, worth stopping in to pick up even if you're not gonna partake. Very helpful staff. Nice space to hang out in & play the provided card & board games. Got some goodies to take home for later - haven't tried them yet because my drink was so strong!

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free & vegan edibles“

“Wow Taste so Good! We will back again next time :)“