30 Best Bakeries near Middleton

“The BEST pretzels, danishes, and bread that I have ever had! Their baked goods are very high quality and they have a wonderful homemade feel to them. HIGHLY recommend!!!“

“The mini cakes are amazing! Highly recommend 🎂“

“An awesome traditional american breakfast spot. It’s great when you walk in and everyone is a local. They had a great selection of just about anything you could think of, omelette, pancakes, scrambles, skillets, etc. My boyfriend said they were some of the best pancakes he’d ever had. My omelette was good, wasn’t out of this world but it was cheesy and had a nice balance of every ingredient. I would loved a little more ham. Very good for a quick bite, they are fast and efficient! Definitely will come again, looking forward to trying more of the menu.“

“My husband, my two boys, and I LOVE this place. The hour drive we take to come to Crumbl Cookies is SO worth it. We've been to two different locations in Madison and they are both absolutely FABULOUS! The customer service has always been outstanding. The staff are so welcoming, patient, and always smiling! My family and I would like to give a special shout out to Ava and the rest of the staff who were working on July 9th, 2025 around 8:30pm. Ya'll killed it! Keep up the good work! Thanks a ton for making this trip worth it!!.“

“Our Christmas variety cookies just arrived today from Yummee Treats! The dough was so rich and dense, and the fillings, chocolate, smores, oatmeal, and pecan were soooo good! They ship internationally to your doorsteps within a day or two! 😋“

“This cafe has many delicious options for food. It however does not have celiac safe options. The cross contamination is too high. They do note this if you call them by stating that they can't guarantee there isn't. But I would not eat here if you have celiacs because I did twice and it made me incredibly sick. Again the food in my opinion is delicious, it just isn't celiacs safe.“

“We were looking for Brownies for our wedding dessert and thank goodness we found The Baled Lab. They were wonderful and so easy to work with! The brownies… to die for!!! It was so hard narrowing down which ones to choose for the wedding. We also got a small Salted Carmel cake which was delicious and exactly what we wanted. We can’t wait to find another reason to work with them and get more delicious desserts.“

“We stopped by there both at the Mad Gluten Free Fest and had your magic bars and this cookie dessert filled with fluffy frosting. My gluten free son LOVED them both as did the rest of our family! Delicious!!!“

“My partner and I were by Batch Bakehouse yesterday and are new to the area, so decided to stop in. It was the end of the day, so immediately the employees were apologetic about the "limited amount of items available". There were PLENTY of items available and every one of them was absolutely delicious. We were able to try their butterscotch chocolate chip bars, salted caramel brownies, and two of their cupcake flavors. We are typically not dessert people, but absolutely cannot wait to return, due to the unparalleled baked goods and the exceptional customer service! I wish I had gotten the names of the people who helped us, so whoever was there at 1 PM yesterday thank you!!“

“I needed to order a cake for my mom’s 90th birthday in Verona. I’m in Cincinnati. I google searched for a bakery in the Verona area and loved the cakes I saw on Craig’s website. I crossed my fingers and sent in an order. Elisa worked with me to make sure I got exactly the cake I wanted at the time I needed it. To say the cake was beautiful is an understatement. It was stunning. Everyone at the party raved about how beautiful it was as well as how delicious it was. I highly recommend Craig’s Cake Shop.“

“Right off the bat, parking is street parking and free. However, if you get lucky this place does have like a two car parking lot.

This place has lots of sweets to buy. There's lots to choose from such as sweet red bean bread, Chinese donuts, sesame balls, pork filled buns, etc. My advice is to get there early so the sweets are fresh and still available. They tend to run out of the more popular items like sesame balls early.

If you're not into sweets, they do have a limited food menu you can order from. The food is not your typical American Chinese food, which if you're looking for more authentic Chinese food, this us the place. Expect things like dishes cooked with tendon or intestines. They do have your typical chinese dishes as well.

Overall would recommend for sweets and more authentic Chinese food.“

“I love El Hornito. I love all flavors of the Mexican tacos they offer. Me encanta el hornito. Me encantan igualmente todos los sabores de tacos mexicanos que ofrecen.“

“I got the most delicious AND beautiful cake from the bakery last week!! I’ve never been disappointed by anything I have gotten from Two Sisters Bakery!!! Highly recommend!!!! And the customer service was exceptional!!!!“

“I came back to town and visited two days in a row. I’d forgotten how much I love this place!“

“Everything was absolutely perfect. Every bite we took was bursting with flavor, but this place didn’t just fill our stomachs—it warmed our hearts, too. Full points for greeting their furry friends at the door with water, and huge applause for the wonderful staff who care for all those beautiful plants. The open kitchen detail takes the experience to another level. Kudos to everyone involved!“

“We were on vacation and we were not leaving Wisconsin without mapping and getting to Stella’s! Seriously the best breads and pastries we have ever had… The cheese bread is the absolute best!!! The customer service was exceptional and very helpful! Now we just need to get one in Indiana!“

“Fresh, delicious and new to me flavors. Thank you for opening my world to your baked goods!“

“I called on a Thursday to have a cake for that Saturday. They said yes and it turned out great. The cake was looked great and taste good.“

“Our company brought a variety of cupcakes in for our annual awards ceremony and they were fabulous! Highly recommend these delicious treats 🧁“

“The pinnacle of Sourdough baking that I have found in the Midwest. Amazing! Great Job!“

“This place is so cool it is a crime it is not jam-packed all the time. It is BEAUTIFUL in there and so fun, the workers were super kind and helpful and the food and drinks were great, fun menu. I got a Palmer, I’d probably like the flavor of the drink to be a bit more concentrated, the flavor was there, just a bit faint, but still really good. Awesome place 🙌🏻“

“So good!! we got two things from them at the farmers market. my girls loved the treats!!“

“Great ambiance, and delicious pastries! If you aren’t a coffee person, like me, Alice has a variety of teas for us tea lovers. The staff is very kind. I also love to support local businesses! Give Alice Good Coffee a try! You won’t want to leave ☺️“

“Donuts were amazing but the staff was even better!!! So friendly and welcoming!“

“One of my favorite foods is pastys, I was excited to learn about this place, otherwise you would find them normal in the u.p area of Wisconsin. All of the varieties are great! Had the chicken tikka masala one today, was awesome! I do like they wrap it in foil, because my 40min drive home it's still warm!“

“I went there at the behest of a gastronome buddy some years ago to try their Torta Cubana. It is an unbelievably huge layered and delicious sandwich of legend. Sadly, I have since moved far away and have not found any semblance of this "Holy Grail" of tortas! Elated to see they still offer it. Be sure to prepare your Will if you're insane enough to take on La Concha's challenge.“

“beautiful location, great service and wonderfully cozy atmosphere!“

“Wow. My husband and I have been coming here for quite a few months now, and everything about this place is incredible. All of the employees are so knowledgeable about dosage, and will give you honest, helpful advice if you’re unsure. The location is always spotless, and the game options are so much fun. I hate mentioning Bingo here as I want to gatekeep it, but Bingo on Wednesdays is INCREDIBLE. All of the employees here are passionate and excited to be there. After a few visits, they start feeling more like friends, and soon, family. They all seem to truly love their job, and it makes us LOVE coming here. We will never try another edible dispensary, as their energy and vibe make it unforgettable. This place has made a lasting impact on me and my husband, and I promise you won’t regret it!!“

“Driftless is one of my favorite coffees. So much so that I ordered some to be delivered to me in North Carolina. If you want a really good tasting coffee, look no further. Wish I was closer to a location, but will be in heavy rotation for delivery.“