20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Milton

“Thank you, Mike’s, for hitting that spot with your bomb pizzas! My husband and I couldn’t agree so we ordered the Hawaiian AND the chicken bacon ranch… all I can say is, YUM! In the past I’ve ordered sandwiches and sides. You guys never disappoint and I’m so glad you’re right here in town!“

“Flavorful, and fast delivery. Toppings were fresh and sauce tasted great. Ordered thin crust sausage, onion, and green olive. Will definitely order from again when in Janesville. Called another place and was told they don't take delivery orders(had to download some eats app.) Another place said it will 1 1/2 hours, and this was a week night. The gentleman that answered the phone was polite and courteous. We stay at the American Inn hotel. Paul Revere's pizza was an excellent choice!!“

“Easy to order online, fast and friendly service when picking up, local for us, yummy food. (I do wish I could change the time on when our order would be ready but I'm not complaining.)“

“The customer service was excellent! I am very indecisive and the cashier was very patient and helped me choose. My friend also ran into an issue with payment and the manager was very nice and flexible. I will definitely be back!! :)“

“Finally tried Milwaukee Street Pizza and am sad we hadn't sooner! It was so good, everyone in our family loved it! Also delivery was crazy fast! Staff very friendly!“

“Mac's is the absolute best. Noy only is their food first class, but they solved my marital and hygienic issues as well. A++++++!!!!!!“

“Jim's has in my opinion by far the best pizza around!!!! The customer service is always great! I live in Edgerton so it's a bit of a drive to get there, anyways I had got to Jim's and when I go to pay I discovered that I had left my debit card at home. So instead of making me go all the way home then come back again, they let me take the pizza without paying and just call in my numbers when I got home. That was super nice of them to trust me in such a way. So whenever I'm in the mood to get pizza there's only 1 place I will order from and that's Jim's Pizzaria!!!!!

Dietary restrictions: I'm allergic to corn so thank God Jim's don't use corn meal in their crust! I'm extremely grateful for that cuz 95% of pizza places do.!!!

Parking: It's very small and always crowded which is the places only negative“

“We got a thin crust, and it was literally perfect! Can’t believe I’d never tried it, and I pass it daily. 🍕“

“Always great pizza. Our 1st choice, best around.“

“lasagna from frozen, Kraft mac n cheese from a box, garlic bread using garlic salt instead of powder that inedible. it was the worst!“

“Best tasting pizza in Wisconsin! I love that Tony and Maria's is still in business with many more years ahead. May God Bless you!“

“We’ve had good pizza before, but tonight wasn’t a good experience. We waited 1 1/2 for our pizza to come. The pizza was lukewarm and dried out. Delivery driver was great, I felt bad because they only had 2 drivers. It would have been nice to get a warning or courtesy call, but nothing.“

“We've been ordering food from here and picking it up for years. We always order online and take advantage of the deals and find it very easy.The food is always great (especially for the price) and we especially love the parmesan bites and their sandwiches.I also love that they offer curbside pickup. The service is always quick and we've never had any mix ups with our food or anything.“

“I've enjoyed Hunt Bros. for over 20 years. The slices are a great after work snack and on a "we just want the whole thing" night, one phone call is all. Our local Marathon ladies make them less than a mile from our house !“

“Better than pretty much any big chain pizza you're going to get and they're not riding the inflation dragon. They understand times are tough and have kept their delicious product at a reasonable price.“

“I've enjoyed Hunt Bros. for over 20 years. The slices are a great after work snack and on a "we just want the whole thing" night, one phone call is all. Our local Marathon ladies make them less than a mile from our house !“

“We just had a private event last night. There were 34 of us that had an amazing time. We had a special menu with cocktail demonstrations and fun. Such a great atmosphere! Plenty of space for all at the bar or at the table. The food was amazing. Everyone in our group felt special! The shop is such a bonus to sample and purchase what you know you like. We will be back! Thank you for the great night!“

“So every time I use a specific card to order on pizza hut.com, it always takes the money off my card for a few days and I’m never able to process my order. Usually I just leave it alone and find something at home to eat, as I have some serious anxieties about talking on a phone when it comes to complaints. Today, my children are throwing up all over, both have pink eye and it’s close to preforming an exorcism when I’m trying to give them eye drops. Everyone’s been crying all day, myself included. Now that they’re asleep, I thought to myself “I literally would give my left arm for a Pizza Hut pizza right now” as there’s no better place around here for a fast and easy delivered pizza. Per usual, my online antics were not processed and every last dollar I had was given away to a pizza I wasn’t going to get the joy of eating. Due to my bad day, I literally called to see if they got the order anyways. They didn’t, however the manager on duty literally just took my bad day and made it all happen for me. All I had was $10 in cash, and even though the online ordering wasn’t their own mishap, he went above and beyond making sure he fixed the issue for me. Only charged me the $10 I had on hand for my order. I am so unbelievably appreciative of whoever the store manager is, and thanks for making my really crappy day.. mildly better. Idk who cries about pizza, but it’s me.“

“At 11 am today Wednesday the 10th of January 2024 the standard hostess with the outstanding personality and charm once again did a phenomenal job at lunch. Mushroom Swiss, chips, pickels and a Pepsi without ice made for another fine lunch meal. Thank you“

“This Pizza Hut is the best one I've ever been to. The service was amazing from start to finish and the pizza and cheese bread were perfection! I will go again and again for those! 😋😍“