Caradaro Club Pizza

$ • Pizza

Hours today·

About Caradaro Club Pizza

Caradaro Club Pizza is a Milwaukee tradition known for its delicious thin crust pizza and garlic cheese bread. The restaurant offers great service and a pleasant ambience, especially when the doors are open. The pizza is highly praised for its quality ingredients and its perfect ratios, with the dough being especially good and the crust being super crispy. It is considered the best pizza in Milwaukee, and features like the pepperoni pizza bread on garlic bread are a standout. The lasagna and garlic bread are also amazing.

The owner is known for being an absolute gem, super nice and accommodating, and the rest of the crew follows suit. The place has an old school, hole in the wall vibe that is great for a wonderful family dinner. Caradaro Club Pizza is also involved in the community, helping with neighborhood events, and is highly recommended for takeout.

Menu

Add a Menu
Caradaro Club Pizza Menu
Caradaro Club Pizza Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Caradaro Club Pizza
Caradaro Club Pizza
View All Photos

Caradaro Club Pizza Reviews

4.6
202 ratings
5
82%
4
7%
3
4%
2
1%
1
6%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.2
Service
4.5

Share your opinion about Caradaro Club Pizza

I will just say (1) thing…… THE BEST THIN CRUST PIZZA we’ve had in years!!!
My wife and I ate there last week, and even though they were hosting a large tour group, they're still able to give us personal and attentive service! The pizza- - oh my goodness it was so good! The cheesy garlic bread really sent it over the top! They have a great wine and beer selection to compliment their incredible pizzas! Gary was a gracious host and very attentive- we will be going there again most definitely!
Great food. Wally really knows how to make an excellent pizza. Garlic bread strips are an awesome starter. Gary at the counter is super friendly and someone i look forward to seeing. Been coming here regularly for years and i dont plan on changing that.

Read All Reviews(202)

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 4 - 10PM
Wednesday 4 - 10PM
Thursday 4 - 10PM
Friday 4PM - 12AM
Saturday 4PM - 12AM
Sunday 4 - 9PM
Updated on: