11 Best Caribbean Restaurants near Milwaukee

Shaker's Cigar Bar Caribbean • $$
422 S 2nd St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Bayou Stuffed Jambalaya
14 Margherita Pizza
Grilled Swordfish
Shrimp and Grits
Cajun Meatballs
Blue Crab Claws
Bruschetta

“We were very impressed with our guide Keirsten.She was over the top with our SPICY group. Shakers accompanied our wounded leg toury so she could seek out ghosts with us. Sampling a few amazing menu items and cocktails prior to walk about. Shakers hands down made the best Old Fashions we had on our trip to the mid-west.Thank you for letting us make memories at Shaker’s 10/10“

4.8 Superb409 Reviews
La Caribeña Puerto Rican • $
1704 S Pearl St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Arroz Blanco Con Habichuelas Y Pollo Empanizado
Arroz Con Gandules Mofongo Y Carne Frita
Empanada de Pollo Chicken Empanada
Mofongo Con Carne Y Bandeja Paisa
Mofongo Con Bistec Encebollado
Mofongo Con Camarones En Salsa
Tostones Y Yuca Frita Familiar
Arroz Con Gandules Y Carne
Chillo Frito Con Tostones
Bandeja Paisa Paisa Tray

“Muchas gracias a Alexandra Ella me hizo sentir bienvenido y tuvo un excelente servicio. Espero que me atienda de nuevo.“

4.7 Superb601 Reviews
Mobay Cafe Caribbean • $$
1022 S 1st St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Two Meat Platter Oxtail and Curry Goat
Sybil's Creole Grill Salmon
Ackee and Saltfish Codfish
Steam Cabbage and Saltfish
Jerk Chicken Wing Basket
Ox Tail and Jerk Chicken
Red Stripe Chicken Wings
Caribbean Shrimp Rundown
Carribean Shrimp Rundown
Jerk Chicken Sliders

“Food and Services was amazing“

4.5 Superb132 Reviews
Frankies Restaurant and Catering Caribbean • $$
1815 E Kenilworth Pl, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Ribs with Homemade Sauce
Mac and Cheese
Fataya Samosas
Curry Chicken
Jollof Rice
Cornbread

“Frankie's catered our thanksgiving dinner and the food was STELLAR! 🤤 Will definitely be ordering again! 😍“

3.9 Good34 Reviews
Fiyahside Jamaican Cuisine Jamaican • $
7434 West Capitol Drive, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Side of Brownstew Curry Chicken Only
Brownstew Curry Chicken Dinner Combo
Jerk Chicken \u0026 Cabbage Eggroll
Jerk Brownstew Chicken Dinner Combo
Jerk Chicken with Cabbage Eggrolls
Jerk Curry Chicken Dinner Combo
Jerk Chicken & Cabbage Eggroll
Jerk Chicken Cabbage Roll Each
Large Brownstew Chicken Dinner
Large Curry Chicken Dinner

“Great food and service every time!!“

4 Good141 Reviews
Mangos Cafe East Cafe • $
1682 N Van Buren St, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Guava and Creme Cheese Empanadas
Steak Mango Fries with Cheese
Mangos Fries Burrito
Tacos and Empanadas
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Caribbean Steak
Caribbean Wings
Chicken Wings
Mangos Nachos
Shrimp Tacos

“Best wings in all Milwaukee hands down“

3.8 Good103 Reviews
Pepperpot Jamaican • $
2215 N Doctor M.L.K. Jr Dr, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Dry Rubbed Chicken Wings and Fries
Jamacian Egg Rolls with Shrimp
Pepperpot Famous Egg Rolls
Jerk Chicken Egg Rolls
Jerk Chicken Rice Bowl
Jerk Chicken Dinner
Brown Stew Chicken
Oxtail Rice Bowl
Ox Tail Rice Bowl
Sauces and Rubs

“I stopped in while running some an errand . The vibe is relaxed and inviting. The have Delicious jerk chicken egg rolls! I can’t wait to come back with my friend group to explore the menu further.“

3.3 Good128 Reviews
Uppa Yard Jamaican • $
4943 W Fond Du Lac Ave, Milwaukee

Customers` Favorites

Two Chicken Combo Brown Stew Chicken and Curry Chicken over Rice
Spicy Chicken Wings and Red Beans& Rice w and Side of Cabbage
Jerk Chicken Rice Bean and Cabbage Large Size
Combo Oxtails and Jerk Chicken Dinner
Jerk Chicken with Rice and Peas
Curry Chicken with Rice & Peas
Large Jerk Chicken Dinner
Curry Chicken Combo
Side Jerk Chicken
Rice \u0026 Peas

“We went in from out of town yesterday and ate here a second time. Both times the service has been great, the atmosphere warm and the food delicious. Importantly, the workers seem pretty happy, so I feel good about supporting this restaurant.“

3.4 Good193 Reviews
McCoco's Caribbean Restaurant American • $$
7420 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis - 5.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pincho de Pollo de 2 de Acompañante Side Chicken Skewer 2
Arroz Con Gandules Y Carne Rice with Gandules and Meat
Ensalada de Mango de Acompañante Mango Salad Side
Grilled Puerto Rican Steak with Onions
Pepper Steak with Bacon Rice and Beans
Alitas Mccocos 6 Piezas Mccocos Wings
Acompañante de Mayonesa Side Mayo
Mojarra Frita Fried Tilapia
Porkchops and Mcrice
Chicken Empanadas 4

“You know what they say about first impressions, right? This place!!! Wow!!! To say I was impressed from the moment I walked in would be an understatement. From The smiling Hostess, to the table services… and then wait for it….. the FOOD!!!!! Outstanding, delicious, like yes, I am raving about this place. Ms. Freda was amazing from start to finish. I had #16! The white rice and beans, with the chicharrones, a thinly cut steak, a sausage chorizo, salad, plantains, and a taste of the yuca frita. OH MY OH MY OH MY!!! My hope really is that this place makes it for years to come and expands to other parts of the city! The design of the place has a vibe that invites you in to stay awhile. To enjoy the flavors of the food entries offered. Each one I have to imagine just as good as what I had. This being my first time there I left with a happy heart and a happy tummy! With a mind made up that I will be back! For more of this delicious and wonderful experience! I invite you to come. You won’t be disappointed! I promise!“

4.5 Superb465 Reviews
Noche Restaurant & Bar Tapas/Small Plates • $$
6601 Northway, Greendale - 8.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dulce De Leche French Toast
La Bandera Burrito
Breakfast Burrito
Huevos Rancheros
Jerk Chicken
Steak Fajitas
Sweet Cake
Empanadas
Rice Bowl
Pancakes

“The food is great and the service is beautiful. Our food and drinks were out fast, our server notice that my aunt was done with her drink and brought her another immediately and also were very quick with noticing we were done eating and asked if we need anything else. 10/10 recommending to all of my friends.!“

4.3 Superb129 Reviews
Wauwatiki Bar & Grill Hawaiian • $$
6502 W North Ave, Wauwatosa - 4.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pain in the Tiki and Banana Daquiri on the Patio
Hawaiian Style Fried Rice
Loco Moco and Crack Fries
Glutenfree Cheese Curds
Barbecue Ribs N' Fries
Shredded Jerk Chicken
Sauteed Vegetables
Sautéed Mushrooms
Chicken Wings
Banana Dto

“Only all GF place I know of around here!!! And it’s good and it’s got a great atmosphere!!!“

4.1 Good150 Reviews