Reynold's Pasty Shop
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
3525 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee
(414) 444-4490
About Reynold's Pasty Shop
Reynold's Pasty Shop Reviews
frequented this wonderful food shop in the 1960's and 1970's when i lived in west allis. been in st paul mn sincce the 1970s and anytime i can get someone to bring me some i buy as mny as i can get. recently we were only able to find 5 frozen ones at a grocery store as the burleigh st shop is closed and not open to the public anymore. sure hope someone will take over, it is a huge loss if not. food is top notch and has been for many years.
the perfect pasties I've ever had!
Not much taste, big huge clumps of ground beef, tiny bits of carrot. Plus, I found a piece of ground up plastic in my first (and last) Reynolds pasty. Thank goodness there are alternatives!
Menu
People in Milwaukee Also Viewed
.jpg)
Reynold's Pasty Shop, a local institution, has been serving its famous pasties for over fifty years. Located at 35th and Burleigh, this small shop offers a savory and filling meal with fair prices and a friendly staff. Customers praise the delicious pecan pie, although limited parking and lack of nearby dining options can be downsides.
The shop is known for its high-quality pasties, using fresh and savory ingredients in the perfect pastry. Visitors from near and far, including those familiar with pasties from the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, have enjoyed this Milwaukee staple. The fast and friendly service ensures a quick and satisfying experience.