10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Neenah

“Best place in town, friendly staff and dynamite pizza!!!!“

“Amazing service and great food. All super reasonable prices. Will definitely one back“

“Yup. It is legit. One of the best places. The crust on the pizza was amazing, the lasagna it's over the top. Even the cheesy bread, like the bread isn't too dried out and it's not soggy. It's like it's just right. And the sauces like I like Alfredo sauce but some places manage to ruin it. Not this place. Super good. And like just honestly the different sauce is try the different sauces. Oh, oh!!! And the root beer, Baumgartners. I had never tried it, and I like to try different root beers everywhere I go. I got an extra bottle to bring home and do some serious taste testing. It might possibly be my next favorite one.“

“Messed up my pizza two times. First said no pinions, put on red onions. I again Stated no onions, they remade it with green, I noticed right away. They asked if I would like to keep it and give it to someone I knew knowing we wouldn’t eat it. Gave it to the in-laws. They remade it for the third time correctly. The team was doing a great job working together under pressure as it was very busy and most likely embarrassed for the mistake. Took my name and next pizza was free. They did a great job and made it right. Stand up service!“

“Been coming to cranky pat's for 30 years. Was in there today with my wife around 3pm. We were the only customers there. One waitress was on the phone with a customer and 2 others were in the area. We sat there for 20 minutes and not one ounce of service. A couple of walk bys but no service. Doesn't the help work together or just ignore customers? Got tired of no service for 20 minutes so we got up and went elsewhere. Nice way to lose lifelong customers........we won't be back.“

“Tom and his staff are top notch! Friendly and responsive. The pizza is top notch 🤌🤌🤌“

“awesome service, quick and pasta bowl was great :)“

“Held wedding rehearsal event. Booked with Sarah Fletcher General Manager. She was great to deal with and handled the details perfectly.
Great venue! We had private bar with large area for tables. Outside adjacent patio was also loved by our guests.
Great food and service. Ally & Maggie took great care of us and our guests. Heavy Appetizers, Buffet, & Kids Menu were all outstanding. I would not hesitate to book another event!“

“love your pizza! Disappointed no locations in appleton anymore! last night we ordered, Grub hub delivered "God knows where? Not to us! when we tried to reorder/redeliver we were told not taking any more orders?? ( busy I guess) But, seriously, you just figure oh well too bad for us???? I und ER stand its Grub hubs fault, but you look pretty bad not having very good customer service!!!! meanwhile someone got a free pizza & cheese bread 😕😡“

“The food was ready so fast and was very fresh/hot. Despite what other reviews are saying about the “disrespectful young staff”, my experience with the staff was nothing but great. Don’t listen to all the cranky geezers on here, keep up the great work guys!“