5 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Glarus

Petrosino's Pizza Pizza • $$
1201 WI-69, New Glarus

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pizza

“Petrosino’s is great little place for homemade, quality pizza. Dining in and carry out are equally accommodated, with equal quality product. I love it when a local family brings authentic flavor, and tremendous pride to our small town. Such an asset to have this great food nearby. This has been made all the better with the opportunities we’ve had to speak with the owner and his wife to get a glass of wine on our later evening visits.“

4.9 Superb73 Reviews
Puempel's Olde Tavern Bar & Grill • $
18 6th Ave, New Glarus

Customers` Favorites

Liverwurst Sandwich with Onion and Mustard
Smoked Turkey with Limburger Sandwich
Gourmet Cheese Flight
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Raspberry Tart
Cheese Plate
Cheese Curds
Pulled Pork
Sandwiches
Bratwurst

“The sandwiches are really tasty, and go well with the beers on tap. It's so nice to see so many locals supporting Puempel's. Between the food, friendliness and the vintage decor, it's a great place to stop for lunch, whether it's for the weekend or just for the day.🙂🍻“

4.4 Superb114 Reviews
Sugar River Pizza Co. - New Glarus Italian • $
700 Railroad St, New Glarus

Customers` Favorites

Fried Ravioli with Pesto & Sriracha Mayo
Margherita with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Kickapoo Taco Pizza
Baked Potato Pizza
Pulled Pork Nachos
Pepperoni Pizza
Beer Selection
Cheese Curds
Cheese Bread
Steak Pizza

“We have had the best experiences every time we have gone to the New Glarus location. Not only has the food been phenomenal, the staff has been tremendously nice and has gone out of their way to make sure we are well taken care of. Well done!!“

4.3 Superb107 Reviews
JonnyO's Pizzeria Monticello Pizza • $
203 N Main St, Monticello - 5.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gyro

“Me again-the lunch specials are good all week. Enjoyed meeting friends on the bike trail & having pizza for lunch. 2 slices & a drink for about $6. Just right for an old biker.“

5 Superb12 Reviews
JonnyO's Pizzeria Belleville Pizza Delivery • $
27 W Main St, Belleville - 5.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese
BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch
Spicy Chicken Pesto
Mac & Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Caesar Salad
Wings

“No complaints about the food. Ordered a delivery at 4:45pm and it took 2 1/2 hours for it to arrive. We could have drove to Chicago and got our food quicker. We had to feed our kids something else because it was their bedtime before it came.“

4.6 Superb83 Reviews

You May Also Like