4 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Glarus

“The sandwiches are really tasty, and go well with the beers on tap. It's so nice to see so many locals supporting Puempel's. Between the food, friendliness and the vintage decor, it's a great place to stop for lunch, whether it's for the weekend or just for the day.🙂🍻“

“We got overcharged on a carry out credit card transaction. Someone gave themselves a 36% tip. My husband went in person twice. He was first told to come back another day. He did so and was told it would be reimbursed within 2 days. It never was so I called. When I called, I was told the owner was "doing a bunch of them today" but it's been almost a week and still nothing. After 3 attempts, I am letting it go but feel the experience and lack of follow through is worth sharing.“

“We've been twice now. Once for great thin crust pizza and again for the Smash Burger. It was caramelized all around including the cheese. Sautéed onions on top. There's nothing like it in Belleville, New Glarus or Monticello. Two great experiences even with construction going on. Exciting to have this new option.“

“No complaints about the food. Ordered a delivery at 4:45pm and it took 2 1/2 hours for it to arrive. We could have drove to Chicago and got our food quicker. We had to feed our kids something else because it was their bedtime before it came.“