26 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newburg

“Absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE this place! From the bartenders to the cook... all the way to the owner! The atmosphere is absolutely "Speakeasy", and the food is impeccable! If you're in the area, come and enjoy! Wing Wednesday and fish fry Friday are the BEST! Especially that baked cod! YUMMMY!!!!“

“Visited from out of town. Never heard of the Pizzeria and was just hungry. My friend and our little daughters HIGHLY ENJOYED this place!!! This is such a cool Pizzeria that your eyes will wonder at all the things written on the walls. The owner has cool rocks and plants and little unique decorations! The homemade pizza was delicious. We enjoyed our pesto cheese ring and my daughter LOVED the homemade Cherry Fairy Ice-cream. The owner was extremely nice and the atmosphere was comfortable and casual. When we are traveling near here, we are definitely making it a point to come back and eat again!!“

“Love sals pizza. Our first experience was when we moved to town and needed a quick dinner for our move in help. Now every time they come to town, they request sals.“

“Great pizza friendly staff my boyfriend got a free slice when we went! Highly recommend this place“

“Eaton's Pizza has amazing and delicious choices for pizzas. I remember being a teenager in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin and looking forward to the best pizza on the weekends. They are so good, the business has exploded in the past 35 years and opened tons of stores around Wisconsin. Their Reuben pizza is especially good. Just be sure to add double meat and sauerkraut.“

“Hadn’t been to Eaton’s for a while and glad I stopped. Staff was helpful and friendly. Pizza was great - abundant toppings, nice thin crust, flavorful sauce.“

“Hands down best pizza in the West Bend area! I ran a very popular pizza place in Okauchee years ago! This pizza is incredible!!“

“Everyone has heard the tale of when Papa Murphy struck down papa John in 1v1 combat with pizza cutters for weapons. Obviously Murphy reigned supreme, and they cornered the market on delicious pizza forevermore....

Praise be the pizza lords!!“

“We got the taco pizza. The size we purchased was the family size. The pizza was delicious. This particular pizza was only for two people. We have enough for lunch. The next day. This is a pizza place. I would recommend to my friends. It’s always clean. The staff is always friendly. I’ve gotten peace of him there many times. It’s always delicious. If you ever get stuffed pizza. Make sure to cook it long enough because one time I didn’t and I got a little sick. But that was my fault not theirs.“

“On Wednesday we ordered a Christmas tree pizza and a chicken Parmesan pizza. They were both sooooooo good! In fact they were so good that we ordered two of each of them tonight. Plus, we ordered their hand rolled mozzarella sticks and cheesy garlic bread (which is free for every two pizzas you order on Friday nights). By the way, both the mozzarella sticks and garlic bread are homemade. If it was possible everything was even better tonight. If you haven’t eaten at Riverview Inn, run don’t walk to this sleeper of a restaurant. I would give them 100 stars ⭐️ on this review if I could. Both times I was greeted very warmly and despite the fact they were super busy both times I didn’t have to wait long to get my orders. I can’t say enough to how good their food is. I would eat here every night if I could. Thank you so much Riverview Inn for the delicious pizza, mozzarella sticks, and cheesy bread. We will definitely be back again in the future!“

“First-time ordering. Pleasantly suprised!! Nice thin crust, plenty of toppings! Absolutely delicious!!“

“I called late one Sunday nite.. The owner answered I believe. I wanted to order a pizza for delivery. He said the driver was done for the night already, and they were about to close for the night. He then asked where I lived. Turns out I was on his way home so he made my pizza and delivered it himself! Real nice and great customer service!“

“You were the only business that would accept online orders Saturday night and the food was amazing. Even better you said delivery time between 9:00 p.m. to 9:15 p.m. delivery person was there at 8:30 p.m. wow!!! Definitely will be ordering again thank you!“

“Never disappointed with the amazing Tomaso’s pizza. Absolutely delish! 🍕“

“The pizza burger was excellent being large and juicy. The large salad had lots of toppings, nothing skimped on Have had the pizza and it's also good“

“Ive been coming to Michalenos for well over a year now. Only in the recent months did I start dining in with my mother and daughter. We always come on a Friday, and we usually have Sarah helping us. She is always so kind and patient. My mother has early onset dementia, and often forgets where she is or what she says, Sarah never misses a beat reanswering questions or repeating what she already said six times before. She’s always prompt and accurate as well. Tonight, she was hopping, the phones were ringing off the hook, she had many tables and people coming in and out. She always had a smile on her face and never stopped moving! She suggested we try the baked pasta because we had the regular last time and it was delicious! I had the spinach lasagna and a fresh salad and it was all hot and delicious. The only complaint I had for the evening, is that you could tell the cook in the kitchen was very frustrated with his slamming, yelling and cussing. I know he was busy, we could see all the people, but maybe vent a bit quieter! Despite that, we’ll be back next week, and the next week, and the next week…“

“Food was spectacular. My husband and I started with the lobster bites. I had lasagna, he had pizza. The sauce is delicious. Our waitress was attentive and good. The owner stopped by to see how everything was and took our leftovers to be boxed up. We will definitely be regulars here.“

“I was part of an event there for a company party yesterday. The staff was nothing short of amazing. Very friendly, great service, outstanding atmosphere. Thank you for your hard work!“

“Every time I order and pick up pizza at the West Bend WI store I always have a good experience. Every employee is happy, prompt, and provides EXCELLENT service. I always leave the store with a smile on my face. Cudos! We've all encountered disgruntled, uninterested attitudes of 'fast food' workers. I just haven't seen it there! Keep it up!“

“We ordered pizza for the first time from John’s, Thanksgiving weekend, wanting to try something new. The BLT pizza and garlic bread sticks were phenomenal! So much so, that we went back the next weekend with friends. What a hidden treasure!“

“Have ordered from Dominos in Jackson Wi. a couple times. Great service. Fast Delivery. Pizza and Garlic bread were hot and delicious.“

“The lady her name is Diana, when I was walking home on the cold windy day and it was super icy, I was walking half way freezing. She offered me a ride to take to the location I needed to be dropped off, she was truly an Angel! I give her the recognition of how wonderful kind lady she was! Thank you!“

“The staff is friendly, fast, and accommodating, the food is as you would expect from a fast food pizza chain. Truly, it is the staff experience that makes this location stand out, and paying tents dollars for a ready made pizza makes it worth it“

“I ordered a small gluten-free pizza with black olives, extra cheese, spinach, mushrooms, and robust tomato sauce, and it was delicious and healthy! The crust was surprisingly good, the toppings were fresh, and everything tasted flavorful without feeling heavy. Definitely ordering again.
Thanks 🙏🏽“

“Walking in this establishment me and my party was greeted with a welcoming hello! The store of course smelled good from the pizza and looking around it was super clean. My pizza was hot and ready with my wings and order of brownies,
Great customer service from everyone especially the store manager made sure I had everything before I left out of the restaurant. Definitely will be returning to try the pasta.“

“Well done, Gary's Place! We had dinner at Gary's Place as part of our company Christmas Party and the service was outstanding. Our server took care of drinks and food for 24 like a well oiled machine. Shout out to Brenda - she was amazing! Good food, great service, what more could you ask for?“