23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newburg

“We ordered the Jimmy the Greek pizza, mozzarella sticks, and garlic bread with cheese for pick up. We hadn’t ordered any food there in quite a while, not for any particular reason just had kind of forgotten about the place. When we pulled up to pick up our order, they let us know that they threw in some chocolate chip cookies, which I thought was really sweet. That pizza was freaking amazing! The crust is the best crust I think I’ve ever had on a pizza. I not a pizza crust person and it was literally one of my favorite parts! The mozzarella sticks had Parmesan cheese on them. The garlic bread was delicious and the cookies were an unexpected but delicious treat. We will be back.Excellent food friendly staff“

“best pizzas around!!!!!!!“

“Great pizza for a great price!“

“best NY style pizza in Eastern Wisconsin!“

“Always go here for carry out pizza. Better than any national brand franchise pizza. Make sure to get the made to order salad. You definitely get a lot for the money. It's a great compliment to the pizza. They also have a huge selection of their pizzas that are frozen. Monday is 3 medium size, one topping pizzas for $20. You can't beat their prices.

Kid-friendliness: They have single, personal size pizzas for everyone, including kids. Very inexpensive.“

“Hadn’t been to Eaton’s for a while and glad I stopped. Staff was helpful and friendly. Pizza was great - abundant toppings, nice thin crust, flavorful sauce.“

“My family and I went to Maricio’s tonight and everyone loved their food!! SO GOOD, and service was amazing!! Thank you!“

“First-time ordering. Pleasantly suprised!! Nice thin crust, plenty of toppings! Absolutely delicious!!“

“My location had only two workers when it opened today, with several customers waiting for their online orders as well as some customers placing orders at the counter. The two employees worked extremely quickly and efficiently to fill all of the orders and still somehow managed to be personable with everyone. Excellent staff and product!“

“Was visiting family but since it was raining we decided not to go out to eat but instead got pizzas. Can’t go wrong with Papa John Pizza since you can either go with what’s on their menu of just build your own. You may have to bake it yourself, but you’ll know it’s hot and fresh out of the oven. We had the Papa’s Favorite and Papa’s Perfect (never understood the need for pineapple on a pizza.)“

“They have great pizza and the best Italian beef sandwiches on their Monday special! This time I tried the pickle, bacon, ranch pizza and it was great! 😁😋“

“The pizza burger was excellent being large and juicy. The large salad had lots of toppings, nothing skimped on Have had the pizza and it's also good“

“Food was spectacular. My husband and I started with the lobster bites. I had lasagna, he had pizza. The sauce is delicious. Our waitress was attentive and good. The owner stopped by to see how everything was and took our leftovers to be boxed up. We will definitely be regulars here.“

“I called late one Sunday nite.. The owner answered I believe. I wanted to order a pizza for delivery. He said the driver was done for the night already, and they were about to close for the night. He then asked where I lived. Turns out I was on his way home so he made my pizza and delivered it himself! Real nice and great customer service!“

“the.everything but anchovies thin crust, I have eaten it here fo'r all 48 years, Mike“

“This was our first visit. They only have carryout at this location. The staff and owner were very friendly. The food was ready on time.

When we arrived at home we dug right in and the food was fantastic. The pizza was cooked perfectly, as was the canzone! The Italian sub sandwich was very good, but I would have liked a little more red sauce. That's just me and I will order it next time.

We will be ordering again.

If you are looking for quality Italian food at a very affordable price, order from Michaleno's!“

“Ive been coming to Michalenos for well over a year now. Only in the recent months did I start dining in with my mother and daughter. We always come on a Friday, and we usually have Sarah helping us. She is always so kind and patient. My mother has early onset dementia, and often forgets where she is or what she says, Sarah never misses a beat reanswering questions or repeating what she already said six times before. She’s always prompt and accurate as well. Tonight, she was hopping, the phones were ringing off the hook, she had many tables and people coming in and out. She always had a smile on her face and never stopped moving! She suggested we try the baked pasta because we had the regular last time and it was delicious! I had the spinach lasagna and a fresh salad and it was all hot and delicious. The only complaint I had for the evening, is that you could tell the cook in the kitchen was very frustrated with his slamming, yelling and cussing. I know he was busy, we could see all the people, but maybe vent a bit quieter! Despite that, we’ll be back next week, and the next week, and the next week…“

“Pizza hut was the place to hang with your friends and family. The pizza was great, remember the salad bar. Times have changed and not for the better.the 80s and 90s are long gone. I tryed the carry out pizza hut. The pizza was good, like back in the day. Worth checking out. I'll probably go back when in the area.“

“I had the opportunity to stop in for the first time and was not disappointed. Very nice place with a friendly and welcoming atmosphere! Wings were great! Can't wait to stop back in.“

“When my food was being delivered, my dog squeezed right through the door when I opened it. I am so thankful for the driver for grabbing my dogs collar because my dog is a runner. Saved me a whole bunch! Food was great as always very thankful! :)“

“I don't often review chain restaurants but had to for this one. Last night, (3-17-24) we ordered a pizza. It was JUST how I remembered it years ago. I feel in recent years it has gone downhill (not enought cheese, usually cooked too long where the cheese is brown) but for some reason last night's was SPOT ON. Cheesy, greasy, hot! BIG Shout out to the staff that worked last night. (one of the kids being a big Marquette fan) I sure management trains all staff to make all pizzas just like that. If so, I'll be back!“

“I hadn't ordered Little Ceasars in years, and it was at 8:40PM that I placed an order for pick up. Luckily, they said they could provide the food within 15 minutes, just before closing.I didn't understand that the lobby closes at 8:30PM until I read a small sign in the window. But, when I pulled into the drive thru, they were very fast and polite. I was even able to ask for additional dipping sauce at the window, and it was of no inconvenience to them. The food was fresh, and so very delicious, ever since I ordered, I've been craving even more. Unfortunately, I don't live that close and so I can't order often, but I would recommend their food. Fresh, delicious, relatively inexpensive, and the people are absolutely polite.“

“Our first time here and we loved everything! The food was amazing, the drinks were tasty and the food came out fast. Our waiter Tim is what stood out the most. He had recommendations for every part of the meal, drinks, food, dessert and overall amazing service while handling all his other tables. It’s not often you see that kind of service anymore. Thank you and we will be back!“