9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Menomonee Falls

Pepino's Italian • $$
N84W15841 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Meat Balls
Pepnios's Supreme Pizza
Ravioli with Meat Sauce
Famous Italian Salad
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Baked Manicotti
lb Beef Burger
Pizza Peperoni
Fish Platter
Appetizers

“Gave this spot a try. Ordered a large pepperoni, basil, and garlic extra thin. And a small pepperoni and black olive thin crust. Also ordered garlic bread with marinara sauce. First let me say. Their thin crust is basically hand tossed and the extra thin is a thicker version of a thin crust pizza. Both pizzas graded out to be about a 6.2/10. The cook on them was good. Not undercooked like many chain places do. The sauce is zesty with little to no sweetness. We preferred the sweeter sauce at Demarinis. But if you like a zestier sauce, you will most likely prefer Pepinos. Pizza was a tad greasy. Basil was dried basil, and not fresh unfortunately. But overall, I’d choose this place over any chain. The garlic bread and marinara was a bit confusing. They forgot the marinara unfortunately. So we just got the bread. The garlic bread looks to be French bread with sesame seeds on the bottom. Definitely different as the bitterness of the sesame doesn’t really mix well the buttery flavor of the garlic. 3.5/10 on the bread. Not my favorite, but not my least favorite. 6/10 overall experience.“

4.5 Superb70 Reviews
Village Bowl Pizza • $
N86W18330 Main St, Menomonee Falls

“Was there for the Women's State Nowling Tournament. They were well organized, and the place lookeattestation. The lanes were nice, but you had to go down 2 steps each time to get on the lane to bowl. Not very friendly if you have any mobility issues. The Bar-Resturaunt had good service and good food. The staff was friendly and attentative.“

4.4 Superb80 Reviews
GrinderVille Grinders & Pizza Sandwich Shop • $$
W186N9515 Bancroft Dr, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Grinder
Southwest Chicken Pizza
Fries

“I’ve lived here in the falls for over 15 yrs. I’ve know about GRINDERVILLE for several years but never ate here. I did a few weeks ago and have gone back 3x in a matter of 2 weeks. It’s fast, fresh, delicious, reasonably priced and overall just a great experience each time.“

4.2 Good158 Reviews
Pizza Crafters Pizza • $
N56W15560 Silver Spring Dr, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pizza and Brownies
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Roma Tomato Basil Pizza
Salad and Pizza Buffet
Salad from the Buffet
Pizza from the Buffet
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chocolate Brownies
Supreme Pizza
Personal Pizza

“Wasn't busy at all. Explained first time here. Cashier explained all the details. Was Ash Wednesday, so I needed a meatless meal. Cashier said "a veggie or a basil & mozzarella pizza". Then she asked if I wanted both so I didn't have to choose. Ate from the extensive salad buffet, where both hot/cold items are offered, along with cinnamon rolls & brownies, which I didn't try cause I was too full The salad buffet was plenty, but I really wanted pizza & could smell them baking. Within about 15 mins, both pizzas were on the buffet. Smelled as good as they tasted. Love the crust! I think this pizza would be good cold, or the next day reheated. They also have lots of pizza ideas on their menu, or make your own. Don't remember if drinks are included in the price. Cleared my own dirty dishes.Vegetarian options: Salad bar & pizza choices.Dietary restrictions: Ask before ordering, or call before goingKid-friendliness: All you can eat pizza buffet.“

4.2 Good66 Reviews
Sportz Pub and Grill Bar & Grill • $$
N80W13003 Fond Du Lac Ave, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“Might be biased because I went to watch the packers beat the cowboys in the playoffs but it was a great time. They pass out free jello shots when packers score a touchdown. Had the BBQ onion ring burger, was great. Staff was busy but didn't forget anyone.“

4.1 Good56 Reviews
De Marinis Pizzeria Pizza • $$
N88W15229 Main St, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Cheese Bread
Mozzarella Sticks
Sausage Pizza
Fish Fry

“Our family had the large room or hall to ourselves for a memorial dinner. The bartender was young and I don't think he was really prepared for us. The lasagna tasted good but didn't really hold up under its own weight. The pizza however was quite good. I think we had extra cheese on one of the pizzas and you could tell.“

4 Good68 Reviews
UNO Pizzeria & Grill Pizza • $
W180N9455 Premier Ln, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Kids Spaghetti with Meatballs
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
Pepperoni Medium Pizza
Broccoli Cheese Soup
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Rattlesnake Pasta
French Onion Soup
Chicken Tenders
Chicago Classic
Fresh Lemonade

“Intention was to go to Applebee's but they had a wait time of 15 mins, because the wait staff could not handle a couple of large groups and everyone else, with half the place looked half empty. So we went to Uno's, which turned out to be a fantastic dinner. Thank you.“

3.8 Good92 Reviews
The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery Bar & Grill • $$
N88 W16718, Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Traditional Wings
Friday Fish Fry
Steak Sandwich
Cheese Pizza
Onion Rings
Sandwiches
Patty Melt
Burger
Italian
Reuben

“Good food. Great service. Don't know how we missed going here for so long but glad we stopped in for dinner. Very friendly, casual atmosphere. Decent prices. Wish they had a slightly larger beer selection but they have most of the basics. We will be back.“

3.8 Good60 Reviews
Toppers Pizza Pizza • $$
N88W15515 Main St, Menomonee Falls

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
Ragin Pepperoni Pizza
Original Topperstix
Triple Topper Stix
Pretzel Bites
Nacho Cheese
Oven Roasted
Smoky BBQ

“I have been to New York. I have been to Roma. I have been to Sicily. This Pizza is as good as any I have had those places.Just kidding. It's a topper's. It's a good carry-out/delivery place. I like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and am not crazy about the mac n' cheese pizza. This location has been reliable for me and if they got something wrong they make it right....what more do you want? Fun fact: I don't know how to say the word "Pizza" (according to my "friends") despite it being my favorite dish. This is a place to send your wife to get pizza when you're drunk. I'm drunk.“

3.7 Good70 Reviews
Loading...
map Map