14 Best Pizza Restaurants in West Allis

“I had ordered a pizza last night from Alphonso‘s and I thought it was the absolute worst pizza I ever had when it arrived at my house. It was almost burnt. I called and complained to the manager. He said he would do everything he could to make it up to me. So I stopped in today and they gave me a pizza and one of their sandwiches and I haven’t had the sandwich yet because I’m too full from the pizza, it was a night and day difference From yesterday to today. It was excellent.“

“Great amazing pizzas! Have to try different ones!“

“Went to see Addiction tonight. Three couples and a birthday in our group. The food was very good and Shelia was the BEST waiter I have seen in quite some time. Warm, friendly, funny and kept track of us expertly!“

“Me and my family love this place! We come here for pizza at least once a week now 👌👌 Best pizza place in town!“

“Very friendly and fast. Clean place. Food is great“

“I had my wedding reception lunch at Nico’s and myself, and all of the attendees were amazed at the quality of food and service that we received! Nico and Tina made the experience personalized for our needs and wants. I highly recommend Nico’s for your party or event!! Thanks again Nico’s!!!“

“Love these pizzas and the service!“

“everyone there is always very friendly. we love eating there“

“The wife and I just got back from taking our son on a walk through a botanical garden and worked up an appetite we were in the mood for some samiches looked up a spot and decided to try this one the wife got a chicken & bacon and I got a chipotle chicken avocado and a Mac and cheese for the kiddo and to wash it all down a lemonade the sandwiches were flavorful warm and delicious and lastly the veggies on the sandwiches were fresh the Mac and cheese tasted like KFC’s well definitely be back for another samich but not a Mac & cheese“

“Went here for the 1st time tonight and is was beyond wonderful. Service was fantastic and the food was soooo good. Can not wait to eat here again ❤️“

“Clearly this is a fixture of West Allis. Took the family to Mama Mia's for a celebration dinner. Five of us waited about 15 minutes to be seated on a Monday night. First time visit we had garlic bread and a garlic bread, meatball sandwich and chicken tenders and fries and the salad and potato soup. And manicotti. Inflation has raised prices everywhere, but the prices here for the portions was quite reasonable.“

“love the place other than calling and asking how your wings are made and getting a smart remark in an oven like everyone dose. So I asked how are they prepared and I was told "I just told you in an oven" and that's all they knew 🤔 please do better. I like your food but incompetent people will ruin that. Thanks“

“Friendly and personable bar tender and excellent pizza as always. My favorite pizza actually. 😀“

“Adriana took my order. After I had told her that I was just next-door pulling up to the subway to do takeout there before I even entered the subway the manager had waved his arms up and down saying that I was not allowed in and that they had closed even though their closing time wasn’t for another 15 minutes. I was disappointed but I decided to go next-door to jets pizza where I ordered a slice of pizza and met Adriana. She was very sweet and took my order with no problem even though she was in the middle of mopping!! After a few mins I had received my order she had to let me know that instead of the one slice I had ordered, she had given me a additional slice and an option for a complimentary beverage for the inconvenience of the business next door.l! That was an above and beyond gesture! It shows that jets pizza truly cares about their customers! And the food was fresh and delicious! So next time I’ll be coming here when I’m in a hurry to get some late night food.!“