8 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Berlin

“Okay, pizza places are a nickel for two dozen, but this particular pizzeria is second to none. It’s busy and hopping for a reason. For one, the food is fabulous. Two, you can sense the pride that’s embedded in the food, service, quality, and overall operations. Additionally, I accidentally forgot my 6-piece buffalo wings when I ordered. I couldn’t get there until three days later (I’m from out of town). The lovely owner (Stephanie) and wonderful manager (Sean) went out of their way to correct my order. They even added a couple of wings on the house. While the pizza is indicative of those who know what they’re doing, the service is equally delectable. Kudos to an outstanding staff. I highly recommend this place hands DOWN.“

“Pizza was on time, and tasty. The crust was not what most around here would call "thin." Doughy if that's a word, not charred but still not floppy. Lots of sauce , if a bit on the sweet side. Not shy with the toppings at all and good flavor. Wings were really good! Also a 9 minute drive right off of I43 to my place and out of delivery zone which was a bummer, because others around here that deliver are not so great and this would be a go to for sure.“

“This was our first time ordering. We’ll definitely order again! We loved everything about our pizza, the crust, the sausage, the sauce. There was just the right amount of sauce and cheese. We really enjoyed it!“

“Worked at Armelis many many years ago. Had a craving for it tonight and it’s exactly how I remember it from 15+ years ago! My husband had it for the first time and said “WHY HAVENT WE ORDERED FROM HERE BEFORE?!” So we will definitely be ordering again!“

“Pizza is great service is good tables are usually maintained well.

Parking: Plenty of parking. Short distance to the door. Farthest parking spot is probably 30 yards from door.

Wheelchair accessibility: Its ground level“

“Good pizzas. It's easy to order on line and the web site is well designed so you can build your pizza exactly like you want it. I always get the really thin pizza dough and usually bake it longer than they suggest to get a super crispy crust. I also add some of my own toppings... like tons of onions and tofu "beef" “

“I came here for dinner with my dad. I've actually been coming here for years, but I wanted to write a review for my recent experience.So the food is awesome. We got cheese and garlic bread with a pepperoni and bacon pizza. All of it was stellar and arrived pretty quickly. I never had issues with the service or food. Our server was great and everything in our order was good and correct, though my dad would say that he wishes the old fashioned he had was stronger.The restaurant was almost empty on a Friday night, which seemed really unusual especially for a restaurant tied to a movie theatre. I also noticed that there was an unusual wait for the check, like over 30 minutes of waiting. The waiter came by and apologized and explained that the POS system went down and asked if we had cash (which I fortunately had). After another wait, he came by to explain that he couldn't ring up the bill, accept payment or bring us a check due to the system being down so the manager had actually comped our entire meal.I wanted to give Zaffiros a great review because I really do love this place. I've been going to this restaurant for years and it's still one of my absolute favorite places to get food. I've always enjoyed the pizza here, and the service has always been solid. I just hope more people come here and support this really great pizzeria.“

“Great local bar. Feels very comfortable. The bartender that works on Tuesday nights is a smoking hot fox.... I would drag my manhood through five miles of broken glass if that meant that I could be served by her every night! Oh and they have a pool table.“