11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Wauwatosa

“Good service, friendly atmosphere and excellent food quality.“

“Great discovery of a great pizza place!“

“Perhaps the single greatest meal of my life. Little Caesars may be the highest quality I have ever eaten. I have always been impartial to LC pizza but I will tell anyone that this location on north avenue has the greatest customer service. The workers were almost as amazing as the pizza. God bless you all.“

“Cannot say enough about the food, the staff and the ambiance. Whether it is pregame, post-game, special night out, day drinking and dining or late night cocktails and dinner after a late flight this place never, ever disappoints. Its been that way for years and hope it never changes.“

“Manager Josh called to ask if I received my order that was being delivered by Uber Eats and explained that he would have the food made again and delivered quickly. He apologized for the inconvenience and kept me updated. I appreciate the contact when he noticed and issue and corrected it properly.“

“We travel in large group as a Team. They were awesome accommodating us, offering our best way to have the most fun! The staff were super friendly and interacted with us throughout the night. The Boys and parents got in on all the fun!! 10/10 would recommend! We need more places like this!!“

“Rocky Rococo Cookie: For most of my teenage years and twenties, Rocky’s was my go-to pizza chain. Although there are multiple locations, the chain is primarily in Wisconsin. The first restaurant opened in my college town of Madison back in 1974. They’re known for my favorite type of pizza, which is pan style. In the context of a fast-food pizza chain, their crust is thick, soft, chewy, and flavorful. I’m usually a cheese pizza guy most of the time, but if you like sausage Rocky’s sausages are massive.
As delicious as their pizza can be, today I'm focusing on the cookie that came with the meal. I couldn't find much info online other than that they offer freshly baked chocolate chip cookies. That's interesting as the cookie I have is clearly an M&M chocolate chip cookie (not complaining, just an observation). I also was not the one to place the order, just happened to be at the party where it was consumed. The cookies are thin, but they have a nice amount of chewiness to them along with a superb buttery flavor. Then there's the always tasty M&M pieces are milk chocolate chips. Although it's not my ideal cookie (I prefer mine thick, chewy, and with plenty of frosting) it was still delectable. Doughboy approved 😋
Doughboy_Food_Reviews“

“DO NOT LISTEN TO KATE WILLIAMS’ REVIEW SHE IS WRONG! Me and my bro came across this place at Mayfair, we were going to get Rocky’s but I’m so glad we didn’t. This place had the greatest pizza in all of Wisconsin, America and the entire Milky Way galaxy. The workers were nice and the food. Oh the food was phenomenal. Me and bro DEVOURED that pizza and Garlic Bread. Please choose this on your next trip to Mayfair.“

“My husband and I stopped in at this location on 8/5/25, about 2:30 pm to order a pizza. I just wanted to compliment the employees that were there that afternoon. There were several people waiting for their pizzas, but the several young men working behind the counter were so efficient, it took only about 5 minutes to get our pizza. All of them were working really hard, no goofing around, talking or ignoring the customers, as one would so offen find at a fast food chain. I just wanted to commend those young men on their commendable work ethic! We'll likely be visiting this location again!“

“You wouldn’t think this is a good place given the location and appearance of the building, but they always greet you and are friendly. Pizzas are done on time and usually taste great. Writing this review because I know how hard it can be to keep the same workers and also hire high-quality staff for these types of businesses.In contrast the Pizza Hut on Glenview is a great example of an absolute disaster of a business. Orders are ALWAYS wrong, always late and the staff is horrendous. They also like to swipe your CC number and make illegal charges with it. Had to have 2 CC replaced because of this.So great job to this Papa John’s location for being able to keep the same staff for a fairly long time and just being nice to customers.“

“You were all AMAZING with our orders today!! Thank you :)“