“A great addition to Bayshore. I've been here several times since they opened and the pizza is very good! They have a nice cocktail menu- and the space is causal and fun. Date night appropriate, or just hanging out- it fits the bill. My favorite pizza is the Cadillac and it's even good the next day cold!“
“Delicious. We got the pineapple BBQ chicken pizza with thin crust. Crust was beautiful. Good mouthfeel. Good sauce. Nice flavors. Prompt service. It could be a little more affordable. Good for takeout. Lights inside are kind of bright. A little crowded inside.“
“Stopped by after lunch for a take order. Ordered the Jambalaya pasta. The meal was good, kinda sad it didn’t automatically come with anything, but they added bread upon my request. Take out was ready within 10, but I stayed longer to enjoy my cocktail. I had a strawberry lime margarita-perfectly mad. They were offering happy hour discount - will be back with friends. I loved the decor near the bar.“
“I love Rocky rococo I just wish they made super slice pie I don't know if you make them they should I was there yesterday I had a super slice pepperoni and sausage it was good on Saturday I'm going to order a large pizza from Rockies if you haven't tried it you should try it I love to her breast sticks to“
“One of my favorite spots for girls night out or to bring my parents. I had my graduation dinner here and impressed all my relatives. My favorite menu item is the cilantro shrimp. Definitely a must try in Milwaukee if you like great food and top-notch cocktails.“
“I’ve never had a bad experience or bad pizza or bad service at this place. Transfer Pizzeria is a Milwaukee gem. Been going there for 10 years and will continue patronizing.Vegetarian options: Talk to them and they’ll accommodateKid-friendliness: What to say? They treat kids respectfully“
“This is the best Italian place that I've ever been to. Pizza is amazing, appetizers are amazing, drinks (you guessed it) amazing. Just the leftover crust from the pizza is better than the entire pizza at most places. Santo and Greg (the owners) are the nicest gentlemen and greet every guest. Laura is our favorite waitress, she is always amazing. Service is always fantastic, even when they are busy.If you want the best Italian food around, this is the only place to go. Just make sure you make a reservation.“
“I was visiting from out of state for a concert and found this place on google as a late night pizza option! I was not disappointed. Easy ordering, very friendly service when I picked up and one of the BEST pizzas I’ve ever had. I never leave reviews, but this place deserves the recognition.“
“5/1 Update: I just wanted to follow up on my 3 star review from 2 weeks ago. I upvoted to 5 stars due to my experience today. Assistant Manager, Ty, was very friendly and courteous, and went out of the way to make sure I had a good customer experience after running out of one of the toppings I ordered. That was much appreciated. And as I noted earlier the pizza was fantastic, the best Toppers pizza I’ve ever had. Thank you, Ty!Previous review:Nice staff working the front, however, when I initially called I was told they couldn’t handle the request, that it should have gone through the call center. After further explanation, they said they would take my order. Lo and behold, when I picked up my order, it was that same staff member who took my order who also rang me up. I didn’t know the staff at our local Toppers shouldn’t be taking orders? Hmm. Not to mention, they seemed otherwise engaged with another staff member, on a very slooow night.Note: I’ve only had really good experiences at this location up until tonight and the pizza is as good as ever.“