“We can't say enough good things about this place! The food was excellent, the service for dine-in was great, and the servers were so nice and checked on us regularly. We tried the sicilian sliders and they were SO good! We had the thin-crust Milwaukee style pizza. This is definitely are go-to for pizza! It's about a 30 minute drive for us, but it is well worth it.“
“Outstanding pizza! Excellent customer service.I have not ordered fast food pizza for many years. My husband was craving PJ’s so we gave it a chance. I LOVE that their website explains how to order a vegan pizza. ❤️ I love how close this is compared to Waukesha. A quick drive, easy to order online and pickup is right on time.My pizza was cooked perfectly. Fresh ingredients and crust was just right. Very rare.My husband enjoyed his pizza as well (pep and sausage) with cheese.We will be back.Dietary restrictions: Vegan“
“I've been getting their pizza delivered or carry out for many years. It is the best pizza in Sussex like they say or anywhere. I always get the Sussex Supreme thin crust with no green peppers. I don't understand all the negative reviews.Parking: Plenty of free parking“
“The Stillery has a great, varied app menu. We usually get burgers, cubanos and buffalo chicken wraps. They've all been great. Expect a wait for carryout unless you do the Fish Fry Fastlane, pull up and order, fish dinner in under 10 minutes! Inside can be a little loud, they pull in a crowd most nights.“
“Super happy to have returned to Old Germantown restaurant for the third time and first time inside the restaurant. Farm Fresh means extra work, planning and focus on ingredients. Forget instant gratification found in drive through's and fast food mass production-delivery. This is a family run throw back offering awesome craft beers made onsite and many creative personal pizza's. Just like the thousands of small craft breweries throughout the west, sometimes ale/beer types run out, you get to venture to other tastes! If you want some lager canned weeks ago designed for college kids on spring break, this is not a place for you. If you are in a hurry and long ago forgot what restaurant atmosphere is, this is not a place for you. If you need a large backlit sign to find the driveway (like main street America looks today), this is not a place for you. Here is a challenge, find the restaurant without your GPS!Last night we tried the "Milwaukee" pizza and if you grew up in Southeastern Wisconsin you know what a "Milwaukee" pizza should taste and look like. They nailed it and I get the left overs today! Regarding the Ale; I was a taste tester for a global Milwaukee beer company, have traveled the Western hemisphere trying ales and beers all over. The ales here are excellent.If you get an opportunity I highly recommend Old Germantown, enjoy!“
“Went there to pickup a pizza it was ready at the time scheduled the pizza it self is the best I can find in the area and I tried just about everyone around. The only negative thing I can say is they only have one size and it's a large being single the only time I go there is when I have company over (once a month). I would have given them five stars but, due to just having one size I gave them four stars. If they had a medium pizza I would probably be eating there at least once a week if not more.“
“Everything is great, but it doesn’t mean you should be charging people $50 for a pizza. That’s absolutely ridiculous. I would come more, but the price is way too high. Three dollars for spinach is insane! But the pizza was absolutely delicious and I would give you a five if the prices were just lowered a little bit. You need to be fair to your customers. Plus, I would spend a lot more money if the prices were a little bit more fair. Sad that greed Pushes people away. You would make a lot more money if you weren’t so interested in your profits. I know that food is more expensive nowadays, but you could be the bigger person and you could make a turnover faster with lower prices therefore you’re still making that huge profit.“
“My husband and I love coming here! There's a ton of great games to choose from and the owners are super helpful if you need a game suggestion or help with rules. Food is very good and it's great to be able to not have to take a break from playing. The open gaming nights are a lot of fun as well!“
“Exceptional pizza in a hard-to-find (but worth it when you do) location. You can drive, boat or swim to Doc's (on Pewaukee Lake's North Shore) to find out why Wisconsin's cracker-thin crust and piping hot toppings, of the finest quality, piled on in huge quantities PLUS a friendly atmosphere and wicked-good service just beats the pants off of those thick, stuffed, overfilled, mostly-dough pies they call deep dish pizza just south of here! Come to Wisconsin, Eat at Doc's and you'll be forever changed for the better!“
“Very few things in life are consistent, but the food from Papa Murphy's is one of them.The people working here are hard working and polite, and I've never had to worry about a bad order or mistakes. Order, pick up, enjoy.Great work, guys.“