Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay
10677 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay
(920) 854-4685
Customers' Favorites
Green and Gold Pizza
Large Deluxe Pizza
The Green and Gold
Fried Cheese Curds
Old School Pizza
Donation Creation
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Parmesan Knots
Paisano Pizza
Menu
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Wild Tomato management were awesome. We walked in as a party of seven at minutes before they closed. They could’ve sent us away. Instead, they sat us and provided excellent food and service. They didn’t rush us (the rain did). When it started raining they asked if we were moving inside. Refreshing in a world of “this is our policy”.
We had a very yummy pizza with italian sausage, red sauce, and pesto. Also parmesan knots as an appetizer, and New York cheesecake with cherry topping for dessert. We didn't have to wait long to be seated, and our server was very helpful. Definitely worth going back to.
This place was great, nice atmosphere, clean restaurant and friendly service. However they have the same problem as all other pizza places that aren't part of a chain. When the pizza comes out it looks and tastes like the vegetable toppings were put on after the pizza was taken out of the oven. I understand if you cook the pizza long enough to cook the veggies the crust will burn. There has to be a better way
You May Also Like
Goose & Twigs - 2322 Mill Rd
![]()
Coffee & Tea, Bed & Breakfast, Pet Friendly
Grasse's Grill - 10663 N Bay Shore Dr
![]()
New American, American, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Door County Creamery - 10653 N Bay Shore Dr
![]()
American, Cheese Shops, Pet Friendly