Bakeries near Westby

“Yes I love this Amish Bakery. Always good, Very inexpensive. Good variety of goods. Plus they have fresh vegetables and home made canned goods. And some other homemade items that are worth checking out. I only wish they were open all the time but I get it, I'm not trying to gain anymore weight so thank you ?“

“LOVED, LOVED this place. We found this on the 'Only in Your State app (that really needs to be updated tho). The hours are not correct on it. The SUPER NICE couple that runs the bakery are mostly doing online orders since covid now, so call before going if you want to go in person. They welcomed us in anyway and shared stories as well as some treats they had on hand. I had some most incredible samples there and will be ordering soon as they ship anywhere in the US. You won't regret it!“

“Overall the cupcakes were good and the sugar cookies were okay. The design on the cookies was a film like texture that most peeled off and threw away due to the toughness. It was almost like thin plastic that made you question if it was edible. Sugar cookies tasted good otherwise. This was my first time ordering here and I’m likely to order there here again but I’ll be more particular about what a am ordering. I struggled with the ordering process over the phone as the person I spoke with gave very little detail on what flavors or even types of designs they are able to do.“

“We love Rhythum bakeries sandwich bread. I text my order into Mason and he has it ready by Friday at noon. It’s the best sandwich bread around. If you think it’s a bit pricey consider the fact that it is a healthy 2 pound loaf and it tastes fantastic. Once you’ve tried it you will never go back.“

“We sent to Grandma's Bakery to pick up subs for a picnic lunch. The building is well-worn but the smell of fresh bakery was wonderfully inviting. We had custom subs created on fresh wheat and french bread. The meats and veggies were fresh and delicious. The subs were everything we wanted for our picnic and inexpensive to boot! They are primarily a bakery and sub shop with no tables or seating. It appeared their baked goods, Bread, cookies etc were very popular and appeared scrumptious but we did not sample them. This is not a trendy place, big on decor, but a solid old-time bakery with wonderful sandwiches. This will be our go-to place in Cashton for lunch from now on.“