17 Best Italian Restaurants near Williams Bay

“Tremendous food and great service! We always have a fantastic time!!“

“Riga-Tony's Delicatezzi Italiano is the best Italian joint in Delavan, WI, delivering authentic cuisine with unmatched flair. Their homemade pasta and rich, savory sauces are crafted with tradition, while their tender, flavorful meatballs steal the show. Every dish, from baked rigatoni to sandwiches, bursts with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The cozy ambiance and warm service make every visit exceptional—a true Italian gem! 🇮🇹 🇺🇸 🤌🏼“

“💕Where do I start? We were fortunate to find Mama T's Italian Eatery on Friday--the choices were many, the food was excellent, and the server was so personable and helpful. She is a positive asset to your team (wish that I remembered her name.) Can't rave enough about our experience--it will be a long drive from our home, but we will be back! Thank you💕“

“That’s an amazing place, one of the best restaurants. I live in Chicago and one of the reasons that I go to elkhorn is to eat their pizza and garlic bread. It’s so delicious and I starve it everyday.“

“Oh my goodness! Where to begin? The moment you walk in the door you are treated like family. Great music, gorgeous decor, and the food is homemade! Bring a date, you will fall in love again. �“

“We had excellent service with Josue. He was knowledgeable about gluten free and cross contamination. He was attentive and offered up options. The food was delicious and accommodated my celiac disease. It was truly a wonderful experience for celebrating our anniversary.“

“I have lived in Walworth County for 18 years and discovered that Elkhorn Enzo’s has the best pizza in the county. Best ingredients, best authentic family recipes and best service.“

“Ordered pizza, hotdog, fries, shakes and everything was great. Lots to choose from on the menu.“

“Started off dinner with thebucatiui carbonara which is guanicale pasta with fresh pecorino cheese and pepper in a fettucinni pecorino cheese sauce. my wife hadthe Baramundi which is Australian sea bass with the pistachio couscous with peas and crispy enoki mushrooms, and a lemon sauce. She said it was delicious and I had the.limbo do verbose which is venison in a raspberry sauce with sweet pea risotto that was fantastic. She finished dessert with a tiramisu and I had a black coffee with black Sambuca dinner fantastic and our server Tanya took very good care of us.“

“Amazing food and amazing customer service! Taco pizza and the Cheeseburgers are our favorites! Can’t wait to try more from their menu ❤️“

“What a fabulous dinner and server! We experienced a beautiful view, delicious food and wine, and a very knowledgeable and personable server .. Sabrina. Highly recommend Crafted Italia. A wonderful menu with a variety of small plates and dinners. The atmosphere is elegant and the view of Lake Como .. Breathtaking ❤️“

“Great food, good value too! My new regular spot!“

“frist time being here and the food is amazing and I love Authentic Italian food and I havnt found one around until know I had the chees and meat Tortelidi combo and it's was Delicious I'm for sure will come back for sure 😋 thank you for the great experience the staff is amazing and very welcome people for sure highly recommend 😀“

“Stayed at the harbor Shores Hotel in Lake Geneva, with the Ginos attached. Sat by the pool for a while, got hungry and went to order takeout. Was told of the kitchen was slammed, and take out orders on pause. Sat the bar, had an iced tea, and the bartender Emily Made sure that we eventually got some service. When we made our order, we got the sweet-and-sour chicken wings and a medium pepperoni pizza thin crust. The food was delicious! Atmosphere was pleasant, eating at the bar was just what we needed. We’ve eaten here before, last summer and the food was very good. Gino did not disappoint this time around!“

“Very much enjoyed our anniversary at The Getaway! Sat out on their beautiful deck. The calamari was superb, my husband loved his chicken Marsala and I really enjoyed the shrimp Diablo. Our waitress Denise was a pro and added to the great experience. We will be back!“

“From the friendly service to the super delicious food to the huge portions to the extensive menu, Nayeli's has it all. Today I tried their western chicken flatbread... in a word OUTSTANDING!“

“Small place but very cozy. Fantastic service from step one! We ordered a lot of food and dessert- Tiramisu ( and I I am a huge fan! ( I ate a lot :-) believe me - many times in Italy) and everything was great and very tasty. We travel a lot and we can high recommend this place in LG! Thank you!“