20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Reedsville

“I can’t recommend this place enough. Everything is made fresh, and you can truly taste the care and effort put into every item. The pizza dough has this perfect balance of savory flavor with just a subtle hint of sweetness that makes it stand out. The pizzas and subs are consistently amazing, and the pepperoni rolls are easily some of the best I’ve had. On top of that, the owners are incredibly kind and welcoming, which makes the experience even better. You definitely get your money’s worth here—every penny is well spent. 10/10, highly recommend supporting this local gem.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Worst ever food. Waited hour and half for cold food ordered at least busy time. We live five minutes away. Terrible food way over priced.“

“Food, service, & atmosphere are never a disappointment. Dan truly is the man! He knows what he's doing, professional, kind & runs this amazing joint like no other! Meeting pure professionalism with genuinity- Dan & his staff, they make it seem like it comes naturally. Wouldn't spend money on pizza anywhere else!“

“I have been a long term lurker and kept saying I would come by to test the vegan cheese out. Welp tonight was the night, I had a veggie pizza with vegan cheese tonight…it was amazing! Thank you! I will be back!“

“We just started coming here a couple days ago! The best service, the best fresh food, good vibes!!! 😎 Our server server Daunte has been the best we have had in years! This is our new place and we can’t wait to make many more memories here! The McManus family!“

“Awesome pizza. Fresh local ingredients. Fun weekly recipes and all the classics. My favorite pizza in Morgantown and some of the best I’ve had anywhere. Super friendly people too!“

“Casa is a staple of Morgantown eatery, whether it’s this location or downtown. Their pizza always leaves me cheesin

Edit: Their pizza is good, slightly greasy but the crust has a nice crunch, the sauce isn’t overpowering and the cheese is nice and flavorful.“

“This place is the best and the owner is so nice and dedicated to this shop. I had a taco wedgie and it was great!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We visited Nonno Carlo tonight (4/24) with a group of six, and WOW - what an absolute gem! Every single thing we ordered was incredible. The two wood-fired pizzas were perfection - crispy, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. We also shared the meatball hoagie, meatballs with ricotta, antipasto salad, caprese salad, cucumber-tomato salad, Italian chicken salad sandwich, and the Italiano… and then there was the porchetta sandwich - hands down my new favorite sandwich in the universe. I’m still thinking about it. As if that wasn’t enough, we finished with imported gelato (strawberry and caramel), and it was the perfect sweet ending. Beyond the amazing food, the two young ladies working the front were so kind, welcoming, and helpful - it really made the whole experience even better. Do yourself a favor and don’t sleep on this amazing little market & café. We will 100% be back! 🇮🇹🍕🍨“

“Really good food — I’ve been here multiple times and it never disappoints. I’ve seen people mention the prices as a downside, but I completely disagree. Some reviewers don’t realize you’re getting high-quality meats and ingredients, and there really aren’t many places like this in the area. The locals are lucky to have a gem like this. I’d be there twice a week if I could!“

“Our staff was very friendly and the food was excellent 😎“

“I went there with family for my nephews 12th birthday party. His dad ordered the pizzas ahead of time and so by the time we were ready for the pizzas they were delivered. The pizzas were very tasty. I had the all meat with green peppers and it had plenty of toppings. The crust was just the right thickness, especially since I don’t care for super thick crust. There’s only one ladies restroom and one men’s restroom, but for the size of the place I think that was OK. The highlight for me was seeing the super large pizza that they have. I kind of wanted one just for the picture! I think he said it was a 32 inch and it had 52 slices so as to serve 26 people. I will try that next time for sure!“

“I love little ceasars but the kitchen door was open and I saw the guy making the pizzas touch the pizza without gloves. Multiple people’s pizza in fact. And then saw another guy hitting his vape plain as day right in the door way by the food. Listen I’ve worked at McDonald’s… I get it.. but with the door open? And you make eye contact and everything?!!! That’s crazyyy.“

“Tasty pizza and delicious antipasta salad. The staff is very friendly.“

“Great experience. My husband got the tomahawk steak. Delicious, cooked to perfection. Moist. No steak sauce needed. He was able to eat about half. Heated up next day to make a delicious steak salad. I had the cod which also was great. Service was good. Will go back soon.“

“Good really cheap pizzas and more, especially with rising cost of everything these days. I used to think of it as a cheaper tasting pizza but either they started making them better or I've grown accustomed to them because they rival even the priciest of bigger chains.“