“This is the best pizza in Morgantown and they are so sweet. My son and I go in there all the time and get a small cheese well done. Thank you guys for being so amazing. I ate here so much when I was pregnant when I had my son they bought me a pizza hahaha!!!“
“A great spot for a quick pizza and hoagie! The meatball hoagie was perfect. It was a nice size- my sister was only able to eat half of it. The ratio of meat to cheese to sauce was perfect and there were a ton of meatballs packed inside! The bufffalo was perfectly spicy and creamy. We got a byo pizza that was also great! I would definitely come by again. Service was fast and easy! Definitely check this out for a quick dinner or lunch“
“I was surprised at how good these little pizzas were. They are thin and crispy. The toppings seem like good quality and they make them very quickly. They are a bit pricey for the size, but I still think they are worth it. The drizzles are a nice touch too.“
“Had to wait an hour for the pizza but it was amazing. Pulled pork mac n chs like who knew, on a pizza. Amazing. And I ordered during dinner rush so no surprise on the wait time. Place was super busy for good reason, amazing food here so ofc every1 is rushing the place. Staff was doing their best to keep up“
“Showed up on a Tuesday at 2pm. Great customer service from a very nice man that just smiled all the time. The pizza was glorious. My wife and I ate in and had a nice little lunch date. He even came over to ask how everything was. We had it all gone by then. Good pizza. Great customer service.“
“Amazing food. We’re sitting here eating now already thinking about what we want next time we come back! Super cool imported goods, homemade mozzarella, affordable wine. Vegetarian food is specifically labeled vegetarian, which made it super easy for us. We will be back!“
“Absolutely love this place. They have one side for people who have children or who don't want to be in a bar amd then the other side is a nice bar. It's very clean no matter which side you decide to sit down and eat. Their pizza is so good definitely recommend if you haven't already had their pizza. I'm not much on bars but I like this one. They play music from the 70s and 80s the music from when I was growing up. They have a nice parking lot and they are all so nice to their customers. They make you feel like they really want you there and to come back. Of course I've been eating their pizza since my boys were kids and they grew up eating this pizza now they bring their kids to eat this pizza.“
“The food is always good here, I've only had it a few times but it never disappoints. Staff are friendly and the prices are good. Heads up, I always forget but they can't take tips on a card payment. The pizza here is delicious, and I can't wait to try the other menu items, they have hoagie, calzones, salads, and some other items too.“
“I ordered delivery today and although they don’t mention the $3 delivery fee, they charge one. In addition, the fee goes not go to the delivery person. Weird.The food was exactly how I requested it and very good.Next time, I will order through DoorDash so I know all of my fees up front.“
“For a small chain restaurant, this is pretty damn good. Their specialty pizzas are a little pricy, but worth it if you're looking for a fancy or unique pizza. Grape and gorgonzola is fantastic. The beer selection here is pretty good, with some local craft options.Vegetarian options: Several vegetarian specialty pizzas“
“I haven't gone into the restaurant, however I get door dash to my dorm. I get their gluten-free pizza with the garlic knots and a side salad. The gf crust is good, nothing great, but good! The garlic knots are super tasty as well. I haven't ran into any troubles, and hope to at some time, make it to the actual restaurant.“
“Best American Pizza in Morgantown! Wings are great too, other menu options aren't just littles extras worth ignoring for the pizza, everything is pretty good! They go heavy on the topping and can be very filling, so decent amount of food for the price.“
“This was my first time eating here and I was very pleased with how it went. I ordered the jumbo cut wings and potato wedges and let me tell you there potato wedges were HUGE and all though they were massive they were perfectly cooked. The wings were perfectly cooked and if you dip them in there ranch it is amazing, plus I asked where they got there ranch and it is all homemade. The staff was amazing and are waitress was the best I forgot her name but she was super kind and even got me ranch to take home with me. Overall 11/10 some of the best food I’ve ever had.“
“great beer great pizza great sandwiches great cocktails. win for the wife, all of the kids ranging 6-14yo and a favorite experience for the swim team's state championship weekend. i think they are moving to a bigger spot or opening a second location.“
“Myself and Andy were asked to perform before an evening WVU football game. A light audience at 1st but by game time, a nice enthusiatic and appreciative audience gathered. The game was fun to watch and WVU won!!!The staff were absolutely great. Sarah Beth made sure we had food and drink throughout the night.I ate the "Pulled Pork Sandwich" piled high, juicy and delicious w/ some great tasting fries. A great selection of brews make it an awesome place with an awesome atmosphere and great food!!“
“every single time I go to West Virginia, I swing by here and buy a bunch of the chili dogs. I don't know what it is, or why, but they have the best chili I've ever had. When I talk to people at my job and they're cutting through Point Marion PA I tell them to swing by Cottrells and give them the adress, keep an eye out for the Hot Dog sign and you'll have a good time!“
“I recently had the pleasure of dining here, and it exceeded all my expectations. From the moment I walked in, the warm atmosphere enveloped me, creating the perfect ambiance for a delightful dining experience. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, making me feel welcomed and valued throughout my visit. But the real star of the show was the food. Each dish was a masterpiece, bursting with flavor and expertly prepared.“
“Good pizza, good crunch in every bite. Feel like there could be some more to the sauce, almost a nonfactor to the taste of the pizza. Get it with a thing of the mikes hot honey, adds some sweetness and overall complexity to the flavor of the pizza. Service was good and pizza came out in a timely manner.“
“Ordered 2 large pizzas. They were so good, haven’t ordered from there in a long time but after I had seen they had new management I had to give it another try. The sauce they use is delicious and the dough and topping just taste so fresh, pizza wasn’t greasy either. Will definitely be placing more orders there. My whole family enjoyed it which isn’t easy for us to all like one thing.Parking: The location is a bit hard to get in and out of. Crossing through traffic. But worth it“
“We called them up to ask if we could order over the phone and they deliver. Without hesitation, they said yes. They answered al our questions about their menu. We've not eaten there before and wanted to try some new things, and were pleasantly surprised. While the pizza may not be "authentic Italian" ..not like anything is around here..it's wonderful.. We loved both the new york and the Sicilian. It's unique...not like nearly every other thing we seem to find in morgantown. We truly appreciated something different than norm yet still quite good. We will absolutely be trying it again and trying new menu items. Ps..salad with homemade ranch was a hit with my fam too, and as a thank you, they gave us free baklava.“