32 Best Pizza Restaurants in Morgantown

“We have eaten here several times. Everything we have had has been delicious. The garlic knots deserve special mention. Highly recommend. We will be back!“

“This is the best pizza in Morgantown and they are so sweet. My son and I go in there all the time and get a small cheese well done. Thank you guys for being so amazing. I ate here so much when I was pregnant when I had my son they bought me a pizza hahaha!!!“

“Delicious, timely, and friendly! Will definitely be back!“

“I wasn't expecting alot from this place. But I have to say there pizza is really good. There toppings are fresh the sauce is amazing . The crust was cooked perfect. The manger was so nice actually came over and asked if everything was good. So if you get a chance go and build your own pizza we'll worth the money.“

“The boneless wings were huge and different sauce options. Friendly staff. Very clean.“

“This was the best food I’ve tasted in a long time! You want fresh and creative food this is your spot. I tried multiple menu items and all were fresh and perfectly paired. I’ll be making the 45 minute drive to eat here way more now. The staff all had very kind personalities and were very helpful. If you haven’t tried this place you’re missing out.“

“Absolutely love this place. Great food and great service?“

“Best thin crust pizza in Morgantown. Wings were good too!“

“Ate at this location today for the first time. Nice, clean, atmosphere. Very friendly waiter/waitress, Stacey and Grayson. They worked together very well to make sure we had everything we needed. Excellent customer service!!!! Especially from Grayson, he was young & young kids usually get a bad rap. They gave us menu suggestions. Food was prepared quick & tasted great! We Will absolutely return here again!!“

“I’ve never had a bad pizza at Pies & Pints. Whenever I’m close to one, I’m there. Salads are amazing as well. If you love root beer, I recommend having a glass as well.“

“The best pizza in Morgantown!!! Stop by and tell them Cousin Dave sent you!!“

“We love their pizza and they have the best cheesesteaks in Morgantown! Highly recommend! As a bonus, their employees have always been beyond nice and helpful every single time we have ordered from here.“

“every single time I go to West Virginia, I swing by here and buy a bunch of the chili dogs. I don't know what it is, or why, but they have the best chili I've ever had. When I talk to people at my job and they're cutting through Point Marion PA I tell them to swing by Cottrells and give them the adress, keep an eye out for the Hot Dog sign and you'll have a good time!“

“Great food !“

“The guy at the register made sure my food was freshly made instead of giving me food that sit under the heat light that was ready to be thrown away like other places I've been to have done in the past so I give credit to this specific little Caesars. The guy that was working that day deserves a raise!! Keep up the wonderful work!! Us food lovers greatly appreciate your generosity!“

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..“

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..“

“Ate at this location today for the first time. Nice, clean, atmosphere. Very friendly waiter/waitress, Stacey and Grayson. They worked together very well to make sure we had everything we needed. Excellent customer service!!!! Especially from Grayson, he was young & young kids usually get a bad rap. They gave us menu suggestions. Food was prepared quick & tasted great! We Will absolutely return here again!!“

“Just tried Fox's. Excellent Pizza cooked to perfection ❤️. The menu is loaded with things like hoagies, taco pizza, wings, Strombolis and seven varieties of Gourmet Fries.“

“There is no better deal of the market than little Caesar’s pizza. I probably stop at this location once a week to once every two weeks (my husband swears he needs it to watch football lol). The staff is always timely and friendly. We have been stopping by this location for years and haven’t had a single issue! Just good hot pizza“

“First time there yesterday. Had the meatballs with ricotta and the Italian sandwich. Both were excellent!! Clean shop and very friendly staff!“

“laid back people, quick service“

“I frequently visit 2 Brothers several times throughout a month,; from customer service to timeliness of receiving your meal is top notch. Weather, you are dining in or takeout. Everything is excellent with great customer service. It’s one of Morgantown’s best kept secrets, and is highly recommended ‼️

Vegetarian options: Garden Salad“

“Not to be confused with Jersey Mike's! This is the real deal. On the restaurant side, their Philly steak and cheese is unmatched outside of Philly! Pizza, also excellent.
And then, they have a solid selection of Boars Head meats and cheeses at far less than the big retailer not too far away. While you're there, throw in some virginia made Route 11 potato chips, or try their homemade sides. I've never left unhappy!“

“wonderful place to play.. Great staff, Great food, Wonderful atmosphere“

“I had gotten sandwiches from here via delivery in the past, but had never gone to dine in until today. So I didn't plan well, and had a doctor appointment to get to, and I didn't realize how pressed for time I was until I was waiting for our food. I went back up and asked for our food to be switched to to-go, and the people were so nice about it. Very apologetic, even though they'd hadn't done anything wrong. They even brought us pizza to eat so we had something before we left. The food is amazing and the service is better. 12/10 ????????“

“I am sorta frequently devouring a pizza. I have devoured some pizza yeah! It's only this , I only eat Domino's pizza and purt near well won't eat any other pizza because well..... Other pizza places don't consecutively make delicious pizza . I've never had a bad pie , especially at the pleasant street Domino's. That has gotta be the greatest pizza place in the world. It ads up .I don't do math but I know that two plus two is two twos . So .. yes this is the only choice . Why because the store is clean smells good and eversince they got rid of that squirrely looking blonde hair kid that was always so rude. I'm a felon so I know a thing or two about breaking the law and hands down pizza this good should be illegal. Like me,, ba da chow. Anyways Dominoes is the only pie factory that makes it into the future. Just ask Sly. I'll tell you what ol Sly thinks. He said "when I turn my hat rownd I'm like a mack truck".that ers purt near how I feel when golfing down a slice. I feel like a dang ol Mack Truck man. Eating Dominoes is where I'll be soon as I get paid . I'm gon grab a good deal on a yummy pie .

Parking: I came I parked I picked up and blew my horn two times . All in one shot . In the parking lot yeah.

Kid-friendliness: Well they have a kids viewing station so kids can watch the pizza get made . So yeah can you say educational. Yeah“

“Went to Whitetail Crossing for lunch and sat at the bar. Staff and patrons very friendly. Decent variety on food choices, beer, and liquor. Wings were excellent for an appetizer and then we both had burgers. You can choose from waffle fries, crinkle cut, brew pub, or sweet potato fries. Guys at the bar had pizza and they said it was great too. They even offered us some. Definitely will be back.“

“I love little ceasars but the kitchen door was open and I saw the guy making the pizzas touch the pizza without gloves. Multiple people’s pizza in fact. And then saw another guy hitting his vape plain as day right in the door way by the food. Listen I’ve worked at McDonald’s… I get it.. but with the door open? And you make eye contact and everything?!!! That’s crazyyy.“

“Really nice ambiance inside. We had dinner at the bar on a Friday night, the place was booked up but we were able to walk in around 5:30 to catch the end of Happy hour. We really enjoyed the cocktails, meatballs, and the Tuscan chicken Alfredo. The pizza was mediocre, the texture of the crust was soggy and didn't seem to rise. However, the service was excellent and we still enjoyed the meal. I'd definitely go back and try other items on the menu.“

“Really great pepperoni and banana pepper XL pizza and the cheese breadsticks were amazing! The Gyro salad was very good and a large salad! Grape leaves were a great surprise and very good! Overall a very good restaurant with quality food! Thank you Papa Allen’s Pizza !“

“Great food great service and great servers when I was there last my 1 yr old autistic son had a small melt down and I really couldn't eat instead one of the servers came over and started talking to him so I could enjoy my meal love the pizzas“