25 Best Pizza Restaurants in Morgantown

“Great pizza and great sandwiches at a very fair price.“

“Was looking for a good Pizza Place after the bar and found this gem!! The Pizza was amazing! Probably the best I have had so far! The Wings were so good! Perfectly cooked and tasty Honey BBQ sauce!! The owner was super friendly, sweet, and interactive with us! Highly recommend!!“

“I had a salad and turkey sub dining in. The staff was very helpful and professional. Food was really good, fresh salad, amazing sub roll: too much to eat all at once. Very low key,clean, and lots of take out business. If I can come back this way again, I would definitely stop in!“

“Stopped in over the weekend and ordered 2 calzones! The best calzone I have EVER had!! It was so fresh and the dough was amazing! The fries are also out of this world! Can’t wait to go back 🙂“

“We just started coming here a couple days ago! The best service, the best fresh food, good vibes!!! 😎 Our server server Daunte has been the best we have had in years! This is our new place and we can’t wait to make many more memories here! The McManus family!“

“Salad was fresh, pizza was perfect, and fries made just right! The portions are huge!“

“Awesome pizza. Fresh local ingredients. Fun weekly recipes and all the classics. My favorite pizza in Morgantown and some of the best I’ve had anywhere. Super friendly people too!“

“We tried this gem last week and have been here twice already! I’m not sure if the food or employees are the best part… seriously.

The lady at the register is SO sweet and helpful with ordering and introducing their offerings. She is not the owner, but you think she is because she’s so vested into the entire interaction and experience- even offering plates and such to go! Who does that?!? She does! 🩷

I really like that they offer a variety of pizza slices and pizza rolls ready-to-go. The pizza is perfectly crispy and yummy. Somehow they have managed to load up the toppings and the crust doesn’t get wet and gross. Pure magic!

Oh! And fresh salads and deeeelicious garlic knots, too! Go, go, go to Casa D’Amici!“

“I would highly recommend this place to everyone. not only do they have a great product.. they have employees with big hearts... we have been without water for 2 days and the delivery driver offered to go and get us a case of water... we have some stocked so it was declined... however that gesture meant the world to me and my family .“

“wonderful place to play.. Great staff, Great food, Wonderful atmosphere“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We visited Nonno Carlo tonight (4/24) with a group of six, and WOW - what an absolute gem! Every single thing we ordered was incredible. The two wood-fired pizzas were perfection - crispy, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. We also shared the meatball hoagie, meatballs with ricotta, antipasto salad, caprese salad, cucumber-tomato salad, Italian chicken salad sandwich, and the Italiano… and then there was the porchetta sandwich - hands down my new favorite sandwich in the universe. I’m still thinking about it. As if that wasn’t enough, we finished with imported gelato (strawberry and caramel), and it was the perfect sweet ending. Beyond the amazing food, the two young ladies working the front were so kind, welcoming, and helpful - it really made the whole experience even better. Do yourself a favor and don’t sleep on this amazing little market & café. We will 100% be back! 🇮🇹🍕🍨“

“Get a sheet pizza and eat cheap for a week! love this place“

“The best pizza in Morgantown!!! Stop by and tell them Cousin Dave sent you!!“

“This place is the best and the owner is so nice and dedicated to this shop. I had a taco wedgie and it was great!“

“What a great first-time experience! The atmosphere was clean and modern, the pizza was fantastic (my family gave it a 9.2/10!), and the wings were some of the best we've ever had. On top of that, the staff was incredibly friendly, especially the young lady at the front counter, who made us feel very welcomed. Great food, outstanding service, and an amazing value. We'll definitely be back the next time we're in the area!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“it was my first time irdering and it was the best food i have ever ate, the sandwiches are extremely big and full of meat and vegs and cheese, great place to dine in or order out“

“It's a cute place. Lots of parking. Location not the greatest as far as being seen from the main road. Food was very good, except for the Alfredo sauce. Our kind waitress took it off of our bill. Guess we will stick with the other items besides pasta! The wings and the hot pepper cheese balls were amazing! We will be back again to try more things!“

“Ryan is the manager at this location and was very accommodating and helpful with our phone/online order. Placed a same day large order for our sports team, he and the crew made sure everything was completed in a timely manner. Very polite and accurate with the order. He just earned a customer for life 🤙🏻“

“Really good food — I’ve been here multiple times and it never disappoints. I’ve seen people mention the prices as a downside, but I completely disagree. Some reviewers don’t realize you’re getting high-quality meats and ingredients, and there really aren’t many places like this in the area. The locals are lucky to have a gem like this. I’d be there twice a week if I could!“

“The guy at the register made sure my food was freshly made instead of giving me food that sit under the heat light that was ready to be thrown away like other places I've been to have done in the past so I give credit to this specific little Caesars. The guy that was working that day deserves a raise!! Keep up the wonderful work!! Us food lovers greatly appreciate your generosity!“

“Me and my friends love wine bar! We love their cocktails and wine. I personally recommend the white sangria. Their charcuterie boards are great and their pizzas are also great! All of the pickled foods you can add are so good and I recommend trying something new! Generally when we go we get snacks and wine so I cannot speak to the meals. But if they are like the snacks then I am sure they are great! If you can stop in, I definitely would!“

“I love little ceasars but the kitchen door was open and I saw the guy making the pizzas touch the pizza without gloves. Multiple people’s pizza in fact. And then saw another guy hitting his vape plain as day right in the door way by the food. Listen I’ve worked at McDonald’s… I get it.. but with the door open? And you make eye contact and everything?!!! That’s crazyyy.“

“Was unaware of store hours today with their summer hours starting. But placed an online order for pick up, and whoever answered offered to deliver it free of charge with them not opening for an hour. Person called me on the way to delivery and delivered it great! The person I talked to on the phone was very friendly and seemed extremely nice, we go to this place often and are treated very well and the entire staff is very friendly. Food is also always good as well!“