12 Best Italian Restaurants in Morgantown

“The service was great. Took the bartender a long time to make two drinks. I enjoy eating and spending time with family but three and a half hours in a restaurant was a stretch. Steaks were slightly over cooked. Hoping it was just a bad night for the kitchen.“

“Nonno Carlo was the perfect choice for our pre graduation luncheon. Nick was great to work with and made planning this celebration stress-free. Everything was fresh and delicious. Don’t skip this gem of a place to eat and shop in Morgantown. MUST try the fresh mozzarella! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Always wonderful service and delicious food !! Highly recommend“

“delicious food, wonderful atmosphere. the chicken Alfredo was delicious along with the desserts..highly recommend.“

“Had the lunch menu. I absolutely loved my fettuccine Alfredo with broccoli, however my husband ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and it tastes of just sausage. Might be okay for some. He wasn't a fan of it. But, the waitress was great.“

“So I just found out about this place from some friends and I was not disappointed. First to arrive was my soup, not too salty and not under salted either, which is a problem I find in a lot of soups: it was prefectly seasoned. Had the Zucchini planks and loaded fries for an appetizer. Fantastic, the Zucchini was cut nice and thin, the breading was nice and crispy and the red sauce was the best I've ever had from any restaurant. Loaded fries were pretty awesome too. Then came our entrees, I had the gnocchi with tomato sauce and my partner had a cold Italian sub. Loved it, favorite part was the pepperoncinis. I suspected he gnocchi was fresh and not frozen from the taste of it, and the same tomato sauce used for the Zucchini planks was on the gnocchi (secretly I was hoping for this as I ran out of the sauce for my Zucchini). That sauce is so good!
Overall 10/10, will dine again. Thank God they deliver to my area.

Vegetarian options: Zucchini planks, pasta dishes, gnocchi“

“Excellent pasta and service!“

“San Marzano was nothing short of perfect! Isabella (server) was on point, personable, friendly and informative overall awesome to work with. The fresh bread was delectable and endless. It’s so good and don’t worry if your table eats a whole loaf there’s always more! Cocktails were very refreshing and booming with flavor! I went with a tequila based lemonade (forgot the name)…..well a couple. Appetizer: We went with the Fried Raviolis for an appetizer and they were amazing! I finished with the Fra Diavolo ~ Spicy Cream “from the devil” with shrimp and it was to die for! (Spicy) Desert was a Tiramisu (home made) it was a great way to finish the dining experience at this fine Italian Restaurant. Things to mention, after reading other reviews, we came in early on a Tuesday and we’re immediately seated and served, others have mentioned waiting, I can only imagine how busy this place gets on Friday/Saturday nights and holiday weekends so make reservations if you’re planning a visit. They have an outdoor patio with a nice authentic feel to it and the inside decor is very swanky as well. Cheat Lake/Morgantown locals don’t sleep on this joint, it’s a gem. I’ve been to Pugs, Olivario’s and Nano’s while they are all nice choices this one stands out to me as the best dinner option. Nano’s is great lunch option. Price and portions were very fair and portions, well you’re probably going home with left overs. I can not wait to go back! I may treat myself this Father’s Day! If your dad likes Italian cuisine then knock his socks off with a reservation to San Mariano’s! If you’ve gotten this far check out other places I have been on my Instagram account @motownfooddude“

“This is a late night favorite for my son and I. The staff members are such nice people. We went up late one night and when we got there he had to use the restroom. As I'm standing in line he comes back from the restroom and says to me that it's locked and had an out of order sign. I told him it's okay we would get something to eat and I would take him down the road. Just as I say this to him, the lady working the cash register looks directly at my son and rambles off a number. He smiles and walks back to the restroom. As I stood there in confusion, she just kind of smiled at me. As I go to get our pizza my son comes out of the restroom. He walked straight to the front counter and said to the lady thank you very much I had to pee really bad!! If you've read any of my other reviews you know how I feel about customer service. Because of this woman's generosity towards my son that night we only get pizza from here on our late night outings not to mention they really do have the BEST PIZZA in the area!!!!

Kid-friendliness: All the staff members are always very nice and polite to my son.“

“Ate at this location today for the first time. Nice, clean, atmosphere. Very friendly waiter/waitress, Stacey and Grayson. They worked together very well to make sure we had everything we needed. Excellent customer service!!!! Especially from Grayson, he was young & young kids usually get a bad rap. They gave us menu suggestions. Food was prepared quick & tasted great! We Will absolutely return here again!!“

“I had gotten sandwiches from here via delivery in the past, but had never gone to dine in until today. So I didn't plan well, and had a doctor appointment to get to, and I didn't realize how pressed for time I was until I was waiting for our food. I went back up and asked for our food to be switched to to-go, and the people were so nice about it. Very apologetic, even though they'd hadn't done anything wrong. They even brought us pizza to eat so we had something before we left. The food is amazing and the service is better. 12/10 ????????“

“I recently had my baby shower here in the Clara room. The room itself is beautiful as is with drapery hanging from the ceiling and it only got better with our decorations. Rob the manager made sure to have tables/chairs set up with napkins and linens when we arrived. He was very attentive during the entire shower and made sure we had everything we needed. The food was hot and delicious and a vegetarian meal was provided for my veggie guest. Rob even brought me sparking grape juice so I could feel included while my guests enjoyed sangria. Everything was lovely and I definitely recommend having your bridal/baby showers or rehearsal dinners here.“