50 Best Italian Restaurants near Mcmurray

“From the valet parker to the hostess to the waiter Russell it was an awesome night. He was so attentive, informative, and funny. We loved our meals and highly recommend it. Food is delicious!!“

“I always have the best food here! Their pink pasta is amazing.“

“Great place for pizza, wings, drinks & it won't break your bank. Also, I'm somewhat of a pizza FIEND, & they're pizza ? definitely makes my Top 5, & that's saying a lot. You can get 2 slices of pepperoni ? for under $7 but the slices are HUGE & DELICIOUS!!!“

“Jocelyn was incredible. So friendly , so fun. Made the whole experience a great one. This was our first time ever at Anthony’s. We just moved from Denver in and we can’t wait to come back. The meatballs. The hot honey pizza. And and and the Espresso martini was maybe one of the best ones we have ever had.“

“We were passing through the area and stopped in Pizzaz to grab a bite to eat and grab a drink at the suggestion of Kevin Dale. This is on my must frequent list as a result. The establishment was clean to include the restrooms, spacious, staff was very inviting and friendly, they were attentive but not overbearing, food was home made, delicious, generous portions and prices were good. The Owner arrived, was approachable, communicated with his customers and just added to that friendly and inviting atmosphere. I will definitely go back and recommend Pizzaz if your taking the family out to dinner or want to grab a drink with a few friends. We came back a month later and guess what, it was even better then the first time. We brought a crew 20+ to see and hear Dip n Dale and enjoy some food and drinks. The only thing better than the food was the staff and owner, Jerry. We had the pleasure of having Stephanie and let me tell you she was on her A game. We will be back.“

“I've become obsessed with the "whacked chicken" hoagie! I've ordered it 4 times at PrimoHoagies. I've been to this location twice and the one in the strip twice. Every visit has been excellent. I order the smallest size and it's just enough to fill me up! The total comes to around $10.“

“Great restaurant. Amazing full American Italian experience. Super staff!“

“Visited for our first time tonight. We’ve been talking about going here for at least a year and never stopped in. Boy were we missing out. The food is excellent. Big portions if that’s what you’re looking for. One portion can feed two. And the cream puff is amazing! It fed four of us. Don’t sleep on this restaurant like we did“

“My wife and I had dinner there tonight 8/22 our 43 wedding anniversary. First timers there and the meal was delicious! From the fried zucchini app to the Seafood trio meal perfect. Thank you for a wonderful dinner!“

“The food is great, staff are professional and the food is definitely, plentiful“

“From the moment we walked through the door the staff, drinks, the food, and the service were top notch! Topped off with great desserts and meeting chef/owner Greg we can't recommend LeoGreta enough and can't wait to return!“

“Best restaurants I ever eat we are customer's over 28 years“

“Don’t sleep on Fredo’s! The food is great, and the owner is excellent. She is great with service, cooking quickly, making suggestions. She really makes you feel at home at Fredo’s.

My favorites are the wings, Italian sandwich, and gyros. They do all the little things right. A true diamond in the rough!“

“Visiting family in the area, we were very impressed with Bella’s. I give the highest rating review for their service and quality. We loved the salads, eggplant parmigiana Chicken Marsala, Lou & Lisa“

“Arleo's Pizza is AMAZING. Their pizza is to die for!! And I'm a bit of a pizza snob lol. The staff is on-task, on-time, friendly and funny! And the prices are quite reasonable. 10/10 I would reccomend.“

“As a tutoring business we require healthy, quality, brain food for us to provide to both our staff and students. Piada has partnered with us on providing students with rewards through their "smart noodle" program which is a big hit. Students love the food, and we love providing them a great reward opportunity that parents will feel good about feed their children. As a staff we thoroughly enjoy the food they provide us, the catering is easy and streamlined for businesses, and both Missy the store manager and Amanda the marketing manager has been such a joy to partner with. As a business we cant reccomend Piada enough!“

“Our recent visit to Olive Garden in Pittsburgh was truly memorable, thanks to our exceptional host, Brennan. From the moment we arrived, Brennan’s attentiveness and efficiency stood out, making us feel welcome and well cared for. His prompt service and warm demeanor transformed our meal into a delightful experience. It’s rare to find such genuine hospitality, and Brennan’s dedication to ensuring we had a great time was evident in every interaction. Olive Garden is fortunate to have him, and we look forward to returning for another wonderful evening.“

“Amazing food. The buffalo chicken pizza and fresh cut fries are the best around!“

“The food is delicious! We've been going for years. Love the staff!“

“We order takeout from Armstrongs Express quite often and it’s always consistently good! My husband loves their wings. We’ve tried a lot of items on the menu and are always satisfied and full. The staff is so friendly and kind!! I also love that they have a few parking spots reserved for takeout costumers since that parking lot can get busy. Only downside is that they are closed on Sundays when we often want to order takeout“

“Fantastic food. Great atmosphere, friendly people. Drink selection was also awesome. Will be returning soon!“

“absolutely the best restaurant. Love Chris amazing bartender“

“Our server was just bizarre. Running around like a chicken with her head cut off. She was forgetting things and screwing things up. She would basically run away while we were still talking to her. This was 7pm on a Saturday. After forgetting my soup, I was eventually brought an incredibly messy bowl, as if the soup was literally thrown into the bowl. She would say she was going to get us refills and then come back without refills. She did package our leftovers which was nice of her and offer us more bread.“

“Armstrongs has AWESOME food. Love their Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers.☺️“

“Staff could've been a little friendlier, but otherwise a very nice place.

Update: Staff was nicer this time, but I was not happy that no one told us that happy hour prices didn't apply to restaurant patrons, only at the bar.“

“First of all I want to say my family and I absolutely love Pasta Too. Raymond runs a fine establishment and before today we have never had an issue. Today however our server completely ruined our experience at Pasta Too. Ca***e, our server acted like every request we had was a chore. She was ignorant and made both my family and I feel like a bother. I’m not sure if this is common with her but we have never had such a terrible dinning experience. Especially at Pasta Too. Other than that the food and every single other server we’ve dined with there has been incredible. We will be back. But we will request anyone but her as a server.“

“The is food is unbelievable good and the staff is awesome!“

“Just ate there. Didn’t seem like anything was actually homemade. Not good. 1 from our group is now sick. And the hostesses were too wrapped up in their conversation with each other to wish us a good night or thank us for coming. First and last time to ever visit here.“

“I sent my friends to this place with my warmest recommendations. I visit this restaurant often. This recommendation is always successful. The dishes they serve are great and the crew is very friendly and cooperative. always when we eat in this place we have a pleasing time. I warmly recommend this restaurant.“

“Our favorite restaurant in Pittsburgh!“

“Great food and service. Portions were perfect.“

“came in to have a nice dinner with family and friends and was lucky to have Emily as our server. Her attitude was exciting and positive and she accommodated us wonderfully as my husband has dietary restrictions. Will definitely be back and will always be asking to be taken care of my Emily!!“

“Excellent food, great staff! One of our new work "go-to's" for lunch! Keep it up!“

“Hubby and I went on a whim after a Steelers game. Dining room was quiet, even though the separate bar was still animated after the Steelers win.
Spaghetti and Meatballs was on special, and it WAS special and a generous serving! Blockhouse Pumpkin Ale on tap served in a
cinnamon sugar rimmed glass. Yummy!
We took a tiramisu to go, it was so good and definitely enough for TWO.
We'll be back, for sure!“

“terrific food and service ~ staff was great Saturday night as usual. 👍“

“Best pizza i have ever had in my 50 years on earth, we drive 3 hours away just to eat this pizza!!“

“We sat on the outdoor covered patio on a perfect day. It was great! Thin crust pizza was very good and not greasy crust! We had sausage and zucchini pizza. It was excellent. Sauce is a little spicy but delicious! Debbie our server was so nice and helpful!“

“Comfortable neighborhood bar“

“The server was excellent, friendly, helpful and prompt on any service needed. I got the all you can eat pasta so that I could try some of the different sauces. The meat sauce was excellent as always. The Alfredo was very good but I think it would have been better if I had gotten some chicken with it. The five cheese sauce was not very good, I know they have had it for many years but it's just too bland.“

“Highly recommend! Food is amazing and thoughtfully prepared. Service is wonderful!! We have been to Albero Verde at least 6 times in the last three months! We are very picky about where we dine and Albero Verde exceeds expectations every time! Best BYOB policy too! Bonus: It’s cool to be able to watch the kitchen in action!“

“The food is awesome, great pizza and the wings are phenomenal. Their new dining room is great for friends to hang together“

“Excellent Pizza 🍕 I'll be back!“

“I had did my multi-class high school reunion there and my baby shower. Clean beautiful venue and professional friendly staff. Anna is so easy and great to work with.“

“Jen is great! Make an appointment! I was well taken care of!“

“Was here this past Saturday for a private gathering on the second floor. Did was very good, it was presented buffet style. Only negative I had was entrance was from the one side of the restaurant up a rather steep flight of stairs. I was curious what they did in the winter time to prevent people from slipping on the stairs and the rational of this as apposed to having a stairway from inside the restaurant. Other than that like I said the food was very good, full bar and the one waitress did a fantastic job.

Update, ate here last week for lunch and again tonight 9/19/24, I think this will be my new go to, closer to home and better menu and they are open till 11pm, the kitchen also closesat 11.“

“Recently discovered Italian Village South Park. Everything we have had there, stromboli, pizza, hoagies has been very good. The service is fast and reliable. Definitely great pizza!“

“First timer here. We just had the Sicilian with pepperoni. It was absolutely delicious. The sauce wasn’t over sweet or over spicy. It was the perfect accompaniment to the light and fluffy pillow like dough with the ends having the perfect amount of crunch. Great balance all around. We will definitely be ordering more of this in the future it was BOMB“

“their plum tomato pizza with the cold cheese is the best, and not too pricey either. this is our favorite, deff recommend!“

“We have been there twice in the last week and it was GREAT! Best steak hoagie on the planet. We also really liked Ashley our server.“

“Ordered delivery through Uber eats and the pizza was exceptional! My husband and I loved the Athena pizza. crust was thinking and foldable. not too crispy and not too soggy. it was just right. Pesto Bread sticks were also on point and their ranch is delicious. Will definitely be ordering again!“