50 Best Italian Restaurants near Jefferson Hills

“I am so glad my husband and I found Yoli's. We went there for the 2nd time tonight and every single thing we got was phenomenal just like the 1st time! From their salads, to the bread and oil, to their Yoli Rolis, to the stuffed shells, to the Grandma Bevy, the food is just unbelievable. I got the crab cake tonight and I have to say, it was one of the best I've ever had, and I've had them in Maryland! We got the canookie for dessert and it was bigger than our heads but unbelievably amazing. Plus everything is SUPER reasonably priced! On top of everything else, the staff is extremely friendly! This is definitely our go-to restaurant from here on out. I can't wait for many more dinners at Yoli's!“

“this has become my wife and I's favorite Italian restaurant in the South Hills. portions are huge. Food is absolutely delicious. Quick warning though if you order the stuffed hot peppers they will be HOT. They're absolutely delicious though!“

“I had a birthday party this weekend and ordered ahead for 14 pizzas and 2 trays of salad. From start to finish the customer service was EXCELLENT. After placing my order I received another confirmation call and then a follow up call the day after. That type of attention makes you feel like they value their customers. Even the driver was awesome. The delivery was on time. She helped carry the food inside the venue and she was super friendly. The pizza was fresh, hot, and delicious. I highly recommend ordering from this site.“

“A group of 5 of us visited Dish last night and the meals were amazing. Grilled Squid, the best I have ever had. Where else can you find it not breaded and fried? Add to that their amazing sardines so fresh and good. Pasta Funghi another high. Exquisite detail to taste in every dish. The owners go way out of their way to make you feel welcomed and happy and very satisfied. A must visit when you are lucky enough to get a reservation though other friends have happily sat at the bar for dinner just to be there!! Kudos to Dish!“

“I come here whenever I am in town. I love the oysters rockefeller and zucchini for apps and the chicken a la johnnys for dinner. The prices are great and I love the entertainment on a Saturday night. It's a wonderful, fun and relaxing evening!“

“My family and friends celebrated my retirement at Storms last night. The food and service were incredible! Thank you to Stephanie and her team for a fantastic evening! If you haven’t checked out Storms yet, you REALLY must! Fantastic, authentic Italian food!💕“

“Amazing food and a great atmosphere. We enjoyed live music and a tremendous dinner. Would recommend Asti’s to anyone. The owner is awesome!“

“we were there last Thursday to celebrate my birthday and also my bfs as they are on the same day. we heard nothing but good things. Pasta was cold, filet not prepared correctly then given back to me burnt on the outside and raw on the inside. We were so very disappointed. $200 wasted and I walked away hungry. Really don't think we would ever try again. On to another top restaurant in the city.“

“Food was excellent. Service was very pleasant and welcoming.“

“Great family-owned business with amazing homemade food!“

“Had a wonderful experience today at Roman Bistro. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Our waiter David was terrific. I chose the perfect restaurant for my birthday lunch.“

“We recently held my parents 50th wedding anniversary party there and it was wonderful! Everyone I dealt with, from the event coordinator, kitchen staff, and wait staff, were incredibly kind and went above and beyond to make our event a special one. I would definitely recommend Rene’s in the future.“

“Fantastic food ,great service..
If you haven't supported this local family owned restaurant yet you are missing out !
The menu is amazing.. thank you Joe our bartender for the great service. Catch you next time Bobby. We dined in and took a huge order home .. DELICIOUS 😋
Jimmy,
Greater Pitt Tree Service 🌳“

“Food is absolutely delicious and the staff is so nice, kind and helpful.“

“Friends and I enjoyed dinner at Tillie's last night and it was a great evening. Of course, the company was great but the food was also great. And, our server was a joy. She was pleasant, attentive and did a good job. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for great food and excellent service. Thanks!!!“

“I had my son’s graduation dinner here in their party room!! EVERYTHING was perfect!! Stephanie the event planner was awesome and the staff is great!! The food was OUTSTANDING 😋😋 I can’t recommend this place enough ❤️🫶🏽“

“I do not even know where to start! From the server(Dominic) who was friendly, always right there and check on our table periodically making sure we always had what we needed! the drinks, the food, the dessert, everything was a 10/10. The sauce was the best I ever had. This place is a must! It is beautiful, clean, and welcoming inside with a sense of family and friends. The host was lovely, and friendly. You can tell the owner cherishes this place,he was hands on the entire time I was there.“

“Best restaurants I ever eat we are customer's over 28 years“

“Visited this morning for the first time. Got egg and cheese sandwiches, one croissant one ciabatta - both were amazing!! The lattes were delicious and rich. You can really taste the quality of the espresso. They were short staffed (1 employee who was grinding hard!) so I did wait about 25 minutes for two coffees and sandwiches. I didn’t mind that much and it was well worth the wait. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Made reservations; had to wait a bit to be noticed at entrance. Not very busy on a Tuesday evening. Would go back for delicious food, but waitress rushed us at every course. Zucchini app was served fast. Wine cork fee $5. Dinner salad was very small, but dinners; veal Marsala & chicken piccata was generous & delicious. Seemed there was a staffing shortage, waitress was catering to party of 12 celebrating a bday. Had to practically beg for a dessert & coffee. I asked for a coffee refill; waitress replied do you want to wait on a new pot as she took my cup & saucer from me. for @ 20 patrons in restaurant it was noisy. Family atmosphere with white table clothed tables. Good parking. Would go back for food, hoping not getting same rude waitress.“

“We have been dining here for 35 years! Sadly, Les and Pauline have passed, but Edmund is continuing the excellence. Just visited for our daughter's birthday and it was perfect. The crab hoelzel and mafalda are delicious appetizers. Chicken parm is unique and yummy,ditto for the lobster Romano. We often disappointed with pricy meals, but never here. It is old school, so not for everyone, but we love it.“

“Delicious, fresh homemade food. The food a service was out of this world! Highly recommend.“

“We love it here! Best prices in the area and most definitely the BEST bartenders EVERRRRRRR ❤️“

“Great service - Great food“

“This was our first time coming here and my family was pleasantly surprised! Our server was nice and everyone’s food was really good! It was fresh and homemade and we will definitely make a trip back coming from Somerset County.“

“Such a nice quiet hospitable place to dine in. Food was top tier!! I will be returning with friends!“

“We dined there for the first time this week. We told our waitress, Katie, that we had never been and she went above and beyond to give us an amazing experience. Our drinks were constantly refilled and the appetizer hot pepper cheese balls were delicious. She recommended the cheese bread sticks (they were so good!) and we thought the pizza (pepperoni sausage mushrooms) was outstanding. Thank you Katie for being so attentive. We will definitely be back Shelly Pie!“

“One of the few good pizza spots in Pittsburgh!“

“We just had a great meal at mama meatballs pizzeria. The owner and his family were great and the pie is a contender for the best pizza in the east Pittsburgh area. Everything but the salad was homemade.“

“We had a Great Experience at Corleones! Ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, Chicken Parm, and pizza. All was delicious and the service was fantastic!!! I will definitely be back! Our new favorite restaurant. Will recommend to family and friends!!“

“No flowery words needed. It's a bar where people actually TALK to one another. Conversation. No constant texting. This place is a gem for humans who want to relate and connect. The bar is Eden to the nth degree.. I'm not a foodie. Although the cuisine here is beyond delicious. But the attraction? It's the forgotten joy of human contact. Don't miss happy hour.“

“the slaughter house 5 with red onion,😁 sausage pizza 😁 the Italian stallion calzone just awesome and a great price.😁 the home made Ranch dressing 😁“

“Today’s order was exceptional. It had been a minute since I ordered from here as usually my order was messed up etc. today I was craving one of their chicken salads so I decided to get that and a pizza for my kids. Both items were amazing and perfect! I understand this place is under new ownership. The manager/owner even brought the food to my car and chit chatted with me a bit. 10/10 customer service. This makes a big difference.“

“I booked their banquet room for a combo birthday party for my daughter and husband and everything was great!!! They let us show up hours early to decorate and the food was amazing. The best part was our server/bartender though. She was so busy taking care of the whole party and never once looked overwhelmed or flustered. She made the party so much easier on me and let me focus on my daughter and family and friends. Thanks Moonlite!“

“Got subs for my wife and myself and we both were amazed. Great value and fantastic flavor. We will be back for sure.“

“This is a great addition to the Southside. We had a delicious dinner - meatballs, burrata, pizza, and tiramisu - and the service was absolutely amazing. Jamie was one of the best servers we’ve ever had. We will be back!“

“The meal was great, we ate at the bar and our server slash bartender was fantastic. The missing star is the fault of tonight's management, who completely failed to keep an eye on the condition of the men's room, which needed about a ten minute spruce up halfway through the evening.“

“Highly recommend this Olive Garden for a casual family dinner! Everything about our visit was wonderful:
The Food: Absolutely delicious and perfectly prepared.
The Service: Fast, welcoming, and our server went above and beyond to ensure we had a great experience.
The Convenience: Great location on Green Tree Road with ample parking.
It is a fantastic place to eat, and we will definitely be returning!“

“Anna and her staff were exceptional . The night before sister’s wedding there had been an accident to the front of the building. All was cleaned and ready for a great night. Staff, food and venue were excellent and I would recommend highly to anyone in need of a venue.“

“Great food and service. Portions were perfect.“

“First time eating Bellisario Pizza. We ordered a regular pizza with peporini and ricotta, a white pizza half jalapeños, half peppers, onion and a steak roll. The service was quick and the vibe is old school but most importantly the food was awesome! 10/10 all around. Looking forward to coming back and trying some other things. Add this place to your favorites list.“

“we've come every so often ever since i was little, but we need to make this place a priority because WOW!

the atmosphere is pretty, lights and pictures everywhere
host and waiters are friendly
the food is the best of all! the wedding soup is just a tad salty but they don't use shredded chicken which i personally love. the garlic bread is some of the best ive ever had and their cheese ravioli is also very good! i wholeheartedly recommend!“

“KATIE MY ONE OF THEE BEST GRILLED CHICKEN SALADS I HAVE HAD IN A LOOOONNNNG TIME !!! DEFINITELY WILL RETURN !!! THANK YOU KATIE ! I just called and thanked you personally!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ highly recommended!“

“I decided to purchase the family Thanksgiving to go meal this year and am so thrilled I did. We picked up at 10 and everything was ready to go and so well organized. Reheating instructions were included and everything was nicely packaged. The food was absolutely delicious!! The turkey was fall off the bone moist and tender. I highly recommend this Thanksgiving meal and look forward to purchasing again next year!!!“

“Try the Chicken parm family meal deal .. you won't be disappointed!!“

“Great breakfast lunch and dinner everythings homemade fresh right in front of you.. great prices great portions and a great vibes...“

“My childhood and all-time favorite Italian restaurant. It's a must visit every possible time I'm back in Pittsburgh. They have come along way since being next to a laundry-mat, but the food is exactly how I remember it. Special recommendation for the chicken parm... this restaurant is the standard that I go by. They also sell their sauce at Giant Eagle where I live now, and it tastes just like the sauce from the store (with a little extra fresh parsley, that is).“

“The food is amazing and affordable, service is awesome ❣️ delivery was on time food temp was perfect my hoagie was warm and my cheesecake was perfectly chill😋 one day I will have to dine in.... Thanks to all involved with my order ❣️ sorry no photo no time for that lol....“

“Al's has a great, extensive menu sure to have something to suit everyone. Their portions are nothing short of incredible for the price, and the service is excellent.

I'm sure they have busy times, but we've never had trouble getting a table for small or medium-sized groups.“