Pizza Restaurants near West Liberty

“READ THIS! My Mom who lives in Wheeling, WV, told me there is NO Domino's that deliver to her home. A few weeks ago, I had a few extra garlic parmesan bread twists from my Domino's order & gave her a few to try. She LOVED THEM! Sadly, she needs surgery & CAN NOT drive till she gets it, 30+ days away. So I figured I'd go on a secret mission. Trying to find the closest Domino's to her address, I found 4 of them. I called EACH store individually to see who delivers to her area. Plus, you need to understand I AM NOT familiar with Wheeling's surrounding street names, so it got kinda chaotic. I'm trying to surprise my Mom, in Wv, while I'm in Pa, with an order to mix up her daily menu. She CAN'T drive to the store to get groceries, house supplies, & etc, now you see my point here. Anyways, the first 2 Wheeling stores I called WERE NOT very helpful NOR seemed too eager to get me any info. I kept going down the line... Then I called the "Route 88 & North Fork, West Liberty, WV" location... The night manager, I think she said her name was Nicole, but... she was a BIG HELP. She also wasn't familiar with the streets so she asked her driver for help. Then asked for the order & said let's put the order in & see if computer takes it... And WOW it went thru. She WENT OVER & ABOVE what she had to do to get a whopping $15 order, lol. The end result? My Mom got her bread twists & loved'em! AND THE BEST/FUNNY part? She's lived in WV for say 10 years now.. and NEVER ordered pizza bc she thought they didn't deliver to her area. I requested menus, so she can FINALLY get pizza delivered to her house.P. S. Driver told her that they DO deliver there all the time. Ha! Ha! Go figure?!?!“

“Thank you Fabio’s for making my husband’s favorite pizza by request!“

“Everytime im in town im stopping here for pizza! Sauce is right, crust is tender crispy and service on point each time. Thx yall. Stopped in before my comedy show started i dont eat pork but that had all options for me. Ordered chicken Parmigiano sub and they hooked it up baby listen“

“Great Pizza“

“The food is always amazing and delicious!“

“order #86 My chicken club salad wasn't with my order when delivered and the driver said I had to call store and was very short after I tipped him. When I called to speak with a manager she was very rude to me and blamed the new girl. after my quality of food and bad customer service I didn't want a credit, I wanted my money back for the 10 salad. She then got smart with me and hung up. I will never order again and will recommend everyone else to do the same.“

“I was visiting my daughter today at OSU & happened to walk by this pizza shop! The same pizza shop “Di Carlo’s” that I ate as a child when visiting my grandparents in Wintersville. Was curious to see if anything had changed over 30+ years and it was exactly how I remembered, even better! Everything fresh & the crispy crust is so Delicious!!!
Got it as a take & bake since I had a 2 hour drive with it.
Thanks Nick !
I’ll be back for sure!“

“Awesome place good food and friendly people. We like supporting the small home made food places and this one was great. We were heading home to Texas and stopped in.“

“First time getting pizza here, and we'll definitely be back. Excellent pie, tasty toppings, but the sauce is stellar. Highly recommend you try Pizza Villa!“

“I’ve been a customer for many years : even after I moved to FL and would return for a visit . Night before I flew out I would order an entire pan , freeze in ziplocks and my sons looked forward to it as well. They don’t have anything like it in FL.“

“Love the pizza and community involvement!“

“Great pepperoni rolls and pizza“

“Only had pizza here about 6 times since the new bridge opened. Never had a bad slice of pizza. Paul that works there is really a friendly guy along with other workers. The hours are perfect don’t know why other shops close at 8 or 9 o’clock. The later hours get my business.“

“picked up a taco pizza tonight at the Martins Ferry location. it was superb per usual!!! thank you girls!!!“

“Love Paula's pizza shop I dont live around there warwood location but I will go to her Bridgeport location she definitely knows how to make things good no other like it. Always friendly an understanding of what people want I'd definitely recommend her pizza an best wings in the valley.“

“I absolutely love the pizza here and I think it’s the best around YTR. Really disappointing that you all stopped delivering to Dillonvale- 5 minutes from the shop. You should offer door dash delivery if you aren’t willing to deliver.“

“The Wheeling Pizza Hut Has Great Pizza Always Constantly Very Great!! but They Always save The Day!! Last Night They saved The Day!! Thank GOD!! - Thank You Pizza Hut Team!!! ****** Thank You Kerri A Harvey Tridelphia WV *****!!!“

“Great food, service and a cool atmosphere. I like how the bar area is separate from the dining area. The patio was nice too. With many TVs, it's a good place to watch sports. The menu had a plethora of choices from pizza, pub grub, seafood, many salad choices (I recommend the basil vinaigrette) and great steaks! Definitely my new go to spot when visiting Wheeling.“

“Foods always yummy and the staff are great!“

“I stopped in on 9/27/2025 in the afternoon. I don’t remember the gentleman’s name and I threw my receipt away but he was very nice and great. The food and service was amazing. I ordered a couple of pizzas and the Philly cheesesteak puffs. The pretzel crust pizza has become my new favorite and the puffs were kick ass.

Thank you for such great service you guys rock“

“Love this place! Great people“

“There was a mixup while ordering through the app and they made it right at no cost to me AND were very nice about it! That’s good business. 👍🏻“

“The team at this location was a huge help during a past recruiting event of mine. They made sure my order was correct, ready on time, and even assisted with processing my tax exemption without any issues. The food was fresh and exactly what I needed to feed my hungry applicants. The staff's efforts made the whole process smooth and I appreciate their support and attention to detail.“

“Another great experience! Love the food and atmosphere!“

“Was looking for a coffee place still open at 8:30pm that wasn't McDonald's, Starbucks, etc. On the the way home from a road trip and craving a frappé. Their house mocha frappé is delicious and good size for only $4! Will be back when in the area!“

“their breakfast on the weekends“