8 Best Italian Restaurants near Williamstown

“Amazing food and amazing service! The owner was so kind and thoughtful, and the entire staff was friendly and accommodating! We will definitely be back!“

“We had a FANTASTIC waitress (Mara)! She was so sweet, friendly, enthusiastic, and knowledgeable. We had the lasagna frita as an appetizer, it was delicious! I'd honestly get it as a meal. Mara was so on top of things, our drinks were never less than half full, she made comments and suggestions, just a fantastic waitress!“

“Waygu burger last night was the best! Love the staff.“

“The agency I work for hosts seminars at Colombo’s several times a year. We absolutely love it! Out of the dozen+ restaurants we’ve used for seminars, this one is truly a well-oiled machine. Not only is their food delicious, but their customer service is top tier. Our party sizes range from 20-40 people, and they handle it like pros every single time. Although I live an hour and 1/2 from Parkersburg, Colombo’s was still my choice for Valentine’s Day dinner. Can’t say enough good things about this place 😃“

“Our first time visiting this amazing local restaurant. Unfortunately, they were out of lasagna. But, the chicken alfredo, which was recommended, was literally the best that I’ve ever had! 10/10!!! We will be back!“

“First time eating here today. Stopped by on a weekend trip to Parkersburg. We stopped in and ordered to go. All employees were friendly and very helpful. Food was received quickly, and everything tasted great. Would definitely consider ordering again whenever we are back in this area.“

“I went in skeptical to be honest, based on some of the prices. But I can tell you it is 100% worth the prices. The sandwiches are unrivaled as far as freshness flavor in the amount of actual meat that you get in them I’ve never ordered before I had I known I probably would not have ordered as much as I did, but I was kind of expecting these to be small and disappointing, but they were mind blowing and delicious..

Ordered for delivery driver was so nice. The entire experience was pleasant. They do have to call to confirm your order which was perfectly fine by me. They extremely courteous on the phone and the entire process was seamless.

I can’t say for 100% certain but I do think that even the bread for the sandwiches is fresh made. It had that homemade bread texture outside crunch inside softness. Unbelievable highly recommend it if you are looking for the best sandwich you’re going to find in the area .

Pizza a little greasy for me personally but the flavors are great. The sauce is nice it’s not overly acidic and it’s not overly sweet. It’s about the perfect balance you want in a pizza sauce and they don’t skimp on the cheese. Other cheese is delicious. I would probably honestly order it again but the not just the edge but like the underneath is all greasy and it’s just too much for my stomach to handle honestly, everybody else in the house loves it.

Mozzarella sticks are average exactly what you’d expect from any other place that you order from they arrived hot fresh crispy on the outside, melted cheese on the inside. Nothing overly exciting but not disappointing either.“

“Whatever you get, it's always good. Pizza is great, but subs are all good, too.“