12 Best Italian Restaurants near Wheeling

“Amazing Food, Service, and Atmosphere. I asked my girlfriend to marry me and they were so helpful :) I called ahead of time and talk to the owner, Dino. He set aside his best table and made sure his best server, Nicole, took care of all our needs. Then I talked to the dessert chef and she did the rest :) They help make a great memory :) In today's world it is tough to fine such a gold mine. They treat you like family and the food is too die for :) I strongly recommend you also purchase a jar of their world famous spaghetti sauce :)“

“Thank you Fabio’s for making my husband’s favorite pizza by request!“

“Had the pleasure of meeting with Alisha (Or Eliza) can't remember her name, but she was extremely nice to us. Even though we just wanted a coffee, she brewed if for us and was very courteous.Absolutely 100% recommend this place, they got great customer service.And of course, the coffee was excellent as well.Can't comment on anything else, as I didn't use anything else.“

“Love love their food has always been good, used to go every year for family reunions and now I continue to go with me and my husband.“

“Great buffet and delicious pizza!! The chocolate chip dessert pizza is like no other. It’s a must. Love their pepperoni rolls too. Please continue to support this local business so we can all continue to enjoy the delicious dessert pizza!!!!!“

“We had a birthday dinner at The Farm yesterday. The food :buffalo bleu chicken, prime rib, Italian chicken breast, pork, asparagus, salads, homemade noodles, mashed potatoes , and everything else was delicious. The staff were all friendly, helpful, and accommodating. The whole atmosphere is just wonderful! I’ve been here many times and wanted to do a review. Definitely recommend this exceptional restaurant!!!!“

“Love love their food has always been good, used to go every year for family reunions and now I continue to go with me and my husband.“

“I had a heavenly experience at the Olive Garden in Wheeling. I always have a good time when I go but this time was a total experience. Every single staff with whom I interacted was so nice and helpful it blew me away. My waitress, Kira, was pheomenal. She was warm and welcoming, and made me and the group I was with feel like part of her family. She was also just a great waitress overall - very attentive, funny, and detailed. She contintued to get my group water (and chocolates!) even after we had paid the bill and were just sitting and chatting after our meal. Chris the manager also stopped by our table, he was super nice as well and made us feel very welcome. 100/10 recommend, and if you go, ask for Kira!“

“I am soooo glad to see this place is still around. My Mom and Dad "Butch and Nancy Prisner" used to go there every year for their anniversary. I ate there as a child and have awesome memories of this place along with Gullas.“

“Called in my order of Chicago style deep dish. Picked it up 45 minutes later. The staff was very inviting and helpful. The restaurant was very clean and the kitchen was wide open to see the whole pizza process. I got the pizza home about ten minutes later and the pizza maintained temperature very nicely. I and my family absolutely loved it. My very picky son said “can we only get this pizza from now on”. I assured him we would. My family highly recommends.“

“We stopped down after a wrestling match because we were far from home. The food was amazing and good selection. The prices were great as well. The two women working there were so sweet. If we are ever in the area again we would for sure visit again!“

“Purchased 10 large pizzas with only 1- hour notice. Since it was before PJ’s opened, I ordered online with option to select desired pick up time. Worked fantastic!! Forget the big chain pizza joints, come to PJ’s. I pulled into the parking area and they even brought my pizzas out 5 minutes before my scheduled request time. All good. Will definitely buy from again.“